The39thStep
Urban critical thinker
If only the rejoiners would believe, and say 'I do believe in rejoining " three times before their bed time coco they would have the promised rejoin utopia by Thursday,
yes absolutely trueFair enough. Though dont think the window of another referendum under a different government was ever going to present itself
in the long term we're all deadyes absolutely true
the best meeting i took part in pre-referendum broadly concluded exit yes, but not now like this
but if this was the only opportunity then i can see the logic of going along with it whatever
but that requires the realism to recognise the choice was for the long term latent socialist potential at the price of the more certain immediate immiseration, deregulation, points based immigration etc etc
It doesnt. Links on EU inflation problems start to kick in and it turns into a panetonei wonder what happens when the green line goes below zero
Pan EU trade unions being illegal somewhat limited 'latent socialist potential'yes absolutely true
the best meeting i took part in pre-referendum broadly concluded exit yes, but not now like this
but if this was the only opportunity then i can see the logic of going along with it whatever
but that requires the realism to recognise the choice was for the long term latent socialist potential at the price of the more certain immediate immiseration, deregulation, points based immigration etc etc
Funny that cos all I see on this thread is acknowledgment from leavers brexit has had an impact and complete non acceptance of other factors from remainers. Agree though HMG official policy seems the denial you outlineEndlessly banging on like it’s still early 2016 and ignoring as much as possible anything about the brexit impacts that are actually unfolding seems to be the happy place for leavers on here. Apart from that good news about mackerel a couple of weeks ago. It’s quite weird but it’s also exactly the same as what the get brexit done government are doing so, understandable.
Seriously? Look at what happened when the issue of the expected imminent impact on workers rights was raised a little while back. nothing, just tumbleweed and then a post about mackerel.Funny that cos all I see on this thread is acknowledgment from leavers brexit has had an impact and complete non acceptance of other factors from remainers. Agree though HMG official policy seems the denial you outline
There's was the future once but it hasn't been for quite sometime AND as they are, having failed to get past 2016 ill prepared for any future referendum should it be called. That said . That said EU itself isn't much better the underlying problems are still the underlying problems 7 years have passed without reform at addressing them. But that's their problem , we have ours Thems that blindly parroting rejoin EU a solution are one of many.The rejoiners are enemies of progress and must be dealt with accordingly
And in the short term we're all fucked.in the long term we're all dead
--keynes
I don't think anyone would or has denied that workers rights are under attack but there's not really much scope for discussion here outside the neverending silly argument is there, likewise I think it was Colin Hunt who made just about the only substantial posts on this thread going into detail about the anti labour policies of the EU and got no response.Seriously? Look at what happened when the issue of the expected imminent impact on workers rights was raised a little while back. nothing, just tumbleweed and then a post about mackerel.
tbf, when presented with arguments that things are no different for workers within or without the supra state, some of us on here have questioned what all the fuss was about, then?I don't think anyone would or has denied that workers rights are under attack but there's not really much scope for discussion here outside the neverending silly argument is there, likewise I think it was Colin Hunt who made just about the only substantial posts on this thread going into detail about the anti labour policies of the EU and got no response.
Nobody would deny that workers rights are under attack in general sure but to a new and much increased degree as a direct result of brexit I mean: Nobody would deny that?I don't think anyone would or has denied that workers rights are under attack but
I'd agree brexit represents an opportunity to attack workers rights in some particular ways, I would disagree that it's new or to a much increased degree yes.Nobody would deny that workers rights are under attack in general sure but to a new and much increased degree as a direct result of brexit I mean: Nobody would deny that?
(not some other imaginary brexit i mean the actual one we are having).
You're the one with over 700 posts on the thread you tell me what the fuss istbf, when presented with arguments that things are no different for workers within or without the supra state, some of us on here have questioned what all the fuss was about, then?
That's OK, we're only 3 years in. There's a long way to fall yet.inva said:I'd agree brexit represents an opportunity to attack workers rights in some particular ways, I would disagree that it's new or to a much increased degree yes.
You're the one with over 700 posts on the thread you tell me what the fuss is
To be honest I wasn't aware of anyone having made an argument there's no difference although if that is what you think then I suppose congratulations are due for finding the weirdist position on a very weird thread
OK so to be clear your view is it makes no difference to workers which of those choices it is. Presumably it made no difference joining the EU/common market in the first place, none of its policies had any effect and neither did its technocratic depoliticisation of many of these issues, and with the vote to leave there's no difference still whether its in not being subject to current EU rules, or the repeal of EU derived legislation, or opportunities for further attacks on workers along those lines, for example.
tbh, I don't think it's at all weird to regard the tory plebiscite as a choice between 2 alternative means of accelerating neoliberal, supply-side reforms.
Latterly, quite a few of my posts have been in response to pro-brexit ("lexit") posters pointing out that whatever negative impact on workers' rights/conditions raised by the remain/rejoin minded posters is matched or already exists within the supra state. They appear to be making my argument for me.OK so to be clear your view is it makes no difference to workers which of those choices it is. Presumably it made no difference joining the EU/common market in the first place, none of its policies had any effect and neither did its technocratic depoliticisation of many of these issues, and with the vote to leave there's no difference still whether its in not being subject to current EU rules, or the repeal of EU derived legislation, or opportunities for further attacks on workers along those lines, for example.
Now of course there's legitimate reasons for not taking part in the referendum and there may be a solid argument that workers are not best served by being invested in the outcome either way, but to claim it makes no difference at all seems... bizarre. What on earth have you been posting about all this time!?
You seem a little reluctant to say whether you actually think that yourselfLatterly, quite a few of my posts have been in response to pro-brexit ("lexit") posters pointing out that whatever negative impact on workers' rights/conditions raised by the remain/rejoin minded posters is matched or already exists within the supra state. They appear to be making my argument for me.
The arrogance of this. At least Planet Remain exists. Planet Lexit doesn't.This, for me anyway, is a fundamental problem for Planet Remain. Here we have a poster snarkily conflating Frost's comments with mine. Whilst it might get a few likes from other Remain loons as a form of politics its at the level of the playground. It doesn't deserve comment and its not designed to stimulate serious debate.
Similarly, the habit on here of raising a question and then asking an entirely different one when it's answered is both tiresome and revealing of a lack of substance. The lack of any coherent argument, vision or ideas lost reman the war and it'll lose it the peace too whatever Mandelson, civil service mandarins and the captains of industry think.
I'm afraid sleaterkinney has ruined it and now we've all been cursed to go on arguing on this thread for another 2 yearsLast in!
You seem a little reluctant to say whether you actually think that yourself