Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Joe Biden's time is up

This is just stupid and disingenuous and I've ansered your question. I believe in genuine solidarity.
It's not disingenuous to point out that on a bulletin board with pseudonyms you could be talking to a woman from Alabama who needs an abortion for all you know. Maybe be a bit more careful with your 'you lot' bullshit in future. Mind your fucking tongue.
 
Stop me when I say something inaccurate...

Most (or certainly many, if not most) people on these boards are anti-capitalist, and do not align particularly closely (or at all) with the Democrats (or Labour for that matter, the argument is transferable across the Atlantic).

Most would see more value for the working class from collective and community action rather than putting their faith in politicians. Many are actively involved in such movements.

Most recognise that for certain marginalised groups, things are demonstrably worse under a Repuplican/Conservative government (e.g. LGBTQIA+, minority ethnic groups, women) than they are under a Democrat/Labour government. See the Republicans using the Handmaid's Tale as an instruction manual when it comes to women's bodily autonomy; say what you like about Joe Biden and Co, but it seems unlikely that they'll be pushing to criminalise early-term medically necessary abortion any time soon.

Many would therefore not consider voting for and electing Democrat/Labour politicians as an end to their political engagement, as any form of solution to the ills of working class people, but would do so and then continue with their collective and community action to whatever extent each and everyone sees fit. Nothing will have changed, other than the starting point towards the post-capitalist utopia not being a Christian fundamentalist Republican administration and/or Conservative kleptocracy.
 
It's not disingenuous to point out that on a bulletin board with pseudonyms you could be talking to a woman from Alabama who needs an abortion for all you know. Maybe be a bit more careful with your 'you lot' bullshit in future. Mind your fucking tongue.
Its not my fault that women don't have access to abortion and its not something I believe in or support. People like me have given real practical solidarity to women who need abortions.
 
Last edited:
Stop me when I say something inaccurate...

Most (or certainly many, if not most) people on these boards are anti-capitalist, and do not align particularly closely (or at all) with the Democrats (or Labour for that matter, the argument is transferable across the Atlantic).

Most would see more value for the working class from collective and community action rather than putting their faith in politicians. Many are actively involved in such movements.

Most recognise that for certain marginalised groups, things are demonstrably worse under a Repuplican/Conservative government (e.g. LGBTQIA+, minority ethnic groups, women) than they are under a Democrat/Labour government. See the Republicans using the Handmaid's Tale as an instruction manual when it comes to women's bodily autonomy; say what you like about Joe Biden and Co, but it seems unlikely that they'll be pushing to criminalise early-term medically necessary abortion any time soon.

Many would therefore not consider voting for and electing Democrat/Labour politicians as an end to their political engagement, as any form of solution to the ills of working class people, but would do so and then continue with their collective and community action to whatever extent each and everyone sees fit. Nothing will have changed, other than the starting point towards the post-capitalist utopia not being a Christian fundamentalist Republican administration and/or Conservative kleptocracy.
Its my view that electoralism is a diversion. So that means you can't put all that time and energy into it and at the same time do that for a genuine alternative. I also believe that the democrats have completely failed oppressed and marginalised groups and will continue to do so. Atleast, they will never do anywhere near enough for them.
 
It's not disingenuous to point out that on a bulletin board with pseudonyms you could be talking to a woman from Alabama who needs an abortion for all you know. Maybe be a bit more careful with your 'you lot' bullshit in future. Mind your fucking tongue.
This is just desperate bullshit if you ask me and how am I supposed to be psychic here? As far as I'm concerned your just proving my point and are trying to make me look bad and probably trying to shut down what I'm saying.

All I've done is try to help and point out how things could be done more effectively.
 
Perhaps two sheds can explain himself here, but you have displayed a lack of care about implications of who gets voted in. I don't think that makes you a bigot, just misguided, perhaps foolish. You do know that Republicans seek to introduce legislation to marginalise and oppress women and LGBT folks way more often than Democrats do, right?
Yes misguided - the fundamentalism means he can't see the real-world effects of his abstract beliefs. Or he's just trolling.
 
Its my view that electoralism is a diversion. So that means you can't put all that time and energy into it and at the same time do that for a genuine alternative. I also beleieve that the democrats have completely failed oppressed and marginalised groups and will continue to do so. Atleast, they will never do anywhere near enough for them.
There are about 150,000,000 people in the US whose only engagement with electoralism is to periodically visit a polling station and check a box for the Democrats. Doesn't seem to be all that much time and energy expended there.
 
Perhaps two sheds can explain himself here, but you have displayed a lack of care about implications of who gets voted in. I don't think that makes you a bigot, just misguided, perhaps foolish. You do know that Republicans seek to introduce legislation to marginalise and oppress women and LGBT folks way more often than Democrats do, right?
But its you people who are actively supporting the system thats actually attacked women's reproductive rights. I'm suggesting an alternative. And its true that the democrats and the capitalist system have failed women here.
 
Last edited:
There are about 150,000,000 people in the US whose only engagement with electoralism is to periodically visit a polling station and check a box for the Democrats. Doesn't seem to be all that much time and energy expended there.
No, people don't just stop there, they engage in and spend their time and energy into other electoralist stuff.
 
