Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

'Vegan diets are healthier and safer for dogs' says The Guardian about University of Winchester survey

Agree with the rest of what you said, but chickens being kept in crowded battery conditions, cows being bred to produce huge quantities of milk, videos of some abattoirs - particularly in the US?

I don't think meat production is necessarily a problem but really no cruelty in how the great majority of meat's produced now? I'd love to think it's true, I'd feel happier in consuming it,
I mean i grew up on a farm, surrounded by other farms and I didn't see any at all. Farmers care for their animals, they don't put on weight or be productive if they're ill or badly treated.
The one thing i would be concerned about is cheap poultry and eggs.I avoid that
 
I mean i grew up on a farm, surrounded by other farms and I didn't see any at all. Farmers care for their animals, they don't put on weight or be productive if they're ill or badly treated.
The one thing i would be concerned about is cheap poultry and eggs.I avoid that
It was working on dairy farms as a kid swung it for me, the way modern milkers have been bred is all wrong. Back then the drugging was pretty terrible too.
 
Things are slightly complicated at the moment because (as I understand it) there are no "free range" eggs or chicken at the moment because of avian flu.
 
Ok, so editor banned me from the other current vegan thread, the kind of thing he tends to do on these threads in a blatant misuse of his mod powers.

So I'll pop this here.

While I'm not narrowly interested in the 'we must be vegan to save the planet' line, I am interested in all viable alternatives. In the very narrow case of dog food, that probably includes entoculture, as it does for humans as well. Mussel farming is another case in point.

Ethics-wise, is it possible to be cruel to a mussel? Given the uncentralised nature of its nervous system, is there something it is like to be a mussel that means it can experience suffering? I would argue that this is very doubtful.

Meanwhile, there are quite a few advocates of mussel farming as a green solution. This study of mussel farming in the Baltic suggests that it can indeed be a very green way to farm. The study suggests that careful positioning of farms allows them to operate without measurable detrimental effects. And mussel farms can even have a net positive effect on the environment by reducing eutrophication where this is an issue.



https://www.submariner-network.eu/images/20190508_BBG_Factsheet_Environmental_impacts

As food, they're very good for you, mussels, and not too pricey. I'd encourage everyone to eat more of them. Maybe even dogs?

My pet moray eel fucking LOVES mussels. The confusion in the fishmongers when I bulk buy a load for him is brilliant.
 
Things are slightly complicated at the moment because (as I understand it) there are no "free range" eggs or chicken at the moment because of avian flu.
Think farmers are hoping the latest restrictions will be lifted late May. Our local organic shop are selling their flock of chickens though - they say they're not laying well and not happy being kept inside.
 
It was working on dairy farms as a kid swung it for me, the way modern milkers have been bred is all wrong. Back then the drugging was pretty terrible too.
I'm a bit uneasy about Holstiens too, but the ones at work seem fairy content. Low mastitis, not many foot issues.

Jersey much more ideal though and when I win the lottery, I quite fancy some pet ones to hand milk.
 
I'm a bit uneasy about Holstiens too, but the ones at work seem fairy content. Low mastitis, not many foot issues.

Jersey much more ideal though and when I win the lottery, I quite fancy some pet ones to hand milk.
It's the breeding to emphasise production, those udders compared to a wild bovine, and not usually drying up naturally so needing to be milked. Seems a far cry from my Mongolian mate hand milking sheep and mares out of the grasslands. Not that he does that except on holidays home now, he's become a photographer :D
 
"Vegans shouldn't have pets" is just playground bullying by the way. "I don't eat meat or dairy products" "You shouldn't have pets then neh neh neh".

It's the sort of thing I'd expect on a right wing Republican site: "You're a socialist? You shouldn't have possessions then you hypocrite". "You're an environmentalist? You shouldn't burn wood/gas/oil for heating and should just freeze to death in winter."
Absolutely. I’m sure hypocrisy hunting is a reason why more people don’t make a partial effort if a full effort isn’t possible. Been able to hold an absolutist position is admirable but I’m sure it can put people off from trying.
I'm familiar with the process and how animals are kept (that I eat) and I completely reject that premise.
Vegans are welcome to their view, but I suspect (like most arbitrary groups of people), they are not a monothought clique. My ex girlfriend was (and still is) a vegan and seemingly had little problem with me both owning a grazing flock of sheep and also working in a broiler hatchery part time.
Yes completely. There are multiple reasons for people being vegan, or at least eating a plant based diet. Whilst I guess animal welfare is probably one of the reasons for many, it’s not necessarily a reason for all, or the reason they’d prioritise most.
As for  most meat eaters, I suspect most couldn't care less and/or never really think about where their food comes from. The modern, supermarket system completely disconnects the consumer from the product.
And I think there are also people (I include myself in this) who are aware and one day would ideally not eat meat, but find with so many other conflicting values and priorities that it’s not manageable yet. Parents have to make sure they feed their fussy kids an adequate diet and might not have the time to cook multiple meals every evening, people who work ridiculous or unsociable hours don’t have the time to plan and cook well balanced vegan meals, people with certain health conditions may not find it suitable etc.

