littlebabyjesus
one of Maxwell's demons
For me, Jonny Bairstow is emblematic of the problem. He was a very good test batter, averaging over 40. He's gone from that to someone who barely averages 30. And we can all see why. In that same time, he's become one of the best 50-over batters in the world.
Now why did he fail to manage to be both a highly successful 50-over batter and a very good test batter at the same time? Others manage both. Why not Bairstow?
Is it a question of the advice he was given, the time he devoted to thinking about both forms of the game? Are there systemic or cultural problems here? I don't know, but listening to Ross Taylor the other day when he announced his retirement, he was most proud of the way he had curbed his white-ball game in order to succeed in the red-ball game. For whatever reason, Bairstow singularly failed to maintain his red ball game while expanding his white ball game. The one came at the expense of the other, and that whole thing seems to be writ large over the whole of English cricket. New Zealand, with only a tiny fraction of the resources both in terms of money and player pool, has managed to be good at both, to improve at both, and with the same core of batters (all averaging over 40 in test cricket) - Williamson, Taylor, Latham and Nicholls - in both the test and 50-over sides.
Now why did he fail to manage to be both a highly successful 50-over batter and a very good test batter at the same time? Others manage both. Why not Bairstow?
Is it a question of the advice he was given, the time he devoted to thinking about both forms of the game? Are there systemic or cultural problems here? I don't know, but listening to Ross Taylor the other day when he announced his retirement, he was most proud of the way he had curbed his white-ball game in order to succeed in the red-ball game. For whatever reason, Bairstow singularly failed to maintain his red ball game while expanding his white ball game. The one came at the expense of the other, and that whole thing seems to be writ large over the whole of English cricket. New Zealand, with only a tiny fraction of the resources both in terms of money and player pool, has managed to be good at both, to improve at both, and with the same core of batters (all averaging over 40 in test cricket) - Williamson, Taylor, Latham and Nicholls - in both the test and 50-over sides.