billy_bob
Air of bewilderment model's own
It's female Bond. Which is something else.
No it's not, it's a variation on the same thing. The clue's in the phrase 'female Bond'.
It's female Bond. Which is something else.
It had better be different. Otherwise it's a woman being a man. Might as well just keep it as a man if that is the case.No it's not, it's a variation on the same thing. The clue's in the phrase 'female Bond'.
its ok. The heroes are basically muggers though and thats never really addressed.My daughter mentioned that yesterday. I'll have to check it out.
That was my problem with it. I was on the side of the alienits ok. The heroes are basically muggers though and thats never really addressed.
But in the comment I quoted Bungle seems to link this fundamental character with the Doctor's biological maleness - or even (given that he's fine with all the other biological varieties the Doctor has exhibited over the years) to say that it depends exclusively on his being a man. So you can change anything else about the character's physical and personal manifestation (although I don't think Bungle ever answered the question about whether a black man would've been OK...) but if you mess with his dangly bits you've unacceptably altered who he is.
I don't want to put words in your mouth, AuntiStella, but I'm imagining you wouldn't go along with that?
It isn't a sex change Dr Who is an alien, not a man or ladyperson.Where has it been established that they can change sex? The Master doesn't count as that character has been jumping in and out of bodies that didn't belong to them for decades.
Where is the "debate" here? I've given my opinion, and the hoards he decided to shoot it down because they can't cope with it.
If people want high profile roles for woman they should go and create some, instead of insisting on a great male hero having a sex change.
i predict at no point will they ever discuss the sex of DrWho. It's appearance and gender identity that's changed. Do we even know if Time Lords have sex? Might they not have out evolved it a long time ago? (not a big Dr Who fan, sorry)It isn't a sex change Dr Who is an alien, not a man or ladyperson.
1. Hope you are right. Doubt you are.i predict at no point will they ever discuss the sex of DrWho. It's appearance and gender identity that's changed. Do we even know if Time Lords have sex? Might they not have out evolved it a long time ago? (not a big Dr Who fan, sorry)
yeah he's married to Alex Kingston and i'm 99% sure they bangDo we even know if Time Lords have sex?
it is possible - i just can't see the BBC ever going there. They struggle just doing a basic, human, every day trans character, so good luck to them if that's how they decide to go.1. Hope you are right. Doubt you are.
2. Appearance has changed (Earth is used to this by now). Funny how you are assuming gender id has changed. You discounting the possibility of this Doctor being a trans man in a female body. If all things are possible so is that.
children does not necessarily equal sex in science fiction (or fantasy).“The first thing he said to me, putting his arms up as if I was abut to strike him, [was], ‘Didn’t make any money from Night of the Living Dead,'” Matheson recalled. “‘Homage’ means I get to steal you work. He’s a nice guy, though. I don’t harbor any animosity toward him.” (Romero later confirmed this story: “I confessed to him that I basically ripped the idea off from I Am Legend. He forgave me because we didn’t make any money. He said, ‘Well, as long as you didn’t get rich, it’s okay.'”
I still can't see Dr Who's genitals and reproductive organs ever being discussed on what is a kids show.
but is this ever overtly stated on the show? Or is just done as a nod and a wink to the adult viewers - loosely implied rather than stated.yeah he's married to Alex Kingston and i'm 99% sure they bang
OK - family showIt's not a kids show.
the above obvs. Its a family show. for ages 6-deathbut is this ever overtly stated on the show? Or is just done as a nod and a wink to the adult viewers - loosely implied rather than stated.
She isn't married to River Song as marriage is only valid till death parts em.if Dr Who was realistic the British government would refuse to recognise her new gender until she divorced River Song and submitted herself to a panel of faceless bureaucrats with a foot deep pile of documentation to prove she was who she clearly was.
It had better be different. Otherwise it's a woman being a man. Might as well just keep it as a man if that is the case.
i predict at no point will they ever discuss the sex of DrWho. It's appearance and gender identity that's changed. Do we even know if Time Lords have sex? Might they not have out evolved it a long time ago? (not a big Dr Who fan, sorry)
I think that's what we would have got with Moffat in charge, I'm hopeful that the new guy will be a bit more subtle. I think it would be probably sensible if there's a bit of a time jump after the Christmas episode so we don't have all the post-regeneration stuff. Introduce the new characters who then happen to meet the new Doctor, who doesn't ever really remark upon the change, unless she runs into past characters at some point.I predict what they'll do is script a bunch of smirky but slightly oblique references to it, none of which are nearly as clever as the writers think they are and which will be grating on all of us by about 3m into the second episode of the next series.
They should have a special guest for post regeneration reaction.
Bungle73 ?
and ask, "need help parking that, TARDIS, love?"He could pop up in a branch of John Lewis, sell her some pot pourri and throw cushions for the Tardis.