And sometimes different approaches to the same value will clash. A while ago I made sure I ate vegetarian food for over half the week and aimed for one or two days of completely plant based fare. But if I was working that would mean going to M&S and using disposable packaging. Living ethically has an almost fractal like number of caveats and counter effects, and it’s hard to manage everything consistently.
 
It's the breeding to emphasise production, those udders compared to a wild bovine, and not usually drying up naturally so needing to be milked. Seems a far cry from my Mongolian mate hand milking sheep and mares out of the grasslands. Not that he does that except on holidays home now, he's become a photographer :D
This is all well and good but selective breeding has tangible benefits in terms of efficiency, which impacts the environment.

One of the main drivers of the drop in numbers in global cattle herd, for example is more efficient dairy animals being bred in the developing world.
 
And sometimes different approaches to the same value will clash. A while ago I made sure I ate vegetarian food for over half the week and aimed for one or two days of completely plant based fare. But if I was working that would mean going to M&S and using disposable packaging. Living ethically has an almost fractal like number of caveats and counter effects, and it’s hard to manage everything coconsistently.
I get that - I don't consider eating meat unethical though, I consider the environment to be at the forefront of my ethical choices (although I do not wish to debate this stance ad nauseam - my opinion in this matter can be found on other veganism threads).

As such, I dislike nutrients I have purchased leaving my house, so everything is composted (down to my rudimentary making of bonemeal). This grows most of my vegetables.
I waste almost no food whatsoever.
 
This is all well and good but selective breeding has tangible benefits in terms of efficiency, which impacts the environment.

One of the main drivers of the drop in numbers in global cattle herd, for example is more efficient dairy animals being bred in the developing world.
I think both you and I know that the driver of "efficiency" in agribusiness is not primarily their concern for the environment.
 
FWIW I doubt most vegans do buy dogs from breeders, but that doesn't mean there are no vegans who own dogs.

And aiming to be more ethical doesn't mean "do absolutely everything absolutely right!" There's no way to completely eliminate everything that harms living beings or the environment anyway - that's just not the world we live in.

I'm not vegan, just veggie. but I make sure to buy free-range eggs (preferably organic because they tend to be more free-range than some other chicken farms) and buy medium eggs if I can. It's not perfect, because male hens still have to be killed, but it's better than encouraging the production of barn eggs.
 
male hens
Hate to break it to you sam, they're called cocks :D
ETA Think I stuck it on the interesting new facts page, but I read that the word "rooster" was coined deliberately as a euphemism to avoid calling them cocks.
 
I think both you and I know that the driver of "efficiency" in agribusiness is not primarily their concern for the environment.
Not entirely certain dairying in developing countries is big business.

Whether it is intended or not, efficiency reduces resource use per unit output, which can only be of benefit to the environment inputs will have an environmental as well as financial cost.
 
Hate to break it to you sam, they're called cocks :D
ETA Think I stuck it on the interesting new facts page, but I read that the word "rooster" was coined deliberately as a euphemism to avoid calling them cocks.
A rooster is a cock bird that has reached sexual maturity, although the two terms are used interchangeably now.
 
And aiming to be more ethical doesn't mean "do absolutely everything absolutely right!" There's no way to completely eliminate everything that harms living beings or the environment anyway - that's just not the world we live in.
Agreed. But unfortunately these discussions often get into polarised positions and some do make some very all or nothing arguments, hypocrisy hunting being at the sharp end. Also see motorists claiming that anyone suggesting traffic should be reduced should never ever fly for any reasons, anyone who tries to avoid buying certain globalised goods due to human labour concerns being berated for having smart phones no matter if they’re rarely upgraded etc.

Another personal example of doing one thing “right” and accidentally doing another thing “wrong” was when I bought the free range “Happy Eggs”, which sounded great from an animal welfare perspective, and then read how terribly they treat their staff :(

If the system in The Good Place really did exist it would be both fascinating and disheartening to see how every action we try and take for the good has a down side.
 
