Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Several people shot dead in Plymouth 12 August 2021

Can you point to one drop of sympathy?

As to "understanding", the only attempt to understand here is one that is trying to prevent people like him from existing in the first place.
i think i'm guilty of what might look like sympathy, with my thing of putting the emphasis on the suicide part. But Begum knew when signing up that the whole suicide-murder thing would be delegated to others, she expected to survive her choice, and i think thats a significant difference.
 
This is interesting, when you're wondering about how important a factor a coherent 'Ideology' really is when you're trying to think about what terrorism is / isn't.
Prevent referrals data: A Massive increase in the 'mixed unstable or unclear' department recently.

"Much of that 10% increase was seen in the ‘mixed, unstable or unclear’ ideology category, which represented 51% (3203) of referrals in 2019/20, up from just 11% (696 of 6093) in 2016/17."

 
Meloy and Yakeley (2014) -- Sci-Hub | The Violent True Believer as a “Lone Wolf” - Psychoanalytic Perspectives on Terrorism | 10.1002/bsl.2109 -- was one of the first papers I read on this. It's pretty readable, if you fancy it.

Thanks for the link (it's seemingly blocked by Vermin Media though, probably others so let me know if I should attach the PDF). The section "Dependence on the Virtual Community of the Internet" certainly rang true with my experiences of various forms of nutters.

Personally I think the same general principles discussed in the paper can be extended to many societal malaises to some degree or another, not just to the extremes of violence/terrorism, but to many "culty" subcultures.

I certainly do blame the internet to an extent, because people can be drawn to a group there and secluded, their beliefs honed and strengthened; this wasn't really an option in pre-internet times. It's now much easier to fall in to a particular rabbit hole and stay there since you're no longer on your own.

Reading the incel description on rational wiki that was posted for my benefit earlier (I've read RW a lot but never come up against this incel thing before) doesn't sound too drastically different from some of my own "desperate teenager" tantrums - I never had a girlfriend until I was well in to my 20s and wondered what was wrong with me that made me so repellent - but how you get from that to this misogynistic piffle is a complete mystery to me. I guess I'm lucky to have avoided chauvinism and "toxic masculinity"; I wonder very much what their relationships with mothers and sisters is like because from my very limited reading it does seem to largely boil down to hating women.
 
I've met one or two blokes with the incel/misogynist mentality, and came to the conclusion that women just can't win with that type. On the one hand, that kind of guy thinks all women are evil based on characteristics women are stereotyped as having. Yet if a specific woman goes against the grain and shows she doesn't fit into that box, that's wrong too because she's not feminine enough. My first ex was like that, and often complained he'd had difficulty getting a girlfriend before me. Not going into details because it might divert from the point of the thread, but let's just say that the benefit of hindsight told me why. In general, who apart from incels would be surprised at a woman not wanting to go out with the sort of bloke who thinks she's evil purely because of gender? It's no different or better than racial stereotyping.
 
Last edited:
i think i'm guilty of what might look like sympathy, with my thing of putting the emphasis on the suicide part. But Begum knew when signing up that the whole suicide-murder thing would be delegated to others, she expected to survive her choice, and i think thats a significant difference.
She was also a fifteen-year-old child when she left the UK, he was an adult of 22, when he went on his rampage, she hasn't actually killed anyone and she's had to watch three of her own children die as a result of her decision.

She's seen as unredeemable, perhaps because of the trite "suicide murder thing" tag, which is unlikely to represent a more nuanced reality that motivated her to make the decision she made. However, there are seventeen pages here with many posts focused on understanding his background and what motivated him.
 
Warning- shit chat from the ignorant (myself)...
I think mapping entire systemic issues onto individuals is a bit of a red herring. My neighbours, (my people, my community) are, in fact, as individuals, frequently quite cuntish. Racist, chauvinistic, homophobic...they honestly exhibit the entirety of class stereotypes...but nonetheless, I am compelled to stand with them because just about all of them (us) are low-income, working class, and marginalised. There are a zillion oppressive systems in place to ensure people like us know our place and don't ever have the temerity to step out of our lanes. So yep, this 22 year old was, on a personal level, an utter shitwipe...but socially, culturally and politically, it seems essential to situate the aberrant actions of an individual iwithin a wider context - a horrible mixture of social contempt, failing services, deprivation, loneliness and the resulting reliance on echo chambers, commodification of the body under a depraved late stage capitalism (including the ubiquity of porn), aspirational consumption...FFS...a fucking morass of fails which, like climate change, cannot be classified as too huge, too nebulous and too overarching as to be in a permanent state of TINA.
Similarly, state surveillance of the individual is not really any sort of useful answer.

