Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Feminism- experiences of man-whispering and the refusal to do so...

I know darling :( it's so incredibly draggy and tiresome. But responding to it just gives them our attention, which is really what they're after. And it just really effectively derails the thread.

You’re right.

I’m sort of saying it for us, but /and also to support those who are reading along, who understand or / and those who are learning, open to suggestion.
 
It's also things like turning a man down in a way that doesn't invite violence. I learned this when I was 16 and at a club. Some bloke tried to chat me up, I politely but unsmilingly turned him down. He set my clothes on fire when my back was turned, in front of all his friends who did nothing to stop him. For example. I only remembered this after reading this thread - seemed pretty run of the mill at the time.

It is not the same thing as tiptoeing around your nearest and dearest. Not not not not not.

It was ok - I was furious af, put the fire out quickly and chased him and his friends out of the club, shrieking like a banshee, followed by some bouncers :D But even though it was a bit of a shock, it just seemed to be pretty standard behaviour. Which is the point really - on the whole I've been very lucky in my transactions with men: never been raped, rarely been sexually assaulted, got a good partner, turned invisible before dick pics and online sexual harassment became a thing. But I'd largely forgotten about being set alight because it was just one nasty event among so, so many.

It really boils my piss to see men equating this constant state of vigilance towards men's feelings, especially as very young women or even girls (actually roughly 12-16 is when you get the most unwanted male attention ime), with the negotiating that we all do (some to a greater extent than others, granted) in our relationships. It's not just the added risk of physical harm. It's that it is fucking constant, from everywhere, all the time, from the outwardly benign to the obviously threatening. It's even the fact that men feel entitled to your time when you're trying to get somewhere - when I was good mates with someone blonde and big breasted who liked to dress skimpily, it would take us forever to get from A to B, because we'd have to give numerous men the fucking time of day. And we would have to 'man whisper', because a straight up 'go away' would lead to such drama that it would take up even more of your time.

Tbh all these feminism threads just make me too angry and depressed to deal, and I take my hat off to all you women and men making brilliant and eloquent posts in the face of whataboutery, distraction techniques and just crap from posters who should know - and do - better.
YES polly. Fucking killing it. And I’m so sorry to hear you were set on fire for not accepting a man’s advances. JFC :facepalm: . My fucking god tho the lessons you learn to appease men who you turn down. Men in bars or clubs, men on dates, even in the online dating world. How quickly shit turns on a dime from compliments and looks, to sneering, insults or even threats if you turn them down. Fuck those men. Fuck their power.

It also goes beyond dating and flirting. When men hold the power, and make no mistake they often do, women are expected to ingratiate themselves. Let me tell you now, if your husband earns the money and your at home with the kids when they’re tiny, you best think twice before you challenge him too much or piss him off cos whose gonna pay the bills if he walks away. He’s out drinking again? Oh well men need to relax after work, better not complain too much, after all he’s earning the money. They’re HIS savings in HIS isa, HIS pension. Smile now, don’t nag.

And if the men on this thread don’t know how this shit works, and don’t think there’s loaded power games in play that make it qualitatively different to walking on eggshells then they clearly don’t have the faintest idea about the female experience.

As for those fucking creepy comments about PMT, I’m not even going there.
 
I’m honestly fucking amazed at how backwards a lot of the men on this site are. Seriously. Wtaf.

They think they're not misogynists because they're "on the left". The left are worse misogynists than the right are tbh. At least the right are open about it rather than pretending.

Boils my piss how shit the left are.

When Dworkin said men on the right think women are private property and men on the left think woman are public property, she wasn't wrong.
 
They think they're not misogynists because they're "on the left". The left are worse misogynists than the right are tbh. At least the right are open about it rather than pretending.

Boils my piss how shit the left are.

When Dworkin said men on the right think women are private property and men on the left think woman are public property, she wasn't wrong.


It’s like as if they think because they’re “right on” about some stuff they don’t need to look any closer to home.
 
And if the men on this thread don’t know how this shit works, and don’t think there’s loaded power games in play that make it qualitatively different to walking on eggshells then they clearly don’t have the faintest idea about the female experience.

Yes, this - the power imbalance is so important to recognise if you are to understand how any of this works. I think some men think that because women can say no to sex (sometimes) it redresses the power imbalance. I mean, I've seen them make this argument elsewhere. (You my love are one of the ones I was thinking of when I said I tip my hat to those coming back and back and making good arguments - the stamina :cool: )
 
I’m honestly fucking amazed at how backwards a lot of the men on this site are. Seriously. Wtaf.

Every. Single. Thread.

Women discuss their experience and BOOM!

There’s a couple missing on this thread that I’d expect to weigh in at some point.

If it wasn’t so awful it’d be funny in its predictability. It’s fucking tiresome.

Eta and the fact it’s so tiresome probably explains why there are a couple of female posters I’d expect to be on a thread like this who are notable by their absence.
 
