Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Sunak wants to phase out legal smoking

Why not close all the pubs and shops and every other <expletive> thing and we can all sit in a room with a neural link to World Wide Web.
I vibe with this sentiment somewhat. There seems to be 3 issues here to my mind:

1. Where does this stop? Aren't there more deaths from alcohol so lets stop that then, no?

2. Some don't seem to make the distinction between dying from something like being murdered and something that was an automonous choice like drinking/smoking, cave-diving or whatever. Like numbers are just thrown together with false equivalence.

3. I know that we can harm ourselves through smoking/etc as a reaction to life stresses, etc. But - at the risk of stating the obvious - isn't it part of being a human being in an imperfect world that we get to make our own decisions, lifestyle choices, etc? Isn't that what the human experience is all about? What's the alternative? Sitting in a corner with a neural link?
 
Last edited:
To me, this is an inevitable part of the chain that started with Hayek and the idea of perfect markets being the answer to all life’s problems. The failure of that idea led to the idea that externalities can be priced into the market. The failure of that led to the attempt to build hedonic “well-being” measures that could be maximised as part of the market perfectability, and positive psychology as a way of aligning behaviours. And that leads us to this — anything that fails to conform with rational maximisation according to those measures needs to be nudged out of existence. No recognising of the need to allow people to build their own lives and communities, autonomously and meaningfully. No social justice, just individual perfection.
 
So what do we think of this proposal to make it illegal for the next generation to buy cigarettes? Or technically I think, illegal to sell to them. Changing the age allowed to buy them every year by one year, so those under a certain age are blocked from buying them forever. Prime Minister to create ‘smokefree generation’ by ending cigarette sales to those born on or after 1 January 2009

It's definitely true that if tobacco was brought to the market today the govt would ban it asap. So its availability is an anomaly. You could say the same about alcohol but it's not quite as thoroughly bad for your health as smoking, and is more culturally important. So maybe tobacco's status as a brutally damaging drug available in every corner shop should end?

If so, how does that fit into a world that might allow recreational drugs to be available in the future? Would tobacco be ranked with the more addictive drugs and be less easily available? Or in a different drug regime would it make sense for everyone to be allowed to buy tobacco again? Or do we make an exception for tobacco and say it simply causes too much harm.

Maybe I should have put this in the drug forum.

For furthur details visit here: Elf Bar ELFA Pods
I think it’s a great idea to make it illegal for future generations to buy cigarettes by raising the minimum age each year. This could help reduce smoking among young people. If tobacco were introduced today, it would likely be banned due to its harm. While alcohol is also risky, smoking causes more health issues. It’s interesting to consider how this fits in with discussions about legalizing other drugs. Should tobacco be treated differently because of its dangers?
 
Last edited:
Lucy, a 20-year-old university student, says she took up smoking recently because "it's just what everyone does".

Almost all her friends also smoke and she says it's more than just a habit, it's an aesthetic.

"I definitely think everyone trying to be brat has influenced people to start smoking because Charli herself says you have to have a pack of cigs if you really want to embody the vibe."

 
Lucy, a 20-year-old university student, says she took up smoking recently because "it's just what everyone does".

Almost all her friends also smoke and she says it's more than just a habit, it's an aesthetic.

"I definitely think everyone trying to be brat has influenced people to start smoking because Charli herself says you have to have a pack of cigs if you really want to embody the vibe."

Every time I think people can’t get any more stupid someone else comes along to prove me wrong.
 
Smoking is just too damn cool unfortunately. To be fair, vapes did make it very uncool for anyone over 21 but the rest of us… we have no chance.
 

I'm just back from Taiwan, where it's long been illegal to smoke outside schools.
first time I saw the signs on a school playground fence, it was a real "that makes sense why don't we do that?" moment.

but on another note, despite vaping being illegal and vapes illegal to import or sell - it's everywhere. people puff away on the club dance floor and nobody seems bothered.
 
