Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Keir Starmer's time is up

This second film about antisemitism is quite upsetting.

It's going to take a herculean effort for the labour party to redeem itself, and they don't want to.

However, I don't want to embolden cranks like Asa Winstanley, Max Blumenthal, Jimmy Dore, Chris Williamson
 
Difficult to tell how many people are looking uncomfortable singing it because they're being forced to participate in a piece of reactionary fan service for disaffected Tories, and who's just wearing the universal uncomfortable face brought on by having to sing a janky, poorly-paced dirge with obviously silly lyrics.
 
I can see the point of Starmer saying something about the Queen's death in opening the conference tbh but don't really see where a stage managed singing of the National Anthem gets them

more positioning as an alternative conservative party in the hope of picking up a few more floating voters
 
Labour is increasingly acting like a cargo cult, just doing random pantomime nonsense in the hopes that the tabloid gods will be appeased and send them a few votes.
It started with New Labour.
It gets even more sad when one reads that twitter thread, with people showing photos of Kinnock and Brown as if that were "traditional" Labour - which it, of course, precisely isn't.
One of the characteristics of New Labour is nationalism, following in the footsteps of Thatcher.
The other point not being mentioned is of course the chauvinism and nationalism of Brexit, which Labour supported, meaning that the only english party representing the pro-EU voters - arguably now more than 50pc of voters - is the LibDem party.

Other points not being considered, though raised by Pickman's model is our relationship with the USA and its plans for Europe as a whole, of which, whether some like it or not, we are a part.

Things aren't going to quiet down and improve in our continent.
What's Starmers position or role on these matters?
We assume he's an atlanticist - anything else would be heresy in a NATO land non plus ultra such as the UK.
 
What's Starmers position or role on these matters?

whatever the most recent focus group said it should be...

The other point not being mentioned is of course the chauvinism and nationalism of Brexit, which Labour supported, meaning that the only english party representing the pro-EU voters - arguably now more than 50pc of voters - is the LibDem party.

dunno really

2017 labour said it would 'respect the result of the referendum', and got a swing big enough to bugger the tories' majority, and the lib dems didn't exactly do well.

2019 labour got in a tangle because starmer (among others) was insisting on being more remainy. and that didn't go well either.

i'm really not sure about the flag shagging thing, and not sure the labour party can 'win' this argument whatever it does here.

it's a favourite argument of the right wing and their friends in the press (not limited to this country) that the left (or less right) party 'is unpatriotic' / 'hates this country' if it criticises the establishment / status quo, or is less shitty about immigration, which is of course bollocks.

one alternative is labour MP's sneering at pictures of houses with 'union jack' / st george's cross flags and a white van outside...

does any form of patriotism have to extend to xenophobia / racism just because the right wing version of it does?

there is an argument (i'm not quite sure it's entirely sound) that labour / the left shouldn't abandon the union jack' to the far-right...

(none of the above implies support of starmer, i still think he's a waste of a suit)
 
Ms Idaho stumbled across him doing something at a local park. She heckled him and the minions ushered her to one side with the promise she could put her comments direct to the great man, which she later did. Her verdict on him was that he was surprisingly or unsurprisingly uncharismatic and unconvincing in real life. "Like that robot character on red dwarf".
 
Back
Top Bottom