Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Transgender is it just me that is totally perplexed?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wow! The demand to talk about "we" and not me, firstly, to do so would leave me open to being a trans representative that I've been accused of before. Also I know every trans person's experience, though we mostly have much in common, is different.
Secondly I was talking personally, not politically.
Thirdly, only in the last five years have I not felt completely apart from every other human being on earth. Nothing I felt made sense. I had no terms of reference to work from. I just felt totally alone, so not feeling totally alone is going to take some time. I'm going through an adjustment period which would be a whole lot easier if I want having to constantly defend myself and answer demands from those who think they deserve an explanation.
 
I wish I could. My meds are leaving me with zero sex drive.
This is one of them things that really gets me down. Nothing works like it once did and currently, I don't even know how sex is supposed to work anymore. I do occasionally feel like sex but just end up crying to porn. I'm hopeful that once I have my own life, there will be good things in it and that it includes sex.
 
This is one of them things that really gets me down. Nothing works like it once did and currently, I don't even know how sex is supposed to work anymore. I do occasionally feel like sex but just end up crying to porn. I'm hopeful that once I have my own life, there will be good things in it and that it includes sex.
it's sertralin that has killed my sex drive, not that I'm too bothered. When i first transitioned i was fully prepared to give up any kind of sex life, if it came to that.
 
Early on when I was a newby to being openly trans, I used to try to field every question I received on Twitter and give an honest answer. Then as I became better known the volume of questions coming just kept growing and often it was the same questions and similarly worded put downs that gradually turned into abuse as I kept my responses civil. Then I had a period of waking up and my timeline being filled with abusive or semi abusive messages. After my name was mentioned in a national publication I had to resort to TERF block bots. Even now I get a trickle of abuse from various quarters: religious, MRAs and US conservatives, and UK extreme right wingers, as well as TERFs.

Oddly one of the first lot of harassment I got online was a group of self identified 'anarchists' who'd found some old pictures of me online and were mocking them on their social media. It was a really odd period. I met a couple who knew these people, knocked around with them for a bit, they got the others to stop attacking me. I thought they were nice people. Then I noticed the guy was getting a lot of flack from pro trans feminists. Soon after he turned on me, so did his wife. Thinking back this lot could well have been linked to the current group of anti trans campaigners. I'm not going to use any identifiers here because the guy sent some seriously nasty threats my way and I took them very seriously.
And at the same time I had no less than Cathy Brennan attacking me and setting her minions on me. None of this was about having a discussion, it was just heckling, calling me names, some abusive, some not.

And I'm a nobody in trans activism. I've seen others actually go into hiding over what they've received, just by trying to help other trans people, or try to challenge the shit storm of crap that fills the media on an almost daily basis.

Yeah, definitely not both sides are the same. We are not as a rule as obsessed with them as they are with us. Most of us would rather be doing other stuff. I wasnt even standing for trans rights in 2015 when I stood, I was standing on a few key policies that were relevant to my area, including housing, transport, pollution, NHS, protecting open spaces and was the only woman who took part in a local hustings about women's rights, and was by far the most feminist person in that room. And yet, I was still undermined and attacked by TERFs just for taking part in the political process as a woman which is my right, effectively helping UKIP and other far right groups who were competing for votes along side me. Makes you wonder what their true motivations are doesn't it?

ETA - I met a good friend of mine last year from Seattle over here visiting, in a pub. She was with a group of her friends. 6 months later she tells me that the woman who got punched at Hyde Park was a friend of hers and I was actually sitting next to her husband at the pub. Small fucking world!!

Also - more synchronicity - the person we'd gone to see giving a talk in the pub was a trans woman.

Anyway she's no longer friends with those people!
I'm sorry to hear about your experiences.

You are an innocent caught in a war. Like all who find themselves in such circumstances, you find a lot to despise in the enemy soldiers that are making your life unbearable.

But your negative experiences don't mean that there aren't also your counterparts in the other country who also are having their own lives made hell by soldiers from your side.
 
Fucking hell. Given her role in recent events that is a really poor choice on the broadcasters part. Or maybe she's just the kind of gleeful shit stirrer they need.

I'm finding it hard to say very much about the Dr RadFem documentary due to the (fairly standard) lack of detail publicly available at this stage.

There are so many ways this could turn out in a manner that isnt what Dr RadFem & friends would like. I say that partly because there are different rules on the internet to tv broadcasting and its far from clear how happy they will be to make their message less spiteful and one-sided to meet broadcasting regulations. And many other things can go wrong when documentary making, I never assume anything will see the light of day at least until the process is far advanced past the 'done a deal' stage.
 
The defenders of the New Orthodoxy get in a real bind when any of this stuff comes up in debate. On the one hand it’s absolutely part of the orthodoxy itself that to debate with “transphobia” is by definition transphobic so the only response they’re really allowed is to chant simplistic mantras and slurs at anyone who isn’t fully signed up. But on the other hand they can see how this alienates the unconverted or ‘ignorant’ majority outside of their tiny political bubbles so they feel obliged to join debate.

The tension between the two poles leads to the sort of chronic dishonesty you’ve highlighted and often means it all gets kind of weird at some point - case in point, the outbreak of kids-in-the-back-row sniggering on the last few pages; you can almost feel the nervous tension bursting out. Face? Bovvered? Am I?

The issue is that 'trans women are women, end of; no debate'. You can't go anywhere from this starting point, because it *is* the debate.

Finding Middle Ground Between Women’s Rights and Transgender Rights
 
I'm finding it hard to say very much about the Dr RadFem documentary due to the (fairly standard) lack of detail publicly available at this stage.

There are so many ways this could turn out in a manner that isnt what Dr RadFem & friends would like. I say that partly because there are different rules on the internet to tv broadcasting and its far from clear how happy they will be to make their message less spiteful and one-sided to meet broadcasting regulations. And many other things can go wrong when documentary making, I never assume anything will see the light of day at least until the process is far advanced past the 'done a deal' stage.

Of course, all fair points. I am just suspicious and wholly disappointed with her particularly spiteful way of driving momentum and self-promotion tbh.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CRI
this would be the liar yardley? you'll be waiting a long time, elbows :(

Maybe. Or I might be treated to some explanation, I dont rule that out.

In any case for me the main thing about backlashes isnt whether they are inevitable, its what scale they end up being and whether they change the big picture or are just the last flickers of resistance to a change that sticks.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom