Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Disgusted by a culture of entitlement? Nurses should be leftwing?

Oh there's no doubt that you get bigots of every political persuasion and I do think it is a myth that the left or some how a nicer bunch of people than the right. However, most acts of charity come from people who aren't loaded. They may not give as much in terms of wealth or time (time perhaps being a more important commodity?) but as group they give more - if that makes sense.

Edit: Geri said it more succinct :D
 
Oh there's no doubt that you get bigots of every political persuasion and I do think it is a myth that the left or some how a nicer bunch of people than the right. However, most acts of charity come from people who aren't loaded. They may not give as much in terms of wealth or time (time perhaps being a more important commodity?) but as group they give more - if that makes sense.
Evidence?
 
Studies mainly in America, the NY Times had quite a large piece on it last year. Give me a moment to dig it up.

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/22/magazine/22FOB-wwln-t.html?_r=1

For decades, surveys have shown that upper-income Americans don’t give away as much of their money as they might and are particularly undistinguished as givers when compared with the poor, who are strikingly generous.

...

In 2001, Independent Sector, a nonprofit organization focused on charitable giving, found that households earning less than $25,000 a year gave away an average of 4.2 percent of their incomes; those with earnings of more than $75,000 gave away 2.7 percent.

There's similar studies over here by Centre Point IIRC.
 
What Mrs Magpie said. My decision to become a nurse definitely was affected by my socialism, but nurses vary. Anecdotally I'd say mental health nurses tend to be more left wing than others, but I used to work with a very right wing Mail reader who was very good at her job. I did mental health in A&E for over six years and for every exasperating frequent attender who might lead you to question your left wing beliefs there would be the person who had had their benefits stopped or had shitty accommodation, their refugee claim turned down, and many other examples, that led me personally to be even more convinced of my beliefs. You go in with your own beliefs and prejudices and your experience confirms them regardless I suspect.

That's the reasonable bit done. I have always thought that purely for self interest nurses voting Tory is remarkably stupid. You might as well burn cash Klf style if that's all you're interested in. You'd think that experience would stop people even if they have been brutalised beyond repair by their job.
 
Evidence?

My OH is fascinating on this stuff, cos it's his job to analyse that kind of data in the third sector. Not sure if I can persuade him to post this evening though, I think he's done one post about Boris being trapped and has probably had enough for one day :D
 
My OH is fascinating on this stuff, cos it's his job toet analyse that kind of data in the third sector. Not sure if I can persuade him to post this evening though, I think he's done one post about Boris being trapped and has probably had enough for one day :D

I was thinking of him when I was reading this thread, wondering if he'd say something, hehe.

He's tweeted, posted on my Facebook and on here. Poor bugger must be knackered :(
 
he was also a megalomaniac who paid his workers in credits which they could only use at the local shop in his pre-built town, Saltaire. if you ever go he has the place surrounded by statues of himself, there's even one in the church - and the whole town had his spies employed and living in the large end-of-terraces at street corners enforcing his often bizarre and authoritarian rules. Saltaire workers lived in something resembling a totalitarian state
 
dylan redefined became more a more a stalinist before he gave up nursing :(
bill gates is possibly going to give malaria a massive kicking he's spent more in a couple of years than goverments have in thirty:eek:
he's scarily geeky about it as well one scientist who met him he gave him a reading list of 25 book and reports thinking that would be the last he heard.
6 months later gates had read 20 of them.
 
geminisnake said:
Did you ask for an explanation of the thinking behind that?? Think I would have had to.
WTF have tattoos got to do with anything?? They don't have an adverse affect on your health/ability to get a job/life, etc afaik :confused:

Plenty of professional jobs would look at visible tattoos as being a negative.
 
he was also a megalomaniac who paid his workers in credits which they could only use at the local shop in his pre-built town, Saltaire. if you ever go he has the place surrounded by statues of himself, there's even one in the church - and the whole town had his spies employed and living in the large end-of-terraces at street corners enforcing his often bizarre and authoritarian rules. Saltaire workers lived in something resembling a totalitarian state
We're getting close to "work for your tesco vouchers in tescos" tbh now. Only difference is the state will be paying and there won't be any need to house your workers either.
 
Plenty of professional jobs would look at visible tattoos as being a negative.

Yeah, I wonder if you could even get into med school if you had one? I've never seen a doctor with a visible tat, ever.
 
Back
Top Bottom