It's really ingrained isn't it? The desire/need to undermine and control women. The need to be right and in charge and 'don't you fucking dare do anything that I am not the centre of because if you do etc. etc...' This tactical reminding us of our periods and PMT, it's a backhanded way of putting us in our place and reminding us of our 'biological weaknesses'... Well done.
And at the same time the expectation that women shouldn't expect safety late at night, that women shouldn't expect their boundaries and wishes to be respected. It's women's responsibility not to go out at night, it's women's responsibility to learn how to 'manage' unwelcome men.
 
I’m honestly fucking amazed at how backwards a lot of the men on this site are. Seriously. Wtaf.

To be fair, less than half a dozen men have made more than a couple of contributions to this thread and these have expressed a range of opinions from gromit's fuckwittery to more considered responses that have been well received. There hasn't exactly been a barrage of denial that the issues being discussed are real from most men on this site.
 
To be fair, less than half a dozen men have made more than a couple of contributions to this thread and these have expressed a range of opinions from gromit's fuckwittery to more considered responses that have been well received. There hasn't exactly been a barrage of denial that the issues being discussed are real from most men on this site.
Most men don’t deny shit, they just don’t understand it, think it doesn’t apply to them, or secretly think it’s unfair. The evidence is on this thread.
 
Most men don’t deny shit, they just don’t understand it, think it doesn’t apply to them, or secretly think it’s unfair. The evidence is on this thread.

I wouldn't know and I wasn't trying to pick an argument. I just thought it might be worth noting that most men on here are taking a back seat on these threads. Having hit the two post threshold I should probably leave it there.
 
Last edited:
To be fair, less than half a dozen men have made more than a couple of contributions to this thread and these have expressed a range of opinions from gromit's fuckwittery to more considered responses that have been well received. There hasn't exactly been a barrage of denial that the issues being discussed are real from most men on this site.
To be fair..this is just a lot of winded way of saying 'not all men' isn't it? Yes we know. You needed to make sure though, because you doubt us.
 
I wouldn't know and I wasn't trying to pick an argument. I just thought it might be worth noting that most men on here are taking a back seat on these threads. Having hit the two post threshold I should probably leave it there.


The thing is, please do join in the discussion. As I said before, it’s not a ghetto. But please for the love of god please make your contribution be more meaningful than “not all men” or, in this instance “very few men on this thread”.

We can’t be beribboning ever single post with “except for the men for whom this is an exception”
 
I know this is a really crass analogy - and even more so because I know there are women on this thread who experience both racism and sexism (so I apologise in advance) - but I cannot imagine a thread on urban where black people are talking about their experiences of racism and white people are piling in to give their redundant point of view that they don't do that. Stop it. Seriously, just stop it.

If you are unable to listen to what women are saying without getting really defensive and angry, think about why that might be. Own it.
 
The thing is, please do join in the discussion. As I said before, it’s not a ghetto. But please for the love of god please make your contribution be more meaningful than “not all men” or, in this instance “very few men on this thread”.

We can’t be beribboning ever single post with “except for the men for whom this is an exception”


I wasn't coming out with a "not all men" argument. I was trying to respond to the specific claim that a few individuals on this thread were representative of the attitude of "a lot of men on this site". At least one of them is a serial anti-feminist troll whose posts are generally greeted by men and women alike with a sentence beginning "Fuck off...". So much so that that it's become an Urban catchphrase, suggesting he's far from representative of this community. One or two others have made provocative points, but they've been challenged by other men more often than not and the tone of discussion and the most prominent voices have been atypical of Urban P&P, which might reflect well on the willingness of others to sit back and listen.

ETA: I'm the only man to have posted on this page. This doesn't look like anything like an urban pile on to me, or a particularly defensive or angry response for that matter.
 
Last edited:
I know this is a really crass analogy - and even more so because I know there are women on this thread who experience both racism and sexism (so I apologise in advance) - but I cannot imagine a thread on urban where black people are talking about their experiences of racism and white people are piling in to give their redundant point of view that they don't do that. Stop it. Seriously, just stop it.

It happens here all the bloody time but that's another thread.:thumbs: BAME people talking about their experiences of racism make some White people feel uncomfortable, exactly the same thing is happening here. Some men are feeling uncomfortable with this conversation.

If you are unable to listen to what women are saying without getting really defensive and angry, think about why that might be. Own it.
:)
 
It's the old adage, isn't it, that men are concerned that women will laugh at them, whereas women are concerned that men will kill them.
if that is an old adage, it's one I havent heard before. It has a ring of truth about it, and I thought it worth repeating.
 
It was ok - I was furious af, put the fire out quickly and chased him and his friends out of the club, shrieking like a banshee, followed by some bouncers :D But even though it was a bit of a shock, it just seemed to be pretty standard behaviour. Which is the point really - on the whole I've been very lucky in my transactions with men: never been raped, rarely been sexually assaulted, got a good partner, turned invisible before dick pics and online sexual harassment became a thing. But I'd la+ Quotergely forgotten about being set alight because it was just one nasty event among so, so many.