Agreed. But unfortunately these discussions often get into polarised positions and some do make some very all or nothing arguments, hypocrisy hunting being at the sharp end. Also see motorists claiming that anyone suggesting traffic should be reduced should never ever fly for any reasons, anyone who tries to avoid buying certain globalised goods due to human labour concerns being berated for having smart phones no matter if they’re rarely upgraded etc.

Another personal example of doing one thing “right” and accidentally doing another thing “wrong” was when I bought the free range “Happy Eggs”, which sounded great from an animal welfare perspective, and then read how terribly they treat their staff :(

If the system in The Good Place really did exist it would be both fascinating and disheartening to see how every action we try and take for the good has a down side.
In reality, the best thing you could do to obtain your eggs ethically would be to keep a few chickens, but I realise that's not practical for a lot of people (although I don't see why that should be, especially they were kept at a small community as opposed to an individual level).
 
In reality, the best thing you could do to obtain your eggs ethically would be to keep a few chickens, but I realise that's not practical for a lot of people (although I don't see why that should be, especially they were kept at a small community as opposed to an individual level).
There is a house with chickens in a neighbouring road and my kids adore walking past it! Several local schools have chickens too, though I’m not sure what they do with the eggs.

My kids would love some chickens, but unfortunately so would this madam. 3F944A0F-D5DE-4FF0-8B36-285F59A49991.jpeg
 
There is a house with chickens in a neighbouring road and my kids adore walking past it! Several local schools have chickens too, though I’m not sure what they do with the eggs.

My kids would love some chickens, but unfortunately so would this madam. View attachment 319653

Cats are not a problem with chickens at all. They're too big for the cats to even consider hunting, and the hens are tougher than you'd think. My Elvis (a hen, not a cock, JimW :D) fought off a fox on two separate occasions. But you do need a reasonably large garden in order to provide a decent-sized coop and run.

I'm still waiting for my crazy neighbour to move out so I can get hens again.
 
Agreed. But unfortunately these discussions often get into polarised positions and some do make some very all or nothing arguments, hypocrisy hunting being at the sharp end. Also see motorists claiming that anyone suggesting traffic should be reduced should never ever fly for any reasons, anyone who tries to avoid buying certain globalised goods due to human labour concerns being berated for having smart phones no matter if they’re rarely upgraded etc.

Another personal example of doing one thing “right” and accidentally doing another thing “wrong” was when I bought the free range “Happy Eggs”, which sounded great from an animal welfare perspective, and then read how terribly they treat their staff :(

If the system in The Good Place really did exist it would be both fascinating and disheartening to see how every action we try and take for the good has a down side.
That was pretty much the problem for the last season or two wasn't it? The complexity of modern life and overlapping oppressions, abuses, environmental damage etc meant none could get into the Good Place anymore
 
Cats are not a problem with chickens at all. They're too big for the cats to even consider hunting, and the hens are tougher than you'd think. My Elvis (a hen, not a cock, JimW :D) fought off a fox on two separate occasions. But you do need a reasonably large garden in order to provide a decent-sized coop and run.

I'm still waiting for my crazy neighbour to move out so I can get hens again.
Don't wait get them now and you'll simply out crazy them.
 
Ok, so editor banned me from the other current vegan thread, the kind of thing he tends to do on these threads in a blatant misuse of his mod powers.

If you're so sure that there was a "blatant misuse of mod powers," be sure to report it to the other mods who will - as ever - take an impartial look at the reasons you were banned. Or you can just keep on whining here if you like.
 
If you're so sure that there was a "blatant misuse of mod powers," be sure to report it to the other mods who will - as ever - take an impartial look at the reasons you were banned. Or you can just keep on whining here if you like.
Or maybe you might reflect a bit on the way you carry on on these threads. Accusing people of agendas, questioning people when they mention illness of family members, banging on about exactly what is or isn't permitted in a discussion only to break your own rules. It's not a good look.
 
Or maybe you might reflect a bit on the way you carry on on these threads. Accusing people of agendas, questioning people when they mention illness of family members, banging on about exactly what is or isn't permitted in a discussion only to break your own rules. It's not a good look.

I think you should take a closer look at your own behaviour, to be honest. Please take all further personal off topic criticisms to the feedback forum as I certainly won't be disrupting this thread any further.
 
Back
Top Bottom