Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

The Ashes 2010/11

A tweak to the review system. There are three decisions: out, not out, and umpire's decision. If it comes down to umpire's decision, the team appealing should not lose one of their referrals.
 
A tweak to the review system. There are three decisions: out, not out, and umpire's decision. If it comes down to umpire's decision, the team appealing should not lose one of their referrals.

Consistent in itself, but not necessarily in keeping with the spirit of the system, which is to get rid of absolute howlers rather than ensure every marginal LBW is correctly called.
 
But if it is a marginal lbw, it's not a bad decision to refer it, yet you lose another referral. I agree that, as with that one, where it's shown just to be skimming the stumps, it should be left as umpire's decision. I just don't think the side referring should be penalised.

I've thought this before, btw. It's not just sour grapes.
 
Hmm.. after listening to the first hour's play last night, I am not unhappy with limiting the Aussies to 220-5. Add two wickets to that and the honours are even. Seemed that Anderson did his usual misfire session early on where he just can't get his length right. Good to hear that Finn is showing the kind of potential we have hoped for on Australian wickets, bowling quickish line and length from a great height.

The 4 bowler attack is looking a bit fragile. Especially with Swann not finding his lengths. However the non-performing batsmen are all indispensable! All the batsmen who needed a score got one, or at least half of one.

But if it is a marginal lbw, it's not a bad decision to refer it, yet you lose another referral. I agree that, as with that one, where it's shown just to be skimming the stumps, it should be left as umpire's decision. I just don't think the side referring should be penalised.

I've thought this before, btw. It's not just sour grapes.

Naah.. the referrals slow down the game enough. I don't want more slow downs.
 
I'm not too unhappy either. A few of the aussie batsmen showed they're still struggling for form and confidence - that allied to the ropey bowling of Johnson in our first innings i think means we're going to have a pretty close series. They were always going to after Swann after we decided on a 4 man attack - and he'd got on top of his length by the end.
 
The current state of the match is still very much within the margin of luck, which is a phrase I have just invented.
 
two good sessions tomorrow could see us in the driving seat and 100+ runs ahead. it's going to be a very important day though, and if we let australia put another 150 runs on, we're going to find it extremely tough. setting them anything over 200/250 in the fourth innings is going to be hard for them to chase.
 
Getting them all out for under 300 and recouping those 40 runs without loss is the key. If we do that, then we have an excellent chance. I think getting them out for under 300 will also give confidence to our batsmen, who can feel they were no way second best.
 
The current state of the match is still very much within the margin of luck, which is a phrase I have just invented.

and a very good phrase it is too.we have 220/5,40 runs behind,thats fuck all in the big picture:cool:.2 days down,3 to go.We need another 150-200,gettable but not likely.You should be batting before tea then you should be out before lunch on the 4th day:DWe will get the runs before lunch on the 5th.:D":DPuts crystal ball away again"
 
This is actually a very finely balanced match, and if we get Hussey out quickly the pendulum swings back England's way
 
It is finely balanced, but I would not say the pendulum's swung back to England until they have a lead with lots of wickets in hand.
 
Did someone on this thread or elsewhere say you can get a short-term sky sports subscription for the iPhone?
 
I found a very reliable stream.

crictime.com

The first day, it connected me to the Aussie broadcast with no adverts – it just went to a widescreen view each time the ads were on, which was great.

The second day, it connected me to the Indian broadcast with the Aussie commentators. Lots of really tacky Indian ads, which is less great. But both days it was continuous coverage. And you get to hear Richie Benaud every now and then. :cool:
 
i know i said it before, but if you're not watching it (or if you want to watch it with radio commentary over the top), then i really do recommend test match sofa. it pisses all over test match special.
 
get the vision from 9 but the commentary from o'feefe,maxwell and co on abc.Great broadcast,just thought i would listen to those cunts slagging us off.glad Huss finally made a few,his head is/was on the block imo,love to see him get a ton+.North needs to make a few too,but aussies generally give batsmen time to regain form,pity spinners dont fare as well
 
Back
Top Bottom