What's most concerning, to me at least, about the events of last night is the complete absence of any serious intervention by the Left.
Should Antifa defend government buildings?What's most concerning, to me at least, about the events of last night is the complete absence of any serious intervention by the Left.
I think it's generally true, yes. If you want to change things meaningfully, you'll always be up against a chunk of the population that likes things as they are. Can you think of a place where this isn't true?
They should at least be first when the arsenals are stormedShould Antifa defend government buildings?
If there were “counter protestors” in dc yesterday (which surely must have been after all the hype for that rally ?) maybe they were stopped at the outer perimeter fence by uniforms. Pure speculation obvs.Should Antifa defend government buildings?
I've read this several times now and still dont understand this tbh. What does this mean in practice aside from writing off the swathes of w/class voters who voted Republican?It's an alternative way of framing the question. To focus on the 70 million and ask how you win them over is a strange way of framing it to me. The answer to the question is that you can't win most of those 70 million over. The more important question for Democrats is how do you keep the 80 million you have.
Tbh, I wouldn't call riots a "strategy" exactly, but I would have thought that the social forces that were expressed over the summer seem like the best available starting point for a forceful, pro working class politics directly counter posed to Trumpism and Biden. And certainly like the most obvious alternative pole of attraction, if not for Republican voters, then at least for very discontented people who might otherwise find themselves drawn to the Qanon crowd, or for whatever comes next after Qanonism.Seriously? That’s your strategy to peel 70 million people away?
I’ll just say this, in the absence of positive utopias people will continue to retreat into reactionary ones especially in a period where there are successive capitalist crises and elite liberals offer no alternative.
Most of those hand wringing now about "fascism" have spent the last decade undermining any moderately left-wing alternative and striving to restore the status quo - providing fertile ground for the Trump and others of a similar ilk.
Only a forceful, pro working class politics directly counter posed to Trumpism and Biden provide an alternative, without it yesterday may well be opening salvo of a very dark decade to come.
But you carry on...
Well everyone who broke into the building were definitely loons. How many of them were there, I'm not sure? And the election has still got called for Biden as expected.This is why i'm increasingly convinced its a good thing that this happened, the it could never happen here its all just a joke or a few loons on the internet in their underpants lot are quiet now.
Yes I really don't see how a load of counter protestors turning up last night would have helped anything. It would have muddied the reporting. This way there is no way it can be reported any other way apart from "trump protestors violently oppose democracy" (apart from by crazy people who were never going to report any other way apart from crazy)Should Antifa defend government buildings?
It was really cringey yesterday on CNN when they were invoking George w Bush as the voice of reason and indeed of law. The one who was so fantastic on election night with the numbers, John King, said something like "say what you like about George W Bush, and he had his own problems, he had his problems in Iraq and a lot of people didn't always agree with him and the way he dealt with it, but he always had the utmost respect for the institutions of government, for the Constitution. "
And I thought - the problems he had in Iraq by invading unilaterally and against the will of that feeble but supposedly important international institution, the UN? Pathetic. Reminded who these cunts really are.
It doesn't take into account the many and varied reasons that prompted 70 million to vote for Trump. Loads of votes would have come via protectionism and consequent revitalising of previously doomed (by globalisation) industries.I've read this several times now and still dont understand this tbh. What does this mean in practice aside from writing off the swathes of w/class voters who voted Republican?
Don’t think just calling them all loons makes much sense tbh. On what basis are you saying that?Well everyone who broke into the building were definitely loons. How many of them were there, I'm not sure? And the election has still got called for Biden as expected.
Should Antifa defend government buildings?
This is unfortunately the most troubling legacy of all this. I sadly couldn't agree more.but the McVeighs will be stirred up by this. They’ll see the chink in the armour around the machine and dig away at that, chip chip chip. They’re not even interested in overturning government, not really. They just want to stand in conflict and create their own little worlds.
Right-wing nut jobs won't be getting their protests anywhere near the Capitol for quite some time.This is unfortunately the most troubling legacy of all this. I sadly couldn't agree more,
What a terrible sight seeing a Republican trying to steal an election.... And now to the voice of reason, W Bush, the Republican who successfully stole an electionIt was really cringey yesterday on CNN when they were invoking George w Bush as the voice of reason and indeed of law. The one who was so fantastic on election night with the numbers, John King, said something like "say what you like about George W Bush, and he had his own problems, he had his problems in Iraq and a lot of people didn't always agree with him and the way he dealt with it, but he always had the utmost respect for the institutions of government, for the Constitution. "
And I thought - the problems he had in Iraq by invading unilaterally and against the will of that feeble but supposedly important international institution, the UN? Pathetic. Reminded who these cunts really are.
But the "other" basket – the other basket – and I know because I look at this crowd I see friends from all over America here: I see friends from Florida and Georgia and South Carolina and Texas and – as well as, you know, New York and California – but that "other" basket of people are people who feel the government has let them down, the economy has let them down, nobody cares about them, nobody worries about what happens to their lives and their futures; and they're just desperate for change. It doesn't really even matter where it comes from. They don't buy everything he says, but – he seems to hold out some hope that their lives will be different. They won't wake up and see their jobs disappear, lose a kid to heroin, feel like they're in a dead-end. Those are people we have to understand and empathize with as well.
I think it is fair enough to call everyone who broke into congress loons. Just look at them.Don’t think just calling them all loons makes much sense tbh. On what basis are you saying that?
i don’t think you can doubt their sincerity now.
Hard to stop a lone wolf thoughRight-wing nut jobs won't be getting their protests anywhere near the Capitol for quite some time.
HahahaThen four years of Bidenfreude*, which could lead to ever greater disenchantment.
*thanks to Benjamin Kunkel.
It would be odd if there weren't attempts to assassinate Biden and Harris.Hard to stop a lone wolf though
I just saw this on twitter, and agree with it completely.