Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Bitcoin discussion and news

Imagine a world in which all transactions were performed via bitcoin. Would it be possible to verify any financial records whatsoever? I don't think it would.

What would the consequences be of not being able to verify any financial records? Ever worked in any kind of audit role? Tax? Financial forensics of any kind?
 
Bitcoin is becoming a lot more heavily monitored these days - the exchanges are for instance requesting verifiable ID. I'm not sure how it would be possible to cash out a lot of BC without attracting attention - or accepting an uncompetitive rate in exchange for suitcase cash (in which case it's only illegal vendors who'd bother). So it is a tax issue for illegal vendors, but they don't pay tax anyway.

Perhaps the 'traditional' exchanges are requesting ID - but decentralised exchanges are now popping up. Localbitcoins for instance put sellers and buyers directly in touch with each other. The site offers an escrow service, along with user comments to reduce risk of being ripped off.
 
Bitcoin transactions aren't actually that anonymous. It is possible to work out who is paying what to whom if you really wanted to.
 
Bitcoin transactions aren't actually that anonymous. It is possible to work out who is paying what to whom if you really wanted to.

I assume law enforcement would really want to trace transactions. Do you know if any drug dealers have been traced and busted from transactions in Bitcoins?
 
I don't know. I think the law enforcement usually start by finding drugs and then work back from there to try and seize assets. I don't think they ever start by looking for transactions.

The situation in the US is pretty unbelievable. If you get caught with any drugs in sellable quantities, they rob you of all your assets.
 
It is tempting to buy more as an investment! I tend to keep around £100 worth which has already given a few 'dividends'.

Their value has risen around 20% in the last 5 days (and making the post above). The bubble has to burst soon.

Naturally I'll put the unearned income on my tax return.
 
You can make up to a certain amount on currency transactions without notifying the tax man. The bubble may burst, but seeing as most people buy in then out quickly, the asset value of bitcoin is less important than it's function in transactions.
 
Yeah - it's interesting.

The market seems to be affected by two main factors. Speculators buying it - which is making them scarce. And SR buyers needing them for transactions, providing some liquidity. Also the gambling thing is starting to take off, and that will be huge in the US.

It is a bubble, but I wonder if it has a fair amount of room to grow yet.
 
I don't see how it can be a bubble where it's getting harder and harder to generate new coins*, so supply should stay below demand. SR and gambling are increasing more and more, and there's a few legitimate websites taking them as payment now (although this will be a fraction of the total transactions).

*I read that people are manufacturing special chips which are optimised for mining. :hmm:
 
It could burst by someone inventing a better system next year, or problems with the technology.
 
I don't see how it can be a bubble where it's getting harder and harder to generate new coins*, so supply should stay below demand. SR and gambling are increasing more and more, and there's a few legitimate websites taking them as payment now (although this will be a fraction of the total transactions).

*I read that people are manufacturing special chips which are optimised for mining. :hmm:

Just because there are a maximum limit of 21 million coins, each coin can be divided up to 8 decimal places. So if the btc becomes ever more expensive, they just get divided up into ever smaller pieces.
 
It could burst by someone inventing a better system next year, or problems with the technology.


The only way you could cause problems with bitcoins is have more hooky clients than there are standard ones.
 
Any bitcoin competitor might well fork the blockchain too, rather than creating a new genesis block.
 
Just because there are a maximum limit of 21 million coins, each coin can be divided up to 8 decimal places. So if the btc becomes ever more expensive, they just get divided up into ever smaller pieces.

That doesn't affect the number of bitcoins in circulation. It just makes them more practical to use.
 
One of the recurring features of all bubbles is that they all say that this time it's different and the sky really is the limit this time.
 
Tax dodging might not seem so unethical if you were a Cypriot of Italian pensioner right now. Especially as the corporations, sitting on record cash reserves, aren't even remotely threatened by these taxes. I wouldn't begrudge them moving their life savings out of the accessible banks.

The irony being that if they converted their savings into shares of the bank they would also be untouched.
 
I caught the first bump, but missed most of this one. Buying in late again now, just in time for the bubble to burst :D
 
Could Bitcoin become a viable alternative to PayPal in anyone's opinion? If so, would it be essentially be costless for me to say, pay someone via Bitcoin in another country for something purchased online? Obviously, this is already happening on sites like the Silk Road but what I'm asking is if Bitcoin has the potential to supplant something like PayPal in mainstream eCommerce.
 
Yes it *is* a costless way to pay someone in another country. I think that Silk Road will soon become a very minor element of it, and transfering funds from country to country will be the mainstay. I can imagine foreign workers sending money home without banks taking a % cut will be a big part of the appeal in the next year or so.
 
I suppose that in order for it to be useful to accept payments in Bitcoin if you were looking for an alternative to PayPal, would be the ease with which you could extract the value in Bitcoins back to your local currency and this could be the area where costs would be incurred.
 
Yes it *is* a costless way to pay someone in another country. I think that Silk Road will soon become a very minor element of it, and transfering funds from country to country will be the mainstay. I can imagine foreign workers sending money home without banks taking a % cut will be a big part of the appeal in the next year or so.
Well it's not really costless.
Mtgox takes a cut when you change it. Then your chosen banker takes a cut when you take the cash out to your account.
Cheaper than western union.
 
A quick divert to Silk Road if I may...wiki says you can buy 'writing services' there. What sort of thing? Cheat on your homework?
 
I can't be doing with SR, I don't care about TOR (absolute pain in the backside to use), it's way too in the open and bitcoins are a headache to deal with IMO.

A quick divert to Silk Road if I may...wiki says you can buy 'writing services' there. What sort of thing? Cheat on your homework?

here's one I found

Ask yourself: Do you trust someone whose listings on Silk Road are rife with grammar mistakes, slang, and misspellings to write a paper with your name on it? Do you even trust them to write it at all, or do you admit it's entirely possible they send you something that has already been turned in?

After all, this will have your name on it. If it's quality you're in search of, look no further.

I have been writing and editing papers for others for many years now and after long deliberation have decided to offer my services to students on Silk Road. I have been an English teacher for years and I know what professors want to see.

I am fully capable of writing high school essays to theses for Master's degrees and dissertations for your Ph.D. I am well-versed in using MLA, APA, Turabian and Chicago citations, and make sure you include any specific directions your teacher has given you.

Regardless of the topic area or educational level required, I can write a great paper for you. All I need from you are directions from your teacher. This includes:

- The number of pages (this is the item quantity)
- The topic area, if I am not allowed to choose
- Any citation requirements
- Any other special requirements given, such as within your syllabus

Sounds great, I've an MSc dissertation to hand in in Sept on a really technical subject that I'm sure an English Teacher would be brilliant for.
 
Well it's not really costless.
Mtgox takes a cut when you change it. Then your chosen banker takes a cut when you take the cash out to your account.
Cheaper than western union.
The transfer is cost free.

The transaction fee when converting from other currencies there is a cost and at the moment the exchange rate is very volatile, so holding capital in btc in a business context is tricky. I think in the future when the rate stabilizes, there will be the less need to transact in and out, minimising this expense.
 
Back
Top Bottom