wiskey said:
thing is though i remember that this year someone said urban would make up 1% of endorse it - we make up much less of glasto
but VF had literally thousands of members all going to the same place, all spending months discussing it (in details rather than our general thread that struggles to plod along int he early months) and planning everything.
that has to have had an effect and one which is way over the one we have (not to mention the swapping of bank details en mass to enable people to get tickets this year - now i dont think that happened on urban but i might be wrong).
and yeah we might not have all met up, but we all went independently before and had a great time so so what?
Has made and still makes a massive difference to me, my life, and my circle of friends. I simply can't have such a dismissive 'so what' attitude to net based interraction and festivals
The difference interacting here and elsewhere makes is very personal for me I guess, whether we're talking online about Glastonbury, festivals, or other things. My Glastonbury timeline :
1984 : went on my own (after having been at Stonehenge! -- but also on my own)
1994 : went on my own
1997 : went with two other friends
1998 : went with three other friends
1999 : went with two other friends
2000 : went with two different friends, but I think I met Tort and moose for the first time
-- it had been around then that I started posting on efests.
2002 (after getting more involved on Urban) : went with Stig and many others who between us created the first Camp Urban
2003-2005 and 2007 : Lots and lots of Urbanites and other friends, real life friends who I'd largely not have known at all but for here and elsewhere.
OK so the above might read a little sad, and also a bit misleadingly.
Misleadingly because in all the pre 2002 years I spent plenty of time chatting with randoms and meeting new if fleeting friends. Maybe if mobiles had existed then, I'd have kept more in contact with some of them, although I still occasionally bump into old schoolers at Glasto and other festies. And there's certainly a good possibility (were my memory clear enough to be sure!
) that I spent more time 'wandering' more energetically, and seeking out more new and interesting and weird stuff and cobbling together my own festival programme, I was always an away from the main stages and markets man (largely) right from the start. Actually I do have some fairly clear memories of epic random wandering and discovering stuff through the 'what's going on in that little tent over there?' factor -- this still happens. Glastonbury made me fit!!
But I can only see the Camp Urban years in a positive light for pretty personal reasons, and I think what Urban brings to Glastonbury (and for eg to Endorse It too) in a lot of ways contradicts your (apparant?) theory that gangs of mindlessly consuming automatons turn up at festivals off the back of the internet.
Raising 'V' is hardly any kind of accurate or fair comparison. Glastonbury really is still very different from BransonFest and CarlingCrapLabelWeakender ("Reading") in loads and loads of respects. I speak as someone who has my own worries about some of the similarities creeping in around the edges in more recent times, but I'd seriously argue that the differences, still, are far greater.
And both my most recent and my present relationships, to both of which festivals were/are central, would not have happened but for net based contact ....
So I'm bound to see stuff more positive .... but as I say, it's highly personal, just my take on it really. Not saying all should or will be as positive, I'm
very able to discuss criticisms of which there are many valid ones. but I suppose I
do think it's more than a bit sad that you seem (?) so jaded and cynical about Glastonbury now.
It's hardly any secret that I'm still full of excitement and enthusiasm for the whole shebang, even with all its faults, and I still think a lot of excellent people go -- beyond our circle of fiendship too, I still meet all sorts of very friendly and weird random stranger-friends who are not in the mindless consuimer bracket at all.
Cider glass (more than) half full and that.