Gramsci
IDF openly saying they bombed the refugee camp to try and kill one person - clip from CNN
2mins in
Been watching this. Curious to see what Barnaby Raine says. Barnaby is 110 % anti Zionist Jew.
The section starting at 37.41 features discusssion about the Liverpool street protest.
The Centre / Right/ NGOS criticised it for not making London not feel safe for Jews.
Martin walker pointed out one banner said Jews against Genocide. So some Jews did feel safe at protest.
A lot of the opposition from the centre and right is done in the language of multiculturalism where these protests are making some people not feel "safe"
Its worth watching Barnaby. Talks a hundred miles an hour and put a case as a Jew that the real Jewish tradition is defending Universal values not the nation state values of Zionism
Will try attempt here to summarise his views. The guy is so bright and fast Im sure to get a bit wrong.
It cuts to the Jewish experience of being treated as an "Other" whatever society they live in.
For him the rise of Zionism was retrograde step for Jews. And continues to be one.
For him the Jewish historical experience in Europe was centuries of being treated as the "Other" . That it was against Jewish Europeans that racist language was honed. This language later being used against people colonised by European Empires.
So I take it he is saying anti semitism was pre cursor to the anti black racism that supported Empire.
A reaction to that was that the Jewish history gave Jews experience to oppose all form of "othering" and to support transcending this for universal freedom
He says:
Do not mistrust a stranger , for you once were a stranger in a strange land"
So in the case of the Liverpool street protest this analysis means its obvious Jews would turn up to support Palestinians. Who are subject to othering and Colonialism.
On Zionism historically - he say its an attempt for Jews to enter Whiteness. From being part of the coalition of the losers to the winners. Herzl was in his view once an assimulationist then deciding that the only way for Jews to become good Europeans was to leave Europe and become successful colonists.
That is try to join the club of racist European imperialism - enter whiteness and have a nation state.
He argues that the Jewish experience of oppression can also lead ( not to aping Whiteness in form of own colonial movement- Zionism) but to yearn for universal freedom.
He puts forward best argument I've seen from a Jewish point of view to oppose Zionism and support Palestinians.
And more profoundly that the Jewish experience is and can be progressive not just for Jews but for the ultimate liberation of all people.
To add imo what he is talking about is the foundations for solidarity rather than freedom narrowed down to a nationalist state. Which only gives freedom to a section at expense of others.
Universal Freedom is what he is talking about.