For myself, I have no sympathy or tolerance for this hateful misogyny but otoh, I don't feel we can actually dismiss the incel culture as just some sort of entitled whining, given many of the often overlapping issues affecting young men (and women) which are manifesting in despair, suicide, self-harm, nihilism, addiction, violence. At it's most basic level, ownership of one's body or direct acting on someone else's is an immediate expression of power for those who feel they have no other recourse.
 
I liked your post because I agreed with almost everything you said. However I take issue with the bolded part. White privilege should not be an undefined term used to beat disadvantaged white people with. By adopting that approach (even in the pro-white working class way that you did) you're playing into the hands of those who seek to divide the working class.

Yup, and it was partly written in direct response to your earlier response to Gramsci - which contextually and politically - I strongly disagreed with. I was actually surprised to read it from you. However, as you rightly say, this isn’t the thread for a derail and so we’ll have the debate on another thread at another time. I look forward to it!
 
Genuine question for those who have had a look at incel sites: do any of them follow football or other team sports? Because that might be one way of getting over your social isolation, to an extent at least.
I don't think mixing with alpha males is really their bag.
 
It's the whole "get a girlfriend" thing isn't it? Like a commodity. These men are used to being able to "get" whatever they want. Buy whatever they want..
But they have turned women into non people. Things to have.

And sadly they are probably very friendless too. Except for other men who think the same way.
It's nearly as if they see women as things to collect. A tick box in life.
Part of a list of things to do / have to make you "successful".
No I don't think so for the most part. People are lonely, and have been conditioned throughout early years to expect work, home, love, family etc.. girlfriends are not necessarily seen as a commodity, these young men want love like the rest of us.

if you go on any dating site, for the most part women can get a date ten times easier than men because they are women, and often in the bio that's all they say. There's confusing signals for young men. Should they be a bad boy, what do women want, if they show vunerabilty they're not included. Life can be alien for those on the asd spectrum, in ways that there are often not even words to explain it. Its not intuitive.

I've seen woman have those tick boxes too. Can you provide for me and my children, can you adapt to my life and my baggage. Even before questioning if there's a connection.

Many of these young men are on the autistic spectrum disorder, they struggle to pick up cues, to engage, to have confidence. If they don't have the insight into their condition, the intelligence to work through it, the support.. it can end in incel type groups and this violence. ASD makes building relationships really difficult. And the often black and white thinking adds to this " all women are like this" etc.

Without this being addressed through other balanced voices, how to help? It's not an easy thing to be that 28 year old virgin and find good people to talk about it with. Plus people don't know how to help, it's often easier to believe that someone is celibate by choice.

People will look for people who will listen, they'll feel like they're in a safe space and radicalization gets a foot hold.

I've got 3 sons, obviously I'm biased but tbf they are lovely in every way. 2 settled down and the third one tied in knots because in spite of the loveliness he is still single and still a virgin. He knows all about incel stuff, he recognizes it'd be easy to go down that rabbit hole, hé describes to me the practices he uses to ensure his experiences as a young man on the asd spectrum don't warp him.

Its both incredibly sad and inspiring to be with him in this journey. Tbh I've said it before about boy 2, he is my moral compass. But he doesn't drink, he needs a lot of time by himself, he struggles with that small talk, life is incredibly confusing for him a lot of the time, and at his age many woman here have a family that they expect to be included in their relationships too which yes, is as it should be but for someone like my son is overwhelming.

On the plus side he's incredibly fit with movie star looks, drives, works ( as a support worker) has the best conversation, kind, empathic, patient and would be devoted and loyal. He also dresses well and smells good. But building connections of any sort he struggles deeply with due to asd and a trauma history.

So I think that this phenomenon is way more complex than is being discussed.
 
Last edited:
ice-is-forming

I agree with you. Society builds a picture of how we should be. And where we should be by certain milestones. Our lives are measured out before we get a chance to know who we even are.
It's frustrating and sad and young people get presssured into all sorts of things they can regret afterwards.