I might have told this before. I was day drinking some years ago in a cracker of a pub here in Preston. Bar manager and one other customer in. A man walks in and asks for a single short of any kind, he just wants to calm his nerves. He then opened up about his mother dying earlier that day in hospital and he was just getting some time away. The three of us became a self help group for a while and turned the pub into a little refuge of calm.

That's the kind of pub culture I love and have always defended. It's why I'm very snotty about Wetherspoons, and you don't need to know my thoughts on other chains, they're not designed to allow people to stay as people, rather than just become customers.
I take your point but the spoons in brockley (the barge) is as sociable as any pub I've ever been in....
 

I'm just back from Taiwan, where it's long been illegal to smoke outside schools.
first time I saw the signs on a school playground fence, it was a real "that makes sense why don't we do that?" moment.

but on another note, despite vaping being illegal and vapes illegal to import or sell - it's everywhere. people puff away on the club dance floor and nobody seems bothered.
really pissed me off being in England for a couple of years, a group of mums used to stand right at the school gate blowing clouds. Yea I get it, you've dumped the brats at school and you're dying for that first hit of the day but at least do the decent thing and cross the street. I'm a smoker but I at least have the brain power to not get the next generation tangled up in it.
 
really pissed me off being in England for a couple of years, a group of mums used to stand right at the school gate blowing clouds. Yea I get it, you've dumped the brats at school and you're dying for that first hit of the day but at least do the decent thing and cross the street. I'm a smoker but I at least have the brain power to not get the next generation tangled up in it.
I think it's a great shame that smoking and drinking beer on playgrounds isn't socially acceptable any more. These days these family outings feel very half asked and rushed.
 
Well my dad was on 100% oxygen for years, forced to quit work at 60 and didn't enjoy retirement cos he as he said. Retirement would be great if I could fucking do anything. COPD is awful but very avoidable by not smoking almost continually for 45 years. Then 10 years of serious illnesses which compounded til he died.

People moan about the smell of vapes but it's a massive harm reduction over smoking.
 
People moan about the smell of vapes but it's a massive harm reduction over smoking.
are vapes definitely better? I thought it was still hard to tell.

but my main issue with vapes is they seem designed for, and marketed at, teenagers. the rows of vapes in shops look like sweets or toys. crazy.
 
“Better” is relative. Smoking is about as terrible for you as it is possible to imagine anything being, short of jumping off a building. So is vaping less mind-bogglingly awful than smoking? Probably. That’s hardly an endorsement, though.
 
I read news stories of teenagers addicted to vaping and doing it as often or more in fact than people smoking in old films

And then getting moody and violent from vape withdrawal so perhaps addicted to vaping. Have no idea if this is actually a thing though or just media scare stories, was probably in the guardian
 
If the vapes contain nicotine, then of course they will get addicted.

I guess those that don't contain nicotine can still become a habit.
 
Lucy, a 20-year-old university student, says she took up smoking recently because "it's just what everyone does".

Almost all her friends also smoke and she says it's more than just a habit, it's an aesthetic.

"I definitely think everyone trying to be brat has influenced people to start smoking because Charli herself says you have to have a pack of cigs if you really want to embody the vibe."


I'm afraid Lucy is just a fuckwit. I smoked at 20 and can't imagine myself or other smokers I knew justifying, explaining it in such embarrasingly immature terms. I wasn't proud of smoking, I just liked it with a drink, then without a drink. Some people are seriously lacking self awareness.
 
are vapes definitely better? I thought it was still hard to tell.

but my main issue with vapes is they seem designed for, and marketed at, teenagers. the rows of vapes in shops look like sweets or toys. crazy.
But the shops you are mentioning are not 'proper' vape shops....these are the 'dodgy' shops that have proliferated over time and literally don't give a shit. My local proper vape shop doesn't have anything in their window and only sell legal vapes with strict I.D. compliance. I have come off smoking to vaping....i like the fruity flavours as i don't want to be reminded of smoking......people keep saying that these things are marketed at kids but how ?
 
Back
Top Bottom