layabout said:
What makes you think it would?
We are living in a completly different era where the populace is quite well educated.
I'm sorry, but at the end day, your notion that in a depression the general populace of this country would approve of a Nazi or facist government is absurd. Even if you was to argue that we can't risk such a thing from happening, the risks of banning a party or the use of political violence is a far bigger threat to the national security of this country than the remote, if not impossible odds of the populace getting behind a facist government with the intent of an agenda similar to Nazi Germany.
woah! nice try at answering the post you
wanted to answer, but no dice. Either go back and READ my post - properly - or at least take on board the following:
1) at NO point did I make ANY assumptions about the likely future political behaviour and affiliations of any part of the UK populace. I do NOT know how they would respond to another Great Depression, and nor do I know where they might stand in, say, 10 years' time. Nor, equally, what events might happen, and what the popular response would be. Nor do I really grasp the inner mental workings of why non-hardcore fash join that squalid little sect.
2. My whole point - absolutely obviously, I'd have thought - was that neither do you, and yet you are making some absolutley whopping assumptions on the motivations, behaviour, views, reactions etc of ALL - or as close to all as makes no odds - of the British public, based on godonlyknows what.
3. Equally, I did NOT say my compatriots would automatically rush into the arms of a UK Nazi party given economic disaster - I asked why YOU categorically, if implicitly, ruled such a scenario right out. My only contention is that it's possible. i.e. 'might'. different chappie to 'would'. yet YOUR words are;
remote, if not impossible odds of the populace getting behind a facist government
YOUR huge, whopping assumption. based on....nothing concrete whatsoever, AFAIK.
I repeat my question; what makes you so sure?
4. And - guess what! I did NOT advocate banning of far-right/fash parties-I'd rather have the little sods right out here, in the open, firstl7y 'cos their views look ridiculous as soon as held up to the light of sustained public debate, and seconde, because that way we can all keepan eye on them.
Now - do please READ my post again, and try again to answer it.
I'll simplify my key Q for you:
on what do you base your huge and sweeping assumptions on the likely political behaviour of the British People?