It really boils my piss to see men equating this constant state of vigilance towards men's feelings, especially as very young women or even girls (actually roughly 12-16 is when you get the most unwanted male attention ime), with the negotiating that we all do (some to a greater extent than others, granted) in our relationships. It's not just the added risk of physical harm. It's that it is fucking constant, from everywhere, all the time, from the outwardly benign to the obviously threatening. It's even the fact that men feel entitled to your time when you're trying to get somewhere - when I was good mates with someone blonde and big breasted who liked to dress skimpily, it would take us forever to get from A to B, because we'd have to give numerous men the fucking time of day. And we would have to 'man whisper', because a straight up 'go away' would lead to such drama that it would take up even more of your time.

Tbh all these feminism threads just make me too angry and depressed to deal, and I take my hat off to all you women and men making brilliant and eloquent posts in the face of whataboutery, distraction techniques and just crap from posters who should know - and do - better.
That is shocking. More shocking that it was just one event 'amongst so many'.

It was certainly a problem in my younger days (before becoming invisible as an older woman) and it seems to be as much of a problem as it ever was, with the younger women I've talk to recently. Which I find depressing.
 
I wasn't coming out with a "not all men" argument. I was trying to respond to the specific claim that a few individuals on this thread were representative of the attitude of "a lot of men on this site". At least one of them is a serial anti-feminist troll whose posts are generally greeted by men and women alike with a sentence beginning "Fuck off...". So much so that that it's become an Urban catchphrase, suggesting he's far from representative of this community. One or two others have made provocative points, but they've been challenged by other men more often than not and the tone of discussion and the most prominent voices have been atypical of Urban P&P, which might reflect well on the willingness of others to sit back and listen.

ETA: I'm the only man to have posted on this page. This doesn't look like anything like an urban pile on to me, or a particularly defensive or angry response for that matter.


You’re right. So I’ll retract that slur against you in particular.

But there has been quite a lot of chatter about the thread itself rather than the issue in the OP, and a lot of that chat has been about whether it’s a real issue or something made up or exaggerated (or attributable to periods ffs).

If we can agree that it is a real issue even though not everyone has first hand experience of it, then maybe we can get on with trying to pick it apart.

Some of the men who have posted on this thread have done so in order to tell woman that it’s not a real problem or whatever, and the discussion has been stalled several times. And then we get pissed off and round we go again. So many of these feminism & sexism threads end up with post after post giving examples of bad personal experiences because we end up backed into a place where we have to justify qualify or in some way prove that the problem we face is real.

And as I’ve said already, it would be great if you and other men also contributed to this discussion about having to negotiate around the fragile male ego ( NAM obvs).

I’ve never wanted to have these discussions in private, I think it’s really important that men are also involved with these discussions, even if that’s only from the sidelines. But this pattern of having to spend pages just getting to the point where enough men agree that it’s a legitimate discussion is really tiresome.

When I talk with women about feminism & sexism in private*, we can jump straight to the heart of the issue without having to wade through the “is it really a real problem” stuff. I’d love it if that could happen in mixed conversation too.



* Edited to add: when I say private here, I mean with women; the thing is though that even when it’s with women who have entirely different experiences and maybe even don’t have first hand experience of what’s being discussed, there’s never any of this “yeah well it can’t be real then” bollocks that we have to wade through when (not all) men are involved.
 
Last edited:
There are a few couples on this site where the bloke has come on to me v v strongly (in one case I actually hit him in response, breaking his glasses) and I have felt like I've just had to accept that and not kick off or ever be open about it because we all know who usually gets shunned from communities for this kind of thing.

I am so sick of feeling threatened by men. The stronger you get the more they want to crush you. It is relentless. I feel like I pander to men less than a lot of people but I still feel completely oppressed by living in this world where to survive you have to let them be absolute dikk edds.
 
There are a few couples on this site where the bloke has come on to me v v strongly (in one case I actually hit him in response, breaking his glasses) and I have felt like I've just had to accept that and not kick off or ever be open about it because we all know who usually gets shunned from communities for this kind of thing.

I am so sick of feeling threatened by men. The stronger you get the more they want to crush you. It is relentless. I feel like I pander to men less than a lot of people but I still feel completely oppressed by living in this world where to survive you have to let them be absolute dikk edds.

That used to happen to men A LOT when I was younger. Coupled up blokes hitting on me because I was single. Yuck
 
There are a few couples on this site where the bloke has come on to me v v strongly (in one case I actually hit him in response, breaking his glasses) and I have felt like I've just had to accept that and not kick off or ever be open about it because we all know who usually gets shunned from communities for this kind of thing.
IME when this happens (as it does), it isn't because people don't believe you. They generally know he's a creep, so it's already priced in. It's because it's easier to exclude the person making the fuss, than to get involved in the fuss yourself.
 
(I'm not justifying it fwiw - it's just another example of the thing that I've realised recently that most bad things happen because it's too much bother, or too awkward, or too inconvenient for people - especially groups of people - to do the right thing)
 
Back
Top Bottom