Key scientific data and advice the UK government is using to guide its covid-19 response won’t be published until the pandemic ends. Documents used to make decisions and the minutes of meetings of the Scientific Advisory Group on Emergencies (SAGE) will only be made public when the current outbreak is brought under control, according to Patrick Vallance, the government’s chief scientific adviser.
In a letter sent earlier this month to MP Greg Clark, who chairs the House of Commons science and technology committee, Vallance said: “Once SAGE stops convening on this emergency the minutes of relevant SAGE meetings, supporting documents and the names of participants (with their permission) will be published.”
“I think they should be sharing who the key people are and minutes of their meetings,” says Devi Sridhar, a public health scientist at the University of Edinburgh, UK, who also signed the letter published in The Lancet. “I think transparency is incredibly important and we’ve taken this route in the Scottish Government Covid-19 Advisory Group. We share the names of members and minutes.”
The refusal to publish minutes of the advisory group meetings until the pandemic is over also contradicts the UK government’s own guidance. The 2011 Code of Practice for Scientific Advisory Committees says meeting minutes should be published “as soon as possible” and written in an “unattributable form” – meaning there is no need to identify members. Advisory committees “should operate from a presumption of openness” the code says, and also publish meeting agendas and final advice.
Withering article in the Sunday Times. What has Johnson done or more likely not done to piss Murdoch off?
I can do screenshots, yes.Paywall. Do you have screenshots or summat? We could all do with seeing a bit of cunt on cunt violence in these dark times.
Paywall. Do you have screenshots or summat? We could all do with seeing a bit of cunt on cunt violence in these dark times.
Edit: just found this:
Ooops (but thanks anyway. Your screenshots are much better!).
888. They abolished it when TV went digital.Why isn't the BBC reporting total number of deaths? How odd.
Ooops (but thanks anyway. Your screenshots are much better!).
Withering article in the Sunday Times. What has Johnson done or more likely not done to piss Murdoch off?
Boris Johnson claims his Covid-19 response is “led by the science”. But one look at the expert advice his Cobra committee received suggests his government resisted being led too quickly. Advice to the government in February recommended closing bars and schools – actions the government didn’t take until late March.
The earliest paper, from 11 February, on “stopping large public gatherings”, makes a strong case that while cancelling big events would not be particularly effective, “stopping all leisure activities, including public gatherings such as at bars and restaurants, would be expected to have a much larger effect”. Johnson did not close pubs until 20 March, well over a month later.
Subsequent papers show there was much debate among experts and the argument was not cut and dried. But they give a distinct impression of early advice being much stronger than the actions the prime minister actually took.
Yup, Gove very