I think Rooney is a good player but for me he hasn't fulfilled the (awesome) potential I thought he had when he was 18. You get flashes of his brilliance (the overhead against Man City) but he never seems to take a game by 'the scruff of the neck' like I thought he would 8 years ago. As for Carroll ge's just an old fashioned centre forward - I think Italian defenders would make him look very ordinary.As for Rooney. I overheard some discussions in the bar tonight and it was unthinkable a few weeks, even days, back. that people would be saying they should drop Rooney for Carroll. They had had a few beers mind, but still it's a case to be argued.
Will Nike allow it?