Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Urban v's the Commentariat

"after twenty years of simmering war of all against all, the army of the new republic launched the final offensive for the fourth time"
 
"after twenty years of simmering war of all against all, the army of the new republic launched the final offensive for the fourth time"

General-Melchett-520x245.jpg
 
I skimmed it when I saw he was going down some Wind Of Change gorky park bullshit to lend credence to his point. guardian keeps crashing my netbook, will you post the paragraph pls



Karl Marx was a gentle man, but his ideas would lead to human suffering almost unequalled in the history of the world. On the best current figures, about 6 million Russians were murdered in the era of Joseph Stalin – and that’s before you factor in the sufferings of eastern Europe from 1945 onwards, or the other revolutions from China to Cuba.

Today, the terrifying reality of Marxism in power has been consigned mercifully to the history books, but it has strange echoes. Clearly, Jeremy Corbyn is no Stalin, or Lenin, or Mao Zedong, just a long-serving British MP, but Marxist ideas live again in some spectral form in Corbyn’s runaway campaign and the enthusiasm of his supporters for a truly socialist Labour party. In one of the unspun answers that makes him appear authentic to supporters, Corbyn called Marx “a fascinating figure who observed a great deal and from whom we can learn a great deal”.

And:

I don’t think that after the fall of communism you can reject the capitalist economy root and branch or want to subject it to strong state control as Corbyn does. Markets are human, they have a powerfully creative side as well as a harsh unjust side, and to believe otherwise is to indulge in the same folly that killed the hapless peasants who Stalin labelled capitalist “kulaks” and saw fit to starve and shoot. The anti-market obsession that has overtaken the thinking left since Lehman Brothers is a treason by intellectuals whose hypocrisy is glaring. It’s like the old Monty Python gag. What has capitalism ever done for us – apart from the clothes, the food, the computers, the films, the pop music, and all the other stuff people swarmed the Berlin Wall 26 years ago to get their share of?

He even invokes the city named after Uncle Joe (and mis-spells 'Volgograd'):

In Russia I came across Marxism Today in a news kiosk in Vologograd – that is, Stalingrad. Of course! It had been funded by Moscow all along, like the entire Communist Party of Great Britain. So that too was compromised. And beside the vast silver emptiness of the Volga, the kulaks were nowhere to be found.
 
Anyway, the guardian has interviewed the head of hizb ut tahrir by one if their journalists who describes him as a mate and has some weird shrine to 'valued' isis fighters ffs
 
I am starting to really loathe that paper. They are not even fake socialists they've called for a vote for the lib dems ffs

I have more time for the FT and the Torygraph. At least their writers actually give you the straight up neoliberal establishment line without private school boys and girls telling off actual socialists by being like 'psst I was young and naive and didn't despise the most vulnerable in society once, just like you, but now it's time to grow up!'
 
they need to paint him so in order to reassure their blairite readership that corbyns mild social democratic spiel is hysterical.

Seems as though the Blairites are the hysterical ones. Hysterical at the thought of the Labour Party actually being socialist again.
 
I have more time for the FT and the Torygraph. At least their writers actually give you the straight up neoliberal establishment line without private school boys and girls telling off actual socialists by being like 'psst I was young and naive and didn't despise the most vulnerable in society once, just like you, but now it's time to grow up!'
toynbee and white, stamping on a human face forever etc
 
I can’t help thinking today’s bold neo-Marxist concepts like “the 1%” and “austerity” are equally unmoored from real lives. Indeed Greece has already found out what anti-austerity means in practice.

The cunt deserves a neck-shot for that alone.
I can’t help thinking...
Then try harder you shiterag.
He should come round our house and have a look at what "austerity" means when it's fucking "moored" itself in our "real lives".

Jonathan Jones your name shall also go on the list.
 
Last edited:
22% unemployment in the city I live in now and 25% youth unemployment in the town I was born in. Capitalism not exactly doing my family or friends many favours. Some social democracy wouldn't go amiss in either of those place.
He seems unable to compute anything outside of his own tiny sphere of existence. A bubble of journalists, the wealthy and the London restaurant scene. It was the same with museums the other week. Loads of people don't have 20 quid to take their family out to look at paintings.
 
White's analysis of Allende and Chile leaves much to be desired as you might imagine. Meanwhile, he has endorsed Jones.

 
Back
Top Bottom