Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Tory UK EU Exit Referendum

I think the original phrase queried was "disruption to capital" not "disruption to capitalism" which aren't necessarily the same thing.
Well, disruption of capital is disruption of process of investment, no? ie disruption of borrowing/lending mechanisms - either loans aren't forthcoming or loans are defaulted on, or both. ie Greece. How do you disrupt that process without causing unemployment to rise, living standards to fall, and worker rights being squeezed?
 
It seems to me that if it inspires similar and increasing calls for referendum/leave movements around Europe, then EU neoliberalism could be derailed...
Nearly half of voters in eight EU countries want own 'Brexit' referendum

And that might also leave deals such as TTIP in a mess too.

Some interesting stuff here too about how Europe countries view EU...
Euroskepticism Beyond Brexit

(of course, going by the threats that sections of capital have been making about leave being 'the end of civilisation', you'd think that they were genuinely concerned, but difficult to not be cynical of such motives)
 
Last edited:
Hmm.

I used the phrase "disruption to capital".

In that Brexit would disrupt capital. It would interrupt the neo-liberal plan as implemented by the EU. It would exacerbate (already existing) divisions within the political manifestations of capital (i.e. the Tories but Labour too and various parties in other EU countries). It would exacerbate already existing division within the business community (transnational capital vs. small business etc.). I'm sure there would be an impact on the markets and the financial sector too.

But.

...but

It's just disruption, it's just interruption.

It's nothing lasting unless we take advantage of it.

Which i don't see happening.
 
...but

It's just disruption, it's just interruption.

It's nothing lasting unless we take advantage of it.

Which i don't see happening.

So what do we do then? This takes me back to something I think I said many pages ago... that is staying in the EU and little bits of reformism then really the best we can ever achieve? ('we' as in left, pro-socialist, pro-worker, anti-capital). Really depressing thought.
 
So what do we do then? This takes me back to something I think I said many pages ago... that is staying in the EU and little bits of reformism then really the best we can ever achieve? ('we' as in left, pro-socialist, pro-worker, anti-capital). Really depressing thought.

Fuck knows :(

It's all very depressing.

It really underlines how absent any kind of "Left-ish" ideas, never mind concrete forces, are at the moment (certainly in England). We're not even in this game.

Neither Brexit nor Remain are any sort of victory. They're both defeats. No sense painting them any other way.

I guess we can argue about which is the more damaging defeat for us.

*sighs*

Forgive me. It just seems politically bleaker than I can ever recall out there right now.
 
Hmm.

I used the phrase "disruption to capital".

In that Brexit would disrupt capital. It would interrupt the neo-liberal plan as implemented by the EU. It would exacerbate (already existing) divisions within the political manifestations of capital (i.e. the Tories but Labour too and various parties in other EU countries). It would exacerbate already existing division within the business community (transnational capital vs. small business etc.). I'm sure there would be an impact on the markets and the financial sector too.

But.

...but

It's just disruption, it's just interruption.

It's nothing lasting unless we take advantage of it.

Which i don't see happening.
well why not just vote leave out of spite to the wankers who did the greeks over and continue to do so? Them and their trading club that has somehow become mightier than the will of an electorate. No ones storming the winter palace here are they. Sneering libs have been insinuating heavily that the lexit case is revo fantasy stuff but then they are smelling their own farts and loving them again
 
Maybe its like being a Scotland supporter during the Euros. Cheering on whichever team might go through to beat the English the most should England qualify from the group stages.

...or something.
 
well why not just vote leave out of spite to the wankers who did the greeks over and continue to do so? Them and their trading club that has somehow become mightier than the will of an electorate. No ones storming the winter palace here are they. Sneering libs have been insinuating heavily that the lexit case is revo fantasy stuff but then they are smelling their own farts and loving them again

Voting out of spite is certainly one option.
 
Sneering libs have been insinuating heavily that the lexit case is revo fantasy stuff but then they are smelling their own farts and loving them again
This is itself a sneer. This thread is oozing with the sneer 'liberal' against anyone who might, for instance, have concerns over losing their job.
 
This is itself a sneer. This thread is oozing with the sneer 'liberal' against anyone who might, for instance, have concerns over losing their job.

Where? I've not seen anyone do that at all. It's critised liberals for offering shit analyses ('but but Gove/Boris/Farage'), and for trying to just reduce anyone wanting leave to being some of racist, and for making out that the EU is some sort of 'progressive' power when it's fucking over workers and member states, and for hyping up dramatic positions ('they'll send 'em home') when the reality isn't that clear. I've not seen anyone actually revel in people losing jobs. Although, if you think I'm going to be upset because JP Morgan threaten to pull out of the UK, well, hmm.
 
Fuck knows :(

It's all very depressing.

It really underlines how absent any kind of "Left-ish" ideas, never mind concrete forces, are at the moment (certainly in England). We're not even in this game.

Neither Brexit nor Remain are any sort of victory. They're both defeats. No sense painting them any other way.

I guess we can argue about which is the more damaging defeat for us.

*sighs*

Forgive me. It just seems politically bleaker than I can ever recall out there right now.

QFT
 
Where? I've not seen anyone do that at all. It's critised liberals for offering shit analyses ('but but Gove/Boris/Farage'), and for trying to just reduce anyone wanting leave to being some of racist, and for making out that the EU is some sort of 'progressive' power when it's fucking over workers and member states, and for hyping up dramatic positions ('they'll send 'em home') when the reality isn't that clear. I've not seen anyone actually revel in people losing jobs. Although, if you think I'm going to be upset because JP Morgan threaten to pull out of the UK, well, hmm.
No, the reality isn't that clear, but the time is coming when Project Wishful Thinking has to start delivering some clarity. We know Project Fear has been overhyped, repeating that over and again doesn't move anything forward.
 
