Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

What is this car sized object which America has shot down?

also confused why you would spy with something so conspiciuous? Surely you would make them look like an actual normal ass ballon
 
also confused why you would spy with something so conspiciuous? Surely you would make them look like an actual normal ass ballon

People have been falling for this shit for years.

Trojan-Horse-900x675.jpg
 
Purely from my imagination....
1. They are a shit load closer to any weak RF they might want examine
2. they are cheap as fuck (comparatively)
 
Three year old article but seems relevant

Interesting about how they can stay in one place.
And because winds often travel in different directions at different altitudes, the balloons can usually hover over a given area simply by ascending or descending.
Linked from article above [ALTA]
 
Last edited:
Any of the same reasons we use Aeroplanes for intelligence gathering as well as satellites with the added economy factor but without the speed and positioning accuracy.
 
also confused why you would spy with something so conspiciuous? Surely you would make them look like an actual normal ass ballon

But until now they haven't been conspicuous. I can't find the article now, but it said it was partly cost, partly they can see stuff satelittes can't (not reliant on orbits as they can hover), and also they are smaller and slower and (until now) much less detectable.
 
An expert on the radio was saying they can look more sideways. So into hanger doors etc rather than directly from above. No idea if this is bull though.

That makes a bit more sense.

Although they'd need to drop from 40000 feet. And not be seen.
 
note that, despite it being the obvious and (relatively) boring answer, the Chinese took responsibility for the first balloon and it was identified as Chinese immediately -- this has not happened for the other three

Doesn't mean it wasn't them, or maybe it could be Russia/North Korea etc.?

Reading between the lines I do think there's a war coming with China in the next decade tbh, likely starting over Taiwan.
 
Each Sidewinder missile costs about 300 grand according to google, so it's 1.2 million dollars just in ordnance.

Nah, the most recent one (Montana?) was shot down by an F-16 firing an AIM-9M - the M was in production in the late 80's. It was superseded by the X, which is expensive, but is bought in huge numbers. Something over 100,000 sidewinders have been produced...

Interesting that the USAF aren't insisting that they use F-22's to shoot everything down - they don't have many, and they're expensive to fly. If an F-16 can do the job with a 20 yo missile, at a fifth of the flying hour cost, then they've obviously decided not to waste their resources.
 
note that, despite it being the obvious and (relatively) boring answer, the Chinese took responsibility for the first balloon and it was identified as Chinese immediately -- this has not happened for the other three
It’s easy to take responsibility for a single balloon that you can claim was to measure the weather and got off-course.

That excuse wears a bit thin when you have to use it for four spy drones in short succession.
 
It’s easy to take responsibility for a single balloon that you can claim was to measure the weather and got off-course.

That excuse wears a bit thin when you have to use it for four spy drones in short succession.
has anyone claimed responsibility yet
 
Back
Top Bottom