I dont think anyone can know for certain why he killed his mother and those poor people. But his videos give a glimpse into his mind and his mother had sought help about him and for him. Its very very sad that she did not get the help they needed.
 
Mirror reporting that he hospitalised a bloke and threw his pregnant partner to the floor 5 years ago. Police caught him but he was just given a 'warning' according to the piece. It suggests that's why that incident didn't ping when he applied for a gun licence. If someone who attacked two strangers and hospitalised one of them were just 'warned', there are major questions for the OB, quite aside from the more recent incident. I suspect the force will be wondering whether to use cuts in funding as a defence, which will make the blame game messy, but that's by the by.

The piece says he went to a school for kids with special needs, which may end up having some relevance to the story (or not at all, depending on his special needs).
 
I've been reading some of the posts here and they are good.

Im wary of concentrating to much as seeing this as some kind of aberrant event related to incel culture. Or trying to classify this as terrorism.

What has made the national headlines is that he not only killed his mother he also went out and shot other people at random.

I looked up murders in Plymouth and not to my surprise there have been some awful cases.

This one covers nine of them in last decade.


Four of them are men killing female partners / ex partners. One is a man who murdered his father did his time then tried to rape a women when released.

Majority of the those convicted were men. Drinking heavily was often involved.

Im not saying Plymouth is unique in this.

But looking at some of the cases and they are as appalling as this one in levels of violence if not the number of people killed. But didn't make national headlines in way this case has.

They also include mainly women being murdered.

Rather than see this terrible murder as part of some kind of terrorism it might be better to see it as a continuum of violence that involves men killing women.

Im not trying to have a go at other people's post here. I'm just suggesting a slightly different way of looking at this. I don't have all the answers.
 
Last edited:
Mmm, my oldest was 42 before he had a relationship. I think I was more bothered about this than he was. He certainly didn't loiter around the parts of the internet which dealt with any sort of relationships, that's for sure, unless it was with computers, plants or green woodworking , collecting keyrings and the like, plus he had a network of friends going back to primary school. For sure, ASD shaped a part of his identity but also in a good way and he did eventually get found by a determined and clear-eyed woman.
Life comes at us all the time but not if your only connections are with bitter online strangers.
 
Because alpha males are the people they despise most (maybe after women)?

'Alpha males' are not a real thing. There's something inherently misogynistic about this trope whereby the ideal male is someone who is in a position to acquire and discard female attention at will. It's everywhere though, just another thing with no real basis to it that's still widely accepted and referred to in all walks of life.

IIRC the 'alpha male' concept is based on an assumption that humans behave like wolves. And also on a major misconception about how wolves behave.
 
'Alpha males' are not a real thing. There's something inherently misogynistic about this trope whereby the ideal male is someone who is in a position to acquire and discard female attention at will. It's everywhere though, just another thing with no real basis to it that's still widely accepted and referred to in all walks of life.
Exactly., but it's incels' perception of other men.
 
Life comes at us all the time but not if your only connections are with bitter online strangers.

For sure. And the last year or so hasn't helped. Find urban to be a safe haven from all the bitterness out there. Normally the misogynists and the chest beaters get short shrift here.

Out there, though. There's a lot of folks (some well meaning, some definitely not) saying how things should be (be a man/get a job/haircut/play sports) etc. Sometimes it's this kind of pressure to conform to the stereoytypical everyday "healthy" male archetype that can mess with peoples heads.

Who knows with this lad? He could have had plenty of underlying issues before he drifted into a world of hate and self-loathing.
 
I've been reading some of the posts here and they are good.

Im wary of concentrating to much as seeing this as some kind of aberrant event related to incel culture. Or trying to classify this as terrorism.

What has made the national headlines is that he not only killed his mother he also went out and shot other people at random.

I looked up murders in Plymouth and not to my surprise there have been some awful cases.

This one covers nine of them in last decade.


Four of them are men killing female partners / ex partners. One is a man who murdered his father did his time then tried to rape a women when released.

Majority of the those convicted were men. Drinking heavily was often involved.

Im not saying Plymouth is unique in this.

But looking at some of the cases and they are as appalling as this one in levels of violence if not the number of people killed. But didn't make national headlines in way this case has.

They also include mainly women being murdered.

Rather than see this terrible murder as part of some kind of terrorism it might be better to see it as a continuum of violence that involves men killing women.