I know. I was responding though to LBJs fucking shit.
it's not though, is it? I said above that "one way to "develop working class struggle" is to make life harder and conditions ever less favourable for the workers." and got a lecture about the four horsemen.

because, as far as I can see, a great deal more of the energy being put into Project Wishful Thinking is raging against Project Fear rather than actually analysing what these concepts really mean. In practice, for people and their lives.

FWIW during the 2008/9 recession I remember trying to find ideas for how to take advantage of that period of 'disruption of capital'. No-one had any and all that happened was that I lost my livelihood and Cameron became PM.
 
problem is I made my decision before any of the campaigns started even lacing their boots and putting on shit ties. My possion has been long decided and not reactionary.
 
I'm not sure that 2008/9 was a period of disruption for capital. Not in the sense that i mean it anyway.

2008/9 allowed strategic moves by capital within states like the UK to shrink chosen aspects of the economy and of the state. Was capital divided, disrupted, vulnerable during this period? I don't think so. The logic of capitalism was more naked than it had been before perhaps, and there was certainly a fairly abrupt shift in "stuff" such as borrowing, house prices and high street consumption. But I don't think its a comparable "disruption".

...but again I'm not 100% sure on any of this.
 
I'm not sure that 2008/9 was a period of disruption for capital. Not in the sense that i mean it anyway.

2008/9 allowed strategic moves by capital within states like the UK to shrink chosen aspects of the economy and of the state. Was capital divided, disrupted, vulnerable during this period? I don't think so. The logic of capitalism was more naked than it had been before perhaps, and there was certainly a fairly abrupt shift in "stuff" such as borrowing, house prices and high street consumption. But I don't think its a comparable "disruption".

...but again I'm not 100% sure on any of this.
capital was very happy as governments fell over themselves to thrust money into the banksters' capacious coffers.
 
Sorry newbie et al, it's no good, I think I'm just so utterly frustrated by the lack of a strong left response and narrative on pro-worker, pro-socialist grounds to any of this (whether that ultimately meant remain or not) when I think that the referendum especially when the Tories are at utter odds with each other with a small majority and the (even tiniest) potential for a leave derailing the present path of EU neoliberalism, that I just haven't got the patience or argument in me for it - especially the liberal privileged guff that now pervades the forum - criticising other posters on the left rather than uniting to attack capital/neoliberalism. I'm gonna take a break from here.
 
Each choice seems to be a sop to one side of the capitalist class, but is there any honour in abstention?

I'm completely undecided and anticap.
 
capital was very happy as governments fell over themselves to thrust money into the banksters' capacious coffers.
and organised labour bent over backwards to reduce hours and take pay cuts in order to have some hope of a job in the future. The precariat got hammered. Benefit cuts were immediately necessary.

No two situations are ever exactly comparable, but where are the precedents for a "disruption to capital" that helped "develop working class struggle" without hurting common people much, much more than it hurt the banking and political classes?
 
and organised labour bent over backwards to reduce hours and take pay cuts in order to have some hope of a job in the future. The precariat got hammered. Benefit cuts were immediately necessary.

No two situations are ever exactly comparable, but where are the precedents for a "disruption to capital" that helped "develop working class struggle" without hurting common people much, much more than it hurt the banking and political classes?
i don't recall unionised people in my sectors bending over backwards to reduce hours and take pay cuts. perhaps you could point to some examples.
 
Hmm.

I used the phrase "disruption to capital".

In that Brexit would disrupt capital. It would interrupt the neo-liberal plan as implemented by the EU. It would exacerbate (already existing) divisions within the political manifestations of capital (i.e. the Tories but Labour too and various parties in other EU countries). It would exacerbate already existing division within the business community (transnational capital vs. small business etc.). I'm sure there would be an impact on the markets and the financial sector too.

But.

...but

It's just disruption, it's just interruption.

It's nothing lasting unless we take advantage of it.

Which i don't see happening.

Bet everybody's heard this one before, but there's that quote from Lenin in Switzerland - "we older comrades may not live to see the revolution" - very shortly before the October revolution. Not claiming there's much ground for predicting great developments from an interruption to neoliberalism. But just the fact of good consequences being unforeseeable isn't necessarily a sign that Brexit won't have them either.

To the extent an interruption/disruption involves victims of neoliberalism exercising power, for once, might that empowerment itself prepare the ground for better developments?
 
Last edited:
You've got zero useful ever to say have you. You and some of your fellow travellers are why I now ignore the Brixton forum.
I'm open to "left" arguments for leaving the EU. But they all seem too hand-wavy or wishful-thinking for me to be persuaded by.

Your statement suggests you also think they are inadequate. "Lack of a strong left response".

Was looking forward to all your useful-things-to-say about this.
 
i don't recall unionised people in my sectors bending over backwards to reduce hours and take pay cuts. perhaps you could point to some examples.
don't you work in the public sector?

Here you go
Workers at major manufacturing company agree to cut hours and pay to save jobs | Eurofound

and by sheer chance, because I wasn't searching for a company owned by a leading Outer, here they are doing it again last Novemebr

JCB staff agree to work fewer hours to save jobs
 
Back
Top Bottom