Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

British IS schoolgirl 'wants to return home'

I think being compassionate is rarely a bad start point, but it's often a very inappropriate finish point.
 
Think the British State has got it about right now. Leave her where she is and make no effort to help her.
Its not to do with her. There is a baby about to be born. The relevant authorities should be seeking that child's safety as their over riding goal.
This woman and her vile views have very likely contributed to the negligence that has cost two other children their lives.
She is in no position to materially care for the child to a manner acceptable to UK authorities.
 
I've spent time reading around it myself, but beyond academia it really does get lost under shouting. It's not a question ''society at large'' seems ready to take seriously.
We're all at a loss, aren't we? Norway has just about the highest living standard in the world, extensive social security networks, etc, yet it produced Anders Breivik. I don't think there are clear answers to any of this stuff. Even in a virtually ideal society, people would come along who would do terrible shit.

Aside from the obvious - stop starting wars and get out of the ones you've already started - I don't have any particular ideas wrt Britain, although 'don't start wars' is a very good place to start, I think, if you're serious about not producing violent extremists.
 
Its not to do with her. There is a baby about to be born. The relevant authorities should be seeking that child's safety as their over riding goal.
This woman and her vile views have very likely contributed to the negligence that has cost two other children their lives.
She is in no position to materially care for the child to a manner acceptable to UK authorities.

What are you suggesting? Go and take the baby from her and leave her there, or bring them both back here, or something else?

And treat her as a special case? I might be wrong but as far as I know the British authorities don't intervene in child protection cases of any other UK citizens that have decided to go and live in other parts of the world.
 
she had no problem with other women being raped to death so the fact she's being fed in a refugee camp rather than left to die in a ditch


You know no more than I do what she did and didn't have problems with. I do however find it strange that a middle-aged man living in relative comfort can be so filled with disgust for a teenage girl living in a squalid camp who has already seen two children die. She may lack compassion, you clearly do, and are old enough to know better.
 
What are you suggesting? Go and take the baby from her and leave her there, or bring them both back here, or something else?
The exact legal moves are beyond me but there should be an investigation of her circumstances from the relevant local authority (in this case Tower Hamlets) and if she cannot provide for the child in a manner expected there should be a legal move in the family courts to place the child in a safe environment. I am sure there are those here who will be able to fill in the details.
 
You know no more than I do what she did and didn't have problems with. I do however find it strange that a middle-aged man living in relative comfort can be so filled with disgust for a teenage girl living in a squalid camp who has already seen two children die. She may lack compassion, you clearly do, and are old enough to know better.
Let's not go overboard the other way though. She knew exactly what IS were and what they did before she went, and her reaction to it was 'can I join in?'
 
You know no more than I do what she did and didn't have problems with. I do however find it strange that a middle-aged man living in relative comfort can be so filled with disgust for a teenage girl living in a squalid camp who has already seen two children die. She may lack compassion, you clearly do, and are old enough to know better.

Speaking of people living in and speaking from comfort do those of you so keen to show compassion for her feel any obligation to be slightly less forgiving on behalf of all those killed, tortured, raped, and made homeless and Stateless that she helped and encouraged through her active support for IS?
 
The exact legal moves are beyond me but there should be an investigation of her circumstances from the relevant local authority (in this case Tower Hamlets) and if she cannot provide for the child in a manner expected there should be a legal move in the family courts to place the child in a safe environment. I am sure there are those here who will be able to fill in the details.

You expect Tower Hamlets child protection services to go to Syria to work this out? Oh dear.
 
The exact legal moves are beyond me but there should be an investigation of her circumstances from the relevant local authority (in this case Tower Hamlets) and if she cannot provide for the child in a manner expected there should be a legal move in the family courts to place the child in a safe environment. I am sure there are those here who will be able to fill in the details.
It's a bit naive to think this case would follow normal procedure like that, though. Various things would be politically impossible were she to return to the UK, especially after this publicity. I suggest that one of those would be the idea that she would be allowed to keep the child.
 
The exact legal moves are beyond me but there should be an investigation of her circumstances from the relevant local authority (in this case Tower Hamlets) and if she cannot provide for the child in a manner expected there should be a legal move in the family courts to place the child in a safe environment. I am sure there are those here who will be able to fill in the details.
Not quite sure that welfare visits to refugee camps in Sryria fall under the remit of the Tower Hamlets child protection team.
 