Im not trying to have a go at other people's post here. I'm just suggesting a slightly different way of looking at this. I don't have all the answers.
Plymouth is my home town and I love it. But yeah, you've pretty much hit the nail on the head. There are the usual arseholes getting drunk and killing their partners (and don't forget, with 2 women being murdered by partners/ex partners each week, every city in the UK must have that problem). The attack a few years ago on a very popular young man who happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time on New Year's Eve shocked everyone because that was carried out by TWO arseholes intent on killing someone. Both with a history.

Plymouth is a military city. There is a culture of heavy drinking, and social problems (undiagnosed PTSD and other service-related mental health issues can affect generations, not just the original victim). It's easy to forget that because it is in fact a nice place to live. Even the "bad" areas are better than most (I've lived in lots of cities and I feel safer here than anywhere.)
 
For sure. And the last year or so hasn't helped. Find urban to be a safe haven from all the bitterness out there. Normally the misogynists and the chest beaters get short shrift here.

Out there, though. There's a lot of folks (some well meaning, some definitely not) saying how things should be (be a man/get a job/haircut/play sports) etc. Sometimes it's this kind of pressure to conform to the stereoytypical everyday "healthy" male archetype that can mess with peoples heads.

Who knows with this lad? He could have had plenty of underlying issues before he drifted into a world of hate and self-loathing.

Yeah I think some (probably most) of the 'sympathetic' posts on this thread are more of a reaction to that than actual full-on empathy for this guy.
 
This might not be a popular view in some quarters, but when I hear about something like this happening, I often muse along "there but for the grace of something-or-other go I" lines. I was still a virgin at 22, and it's fair to say that that I was not at all happy about it, to the point of being pretty miserable and not a little resentful when I got friendzoned YET AGAIN. What makes the difference, I think, is that I lacked the sense of entitlement which seems to be a core part of the incel ideology. I assumed - and I still think this is true - that it must have been something about me that made situations pan out the way they did. Which was miserable and uncomfortable, and I can see how much easier it might have been just to externalise it all, and lay the blame on those horrible women and the culture that excluded me from all the fun. I don't know why I didn't go down that road - maybe I just choose the hard path - but I'm eternally grateful that I didn't.

But I'm not even sure that I can claim credit for being such a Nice Bloke that I didn't choose the blame-externalising route. It was probably luck. That, and, with the benefit of hindsight, the fact that my personality and upbringing didn't foster that sense of entitlement that seems to be a common factor in the incel, MRA, etc world. Maybe it was the lack of exposure to the cultural clues in film and TV that create a wholly artificial notion around the "boy meets girl" thing. Or perhaps I really was that Nice Bloke.

Whatever it was, I dodged a bullet there, and it does make it slightly harder not to just "other" pathetic individuals such as this one: perhaps quite a few of us weren't nearly as far away from what these people become than we'd like to admit?
 
I can't honestly see myself in him and I genuinely believe what a lot of 'incels' need is to get together sexually. If you're that frustrated, and so is your mate, what the fuck are you complaining at each other for? Whip 'em out and have a wank together.

I know that sounds as flippant as fuck, and it is, but that has worked for generations of boys and young men. Stop demanding women sort you out, sort each other out then maybe find something else to talk to women about :thumbs:
 
I can't honestly see myself in him and I genuinely believe what a lot of 'incels' need is to get together sexually. If you're that frustrated, and so is your mate, what the fuck are you complaining at each other for? Whip 'em out and have a wank together.

I know that sounds as flippant as fuck, and it is, but that has worked for generations of boys and young men. Stop demanding women sort you out, sort each other out then maybe find something else to talk to women about :thumbs:

Group masturbation?
 
I can't honestly see myself in him and I genuinely believe what a lot of 'incels' need is to get together sexually. If you're that frustrated, and so is your mate, what the fuck are you complaining at each other for? Whip 'em out and have a wank together.

I know that sounds as flippant as fuck, and it is, but that has worked for generations of boys and young men. Stop demanding women sort you out, sort each other out then maybe find something else to talk to women about :thumbs:
Hmm. I wonder if it's maybe less about sex than some perceived male identity idea? You know, "you're not a Proper Bloke if you're not squiring your way through the neighbourhood" kind of thing?
 
Back
Top Bottom