There are activists for political parties of all stripes, there are those who expend time and energy. For the vast majority, it's a box ticking exercise.
They spend alot of time doing other stuff, even if its spending loads of time posting about it on the internet or generally promoting or being invested in their electoralist beliefs in various ways, even just in conversations with others for example..
 
Here's just one example of the sort of thing I'm referring to.
You've lost me with this one. You're responding to my

but again you ignore how bad things would be particularly for women and LGBT+ people if the republicans were to get in. It fucking matters to them.
I'm not accusing you of misogyny or homophobia, I'm just saying those are the effects of what you're proposing

Its my view that electoralism is a diversion. So that means you can't put all that time and energy into it and at the same time do that for a genuine alternative.
And this is just silly. It takes me five minutes to fill out my postal vote.
I also believe that the democrats have completely failed oppressed and marginalised groups and will continue to do so. Atleast, they will never do anywhere near enough for them.
And nobody is disputing that.
 
They spend alot of time doing other stuff, even if its spending loads of time posting about it on the internet or generally promoting or being invested in their electoralist beliefs in various ways, even just in conversations with others for example..
1674058581397-png.359928


:)
 

Attachments

  • 1674058581397.png
    1674058581397.png
    145.4 KB · Views: 129
I'm not accusing you of misogyny or homophobia, I'm just saying those are the effects of what you're proposing
Its capitalism that strengthens and uses things like homophobia and misogyny to oppress and divide and I am opposed to all of that and suggesting and promoting an alternative. I'm anti-capitalist, so what you say here makes no sense. You on the other hand are actively and unashamedly supporting capitalism and its politicians.
 
Last edited:
But its you people who are supporting the system thats actually attacked women's reproductive rights.

But it's not "the system" which is doing that. The two parties have different track records on the matter. Which party has continually sought to undermine legislation such as Roe v Wade, and eventually succeeded? Which party has spent years setting up "trigger" legislation that came into effect the moment RvW was overturned?

You know what the answer is.
 
But it's not "the system" which is doing that. The two parties have different track records on the matter. Which party has continually sought to undermine legislation such as Roe v Wade, and eventually succeeded? Which party has spent years setting up "trigger" legislation that came into effect the moment RvW was overturned?

You know what the answer is.
Its capitalism and in any case, as I keep repeating, the dems haven't done enough and have failed women. Biden even has a history himself of being with the republicans on this issue ffs.
 
Stop me when I say something inaccurate...

Most (or certainly many, if not most) people on these boards are anti-capitalist, and do not align particularly closely (or at all) with the Democrats (or Labour for that matter, the argument is transferable across the Atlantic).
Well I'll stop you there. I don't think most are anti-capitalist, at least not in the sense of being socialists. There's a lot of centre-left liberals or social democrats but the presence of class politics on U75 is far less strong than it once was.
Many would therefore not consider voting for and electing Democrat/Labour politicians as an end to their political engagement, as any form of solution to the ills of working class people, but would do so and then continue with their collective and community action to whatever extent each and everyone sees fit. Nothing will have changed, other than the starting point towards the post-capitalist utopia not being a Christian fundamentalist Republican administration and/or Conservative kleptocracy.
There clearly are people on U75 that will vote while also it see it as not the end point (which includes myself - I voted Labour in 2017 and 2019). But there are plenty of posters that do go further than that.

Some posters have argued that everyone should vote, that not voting for Labour/Democrats/Macron is supporting the Tories/Republicans/Le Pen, even that voting Green, for example, is supporting Trump.
There are posters that have argued that 'vote to keep out the fascist' is a useful strategy and backed it politically. There are posters that back anti-toryism and a progressive alliance.

I'm not going to tell people not to vote. I don't think voting is really political. But what I do criticise is electoralism and there are plenty of U75 posters that do subscribe to that.
 
I certainly wouldn't want to get involved in any collective or community organisation in which I would be subjected to a torrent of personal abuse for daring to disagree with a supposed comrade, that's for damn sure!

I've seen these disagreements tear apart entire groups doing good stuff. At times, I've wondered if some people were plants sent to disrupt groups with internal rifts. Some of the tactics used against water protectors were like this so it seems like a rational thing to worry about.
 
Last edited:
Well I'll stop you there. I don't think most are anti-capitalist, at least not in the sense of being socialists. There's a lot of centre-left liberals or social democrats but the presence of class politics on U75 is far less strong than it once was.

There clearly are people on U75 that will vote while also it see it as not the end point (which includes myself - I voted Labour in 2017 and 2019). But there are plenty of posters that do go further than that.

Some posters have argued that everyone should vote, that not voting for Labour/Democrats/Macron is supporting the Tories/Republicans/Le Pen, even that voting Green, for example, is supporting Trump.
There are posters that have argued that 'vote to keep out the fascist' is a useful strategy and backed it politically. There are posters that back anti-toryism and a progressive alliance.

I'm not going to tell people not to vote. I don't think voting is really political. But what I do criticise is electoralism and there are plenty of U75 posters that do subscribe to that.
I don't disagree with much of what you say in the above. Mine was a very simplified take on the prevailing tone, primarily for the benefit of our amateur comrade who doesn't seem to do nuance or complexity particularly well.
 
Back
Top Bottom