Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

The big Brexit thread - news, updates and discussion

Of course it would - and does - but not in anywhere near the quantity or at anywhere near the price it has done up til now, so it won't be worth at least some of the catchers' and processors' while to deal with it.

But if you want to be narky about it, are you ready to admit you were wrong yet?
So it would sell and no doubt would sell out. But it would be for less cash than the French would pay hence less profit.
 
So it would sell and no doubt would sell out. But it would be for less cash than the French would pay hence less profit.

You can make anything sell out if you drop the price low enough. Problem is, dropping the price to the point where they could sell all the languostines wouldn't cover the fuel, overheads, never mind an income for the crews. They're fucked.
 
It's about profit only then, not feeding the UK.
What's wrong with that? boats and trucks require fuel and maintenance, fishermen and truckers need paying. They can't be expected to do it out of the goodness of their hearts. I'm sure they have families to support.
 
It's about profit only then, not feeding the UK.
Fishing isnt subsidised.

This could be a serious crisis here: if nothing happens quickly sounds as if it could see a collapse in Scottish fishing businesses, which in turn would I expect, mean indieref2 signed and sealed in Scottish consciousness. Tory polling in Scotland is already dropping day by day supposedly.

There is talk of possible "compensation" from government, but I just can't see if happening on a meaningful, endless scale
 
What's wrong with that? boats and trucks require fuel and maintenance, fishermen and truckers need paying. They can't be expected to do it out of the goodness of their hearts. I'm sure they have families to support.
Is the price they would get for a kilo of shellfish that different in France anyway compared to the UK? Minus the ridiculous transport costs?
 
Fishing isnt subsidised.

This could be a serious crisis here: if nothing happens quickly sounds as if it could see a collapse in Scottish fishing businesses, which in turn would I expect, mean indieref2 signed and sealed in Scottish consciousness. Tory polling in Scotland is already dropping day by day supposedly.

There is talk of possible "compensation" from government, but I just can't see if happening on a meaningful, endless scale

It's not just Scotland. The south-west is in exactly the same situation.
 
Is the price they would get for a kilo of shellfish that different in France anyway compared to the UK? Minus the ridiculous transport costs?

Selling fish abroad is a wealth creation activity while selling it in the UK only moves money around the economy. So UK will be less well off. Plus there is no secret stash of UK buyers ready to step in and buy it all.
 
Is the price they would get for a kilo of shellfish that different in France anyway compared to the UK? Minus the ridiculous transport costs?
I would imagine it has to sell for more in France than in the UK. It costs the same to catch it no matter where it goes but clearly shipping it to Europe is going to be more expensive than shipping it to just London. But you're missing the point, I have no idea what proportion of the population like shellfish (I don't) but the population of the EU is roughly 7 times the size of the UK. No matter how much you cut the cost (and there is ultimately a floor) then the UK simply isn't going to be a big enough market for all the shellfish that once went to the EU.
They might sell a bit more but nowhere the amount they did before ergo less will be caught and there will be fewer jobs for fishermen, for the people processing it and the truckers taking it to market.
 
Selling fish abroad is a wealth creation activity while selling it in the UK only moves money around the economy. So UK will be less well off. Plus there is no secret stash of UK buyers ready to step in and buy it all.
Remainers For Global Capitalism. You could get Blair to head that up. Certainly get Swinson.
 
I would imagine it has to sell for more in France than in the UK. It costs the same to catch it no matter where it goes but clearly shipping it to Europe is going to be more expensive than shipping it to just London. But you're missing the point, I have no idea what proportion of the population like shellfish (I don't) but the population of the EU is roughly 7 times the size of the UK. No matter how much you cut the cost (and there is ultimately a floor) then the UK simply isn't going to be a big enough market for all the shellfish that once went to the EU.
They might sell a bit more but nowhere the amount they did before ergo less will be caught and there will be fewer jobs for fishermen, for the people processing it and the truckers taking it to market.
It might, presumably, be possible to scale up processing so that less easily perishable products can be sold to the EU. But not overnight, and not without sacrificing profits.
 
I can't see anything happening in the next week that avoids a truckload of rotting langoustines being dumped outside downing street. Looking forward to that.

The truckload of rotting langoustines would probably be given a senior position in government. And it'd still be the least corrupt thing in the building.

I'm here all week folks, try the scampi.
 
Remainers For Capitalism. You could get Blair to head that up. Certainly get Swinson.
I'd be up for nationalising the Scottish shellfish market and delivering a daily box of the people's langoustines to every family in the country whether they want 'em or not, but until that glorious day arrives what are they going to do with the fish that no-one wants to buy or eat here?
 
Remainers For Capitalism. You could get Blair to head that up. Certainly get Swinson.

Leavers were/are for capitalism too - well, except those so naive as to think a leave vote would hasten in the revolution. It was - and is - just a matter of how you like your shit sandwich, and to me the turd in the 'out' sandwich looked bigger, sludgier and smellier than the 'in' one. I wasn't wrong. But no matter: now you, me and everyone else has no alternative but to eat it.
 
Back
Top Bottom