... teenage girl living in a squalid camp who has already seen two children die.

She's a woman, not girl.

Given her children seem to have died (at least in part) as a result of malnutrition, one has to wonder about the extent to which their deaths were casued by her decsion to remain until it was obvious the caliphate was on its last legs.
 
It's a bit naive to think this case would follow normal procedure like that, though. Various things would be politically impossible were she to return to the UK, especially after this publicity. I suggest that one of those would be the idea that she would be allowed to keep the child.

I think the opposite, if she did end up back here it would be pretty impossible to take the child off her. And if the authorities did I expect a number of people on here to be moaning about that as well.
 
I think the opposite, if she did end up back here it would be pretty impossible to take the child off her. And if the authorities did I expect a number of people on here to be moaning about that as well.
Well she'll be in prison for a start. But seriously, you think it would be hard to take her child? Someone who committed a criminal offence in travelling to Syria to join IS, who has already let two children in her care die? If you were following some kind of normal procedure I think it would be very easy to take the child away on child protection grounds. Given these circumstances, it becomes more or less mandatory to do so.
 
If she can get to where she can obtain consular assistance and makes it back to the UK with her newborn child, I'd expect her to be arrested and her child removed initially under Child Protection processes. I'd expect her to be prosecuted and locked up. It would be unlikely, depending on the length of the subsequent sentence, that the child would ever return to her care.

My impression of the video is that it's chilling. A completely brutalised person. Clearly still a risk to the public in general, and to her child in particular.
 
Speaking of people living in and speaking from comfort do those of you so keen to show compassion for her feel any obligation to be slightly less forgiving on behalf of all those killed, tortured, raped, and made homeless and Stateless that she helped and encouraged through her active support for IS?


She was a child from Tower Hamlets who ran away, not a Daesh strategist. As to forgiveness, I'm not in a position to need to forgive her, anymore than anyone here is. I can't forgive on somebody else's behalf
 
Well she'll be in prison for a start. But seriously, you think it would be hard to take her child? Someone who committed a criminal offence in travelling to Syria to join IS, who has already let two children in her care die? If you were following some kind of normal procedure I think it would be very easy to take the child away on child protection grounds. Given these circumstances, it becomes more or less mandatory to do so.

So many legally disputable things in that even at first glance by a non-legal person.
 
She's a woman, not girl.

Given her children seem to have died (at least in part) as a result of malnutrition, one has to wonder about the extent to which their deaths were casued by her decsion to remain until it was obvious the caliphate was on its last legs.


She was certainly was a girl when she got into the mess she's now in.
 
She was certainly was a girl when she got into the mess she's now in.

She was a girl then, but was well above the age of criminal responsibility when she left. And she is now an adult and as such has actively engaged in support for IS, probably including more than just 'passive support', and is currently unrepentant and still supportive of IS and its ideology.
 
You think it is legally disputable that she broke the law? That's the most important point, and the one that will land her in prison.

Go on then, explain how.

"She went to join IS your honour?"

"No, she went to marry someone as she was alienated, depressed, and while vulnerable was brainwashed online."

As many on here have said. It'd be an easy case to construct in the courts.

Not everyone who went to join IS and fight has even been imprisoned and that's not what the State thinks is best to do. And you do know it's possible to break the law and not go to prison right?

As I said initially, best off turning our backs and hoping the problem gets sorted somehow.
 
If she does manage to return to the UK isn’t she going to require protection from her former Isis comrades, that will want her dead for running home. Or more likely from someone thinking that killing her in their mind, evens things up.
 
Out of curiosity, how far was she from her 16th birthday when she fled to join this bunch of murderous, hate filled cunts?
I don't know but I keep coming back to the fact that somehow there was a point when an unsupervised 15 year old child got on a plane. At some point she was protected as a minor and then she wasn't. What point was that? Surely a 15 year old can't just get on a plane to Turkey? Surely someone has to be with them at the airport if they're flying alone?
 
I’m unsure what this means.

I mean that starting from a position where being kind and understanding rather than condemning out of hand is a good thing, but there's times when you do need to move beyond that and take a position that judges and condemns someone's actions and expects them to take responsibility for what they did.
 
Back
Top Bottom