Wonderwall - opinions

[el-ahrairah]

yet both bands made millions off their respective music.

Talentless?

Hardly.

oh for fuck sake, you don't need talent to get rich you fucking thatcherite. have you ever worked in the music industry?

 

[el-ahrairah]

neither blur nor oasis would have made the bus fair home if some wealthy middle class coke addled tory in the home counties hadn't seen a way of marketing them.

 

[BigMoaner]

how can you say they done a disservice to the working class when they were fucking loved by millions of working class kids?

 

[clcat]

oh for fuck sake, you don't need talent to get rich you fucking thatcherite. have you ever worked in the music industry?

Never been called a "Thatcherite" before but sticks and stones

 

[el-ahrairah]

fare, obv.

 

[Sirena]

Because I sort of work in the music business, I try to keep a general respect for all music and I try not to hate any music, even the stuff I don't really like.

I make a single exception for Oasis. I don't know if it's their whiny music or the twattish attitudes of the Gallagher brothers or their ugliness or the fact they hung around with Tony Blair or the fact that I was at a really nice party once when someone ruined it by insisting on putting on an Oasis album.... Or it could be a mixture of all this.

But I really can't cope with them.

 

[el-ahrairah]

how can you say they done a disservice to the working class when they were fucking loved by millions of working class kids?

the one doesn't equate to the other.

 

[el-ahrairah]

Never been called a "Thatcherite" before but sticks and stones

but that's a thatcherite attitude you're giving out. wealth = quality. it's bollocks innit.

look, you like their music and i don't, fair enough, but come on, at least make an argument based on an analysis of why you like them. do you like everything popular, is everything popular also the best?

 

[el-ahrairah]

oh god, i'd forgotten about all those wankers hanging around with tony blair.

 

[clcat]

but that's a thatcherite attitude you're giving out. wealth = quality. it's bollocks innit.

look, you like their music and i don't, fair enough, but come on, at least make an argument based on an analysis of why you like them. do you like everything popular, is everything popular also the best?

No, I'm just being objective as being subjective is just opinion.

 

[el-ahrairah]

 

[el-ahrairah]

No, I'm just being objective as being subjective is just opinion.

the pretence of neutrality

what other cunts went to downing street, it wasn't just that oasis idiot?

 

[free spirit]

neither blur nor oasis would have made the bus fair home if some wealthy middle class coke addled tory in the home counties hadn't seen a way of marketing them.

Not really sure you can call alan McGee a wealthy middle class home counties tory tbh, at least not back then.

 

[clcat]

I think the hate police still have a warrant out for Noel Gallagher meeting Tony Blair tbh so it's not all plain sailing being a successful musician

 

[el-ahrairah]

Not really sure you can call alan McGee a wealthy middle class home counties tory tbh, at least not back then.

i wasn't thinking of him really.

 

[DrRingDing]

Rocking all over the world

And I like it, I like it, I like it, I like it
I li-li-like it, li-li-like
Here we go, rockin' all over the world

You was more of a Chaz'n'Dave cheese farmer fan?

 

[clcat]

Not really sure you can call alan McGee a wealthy middle class home counties tory tbh, at least not back then.

I'm sure one of the former members of blur is now a pig farmer so that's ok for him to pass the hate police I guess

 

[Orang Utan]

yet both bands made millions off their respective music.

Talentless?

Hardly.

Plenty of talentless twerps make millions

 

[Orang Utan]

No, I'm just being objective as being subjective is just opinion.

You can't be objective about music

 

[clcat]

Plenty of talentless twerps make millions

I don't begrudge them

 

[el-ahrairah]

I'm sure one of the former members of blur is now a pig farmer so that's ok for him to pass the hate police I guess

look at this prick. to find this picture i searched "cheese twat"

 

[free spirit]

i wasn't thinking of him really.

ok, bit of an odd comment to make then.

 

[clcat]

You can't be objective about music

I was talking objectively about Oasis's recorded success not my opinion of their music.

 

[BigMoaner]

the pretence of neutrality

what other cunts went to downing street, it wasn't just that oasis idiot?

look at this prick. to find this picture i searched "cheese twat"

cricket bat to the side of head, i am ashamed to say. have that you cheese cunt

 

[fishfinger]

I'm sure one of the former members of blur is now a pig farmer so that's ok for him to pass the hate police I guess

If you mean Alex James, then I think you'll find he's pretty universally disliked. If that isn't enough, he's also a mate of David Cameron.

 

[Orang Utan]

look at this prick. to find this picture i searched "cheese twat"

Some classy quotes from his memoir here:
http://www.theguardian.com/lifeands...usion-david-cameron-jeremy-clarkson?CMP=fb_gu

 

[el-ahrairah]

ok, bit of an odd comment to make then.

no it wasn't.

alan mcghee didn't sign oasis and then nothing happened and then oasis sold a million trillion records and were at downing street. a lot of other wealthy middle class coke addled wankers had to decide to invest time and money on oasis on the principal that there would be a good return.

 

[clcat]

this one's for you



cricket bat to the side of head, i am ashamed to say. have that you cheese cunt

Cheesy can be good sometimes

 

[Orang Utan]

I was talking objectively about Oasis's recorded success not my opinion of their music.

The fact that you seem to regard record sales as an indicator of quality makes this untrue.

 

[clcat]

no it wasn't.

alan mcghee didn't sign oasis and then nothing happened and then oasis sold a million trillion records and were at downing street. a lot of other wealthy middle class coke addled wankers had to decide to invest time and money on oasis on the principal that there would be a good return.

Nothing wrong with a sound investment