Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

England cricket, 2019-20 winter tours

Yeah , Ali is still unavailable for red ball cricket. Jennings is an odd one but signals perhaps a new strategy of flexibility with selection depending on conditions. It might be a good idea as its always seemed a bit odd to insist a player must perform in all conditions. Some players are just better suited to certain conditions. We wouldn't take 3 spinners on other tours so why not bring a batsman who has a decent record in these conditions. Not that he'll get a game I reckon, not without a repeat of illness and football madness.
I agree that he won't start barring injury, but what if he gets a go in the second test and makes a double hundred? Is he then dropped for the summer to come back for India? It works more easily with bowlers than batsmen to do that.
 
To add to the above, yes, sometimes bowlers just aren't suited to certain conditions, but history shows us that top batsmen do well everywhere. If Jennings is a 'horse for a course' that means he's not a top batsman (well dur, county bowlers could tell you that, and two centuries plus a bunch of low scores isn't amazing. Can't we aim higher than that? Especially now with a bit of optimism around the place.
 
We've really struggled against high quality spin bowling in favorable conditions. I agree it seems counter intuitive but its interesting thinking nonetheless.
 
I guess they don't want an entirely new to SL top 3 - last tour the top 3 were Burns, Jennings with Ali, Stokes and Bairstow all tried at 3. Nothing too wrong with batsmen being picked as horses for courses, certainly happened a lot when facing Lillee, Thomson, the Windies etc back in the 70s and 80s. If it wasn't David Steele, fairly sure David Smith was picked to tour the Windies, Robin Smith apparently couldn't play spin..
 
I guess they don't want an entirely new to SL top 3 - last tour the top 3 were Burns, Jennings with Ali, Stokes and Bairstow all tried at 3. Nothing too wrong with batsmen being picked as horses for courses, certainly happened a lot when facing Lillee, Thomson, the Windies etc back in the 70s and 80s. If it wasn't David Steele, fairly sure David Smith was picked to tour the Windies, Robin Smith apparently couldn't play spin..
Before my time really, but on the face of it David Steele was a bit hard done by not to be given more opportunities after that, although he was already quite old and his county stats are ordinary (bit like Jennings).

I don't hate the idea, but SL have a couple of decent quicks as well at the moment. If anything their seamers are better than their spinners at the moment, and noises are that they may not prepare raging bunsens this time. Also, will Jennings survive to the spinners? I just don't think Jennings is that good tbh (Lancashire's fifth-best batsman last season), and yes two centuries against spin are very good, but he barely scored a run in his other innings on those series. Typical opener, you'd say - big scores and lots of low ones - but it's not entirely convincing to me.
 
Last edited:
Thought it probably wasn't worth starting a new thread for country cricket this year but take it people have seen that the ECB still seem to be pushing ahead with the fucking nonsense that is the hundred.
While a draft schedule has not been published, the T20 Blast similarly moves to the later summer months should staging cricket be possible – no given, Harrison admitted – though there was an absence of any guarantees that a meaningful County Championship can take place, only allocated blocks for “red-ball cricket”.

Concurrent Test and white-ball series could allow all four sets of men’s tourists to be hosted but if there is a further delay, the number of fixtures will start to drop off. Harrison, however, was unable to give any guarantees for the women’s team given the expense of needing to create the required “bio-secure” conditions behind closed doors.

Meanwhile a final decision on the Hundred being played this year has been delayed until Wednesday as the ECB works through the financial and legal implications of its seemingly inevitable postponement, including negotiations with broadcasters and compensation due to players (reported to be 12.5% the value of their contracts).
Also don't quite get the playing abroad thing, I suppose Aus and NZ might be secure but I don't see why playing in Dubai would be better than the UK
 
Might be of some interest to country cricket fans - Who is your county's greatest overseas player?

Lehman for Yorks - easily.

Has to be Imran for Sussex, despite being a twat. They have Steve Magoffin in the vote. Erm...

I once saw Javed Miandad get about 150 in a day for Sussex which included about half an hour of not scoring and DELIBERATELY edging the ball in order to bring the field in (he said this in interview afterwards). He was class. Bit of a twat too, but class.
 
Has to be Imran for Sussex, despite being a twat. They have Steve Magoffin in the vote. Erm...

I once saw Javed Miandad get about 150 in a day for Sussex which included about half an hour of not scoring and DELIBERATELY edging the ball in order to bring the field in (he said this in interview afterwards). He was class. Bit of a twat too, but class.
Could be quite a high twat count - Lehman certainly goes in that category.
 
Very varying lists in terms of strength in depth. No Jeetan Patel for Warks, yet a few journeymen get in elsewhere.

I would guess that Viv Richards will win the Somerset nomination, but I suspect that Joel Garner's yorkers were more important to their one-day successes in the early 80s than Viv's runs.

Greenidge to lose out to Marshall at Hants.

In fact, the WI quicks who I'd vote for are many: Walsh, Ambrose, Marshall, Holding, Daniel and Clarke must all win for their counties. But I grew up with them, so I'm biased. I started supporting Derbys cos Holding played for them. Always disappointed when he came in off his short run (which was always in the Sunday League, of course).
 
Zaheer Abbas and Courtney Walsh for Gloucestershire. I guess technically Murali too, although that was for the tip and run competition, so doesn't really count.
 
Back
Top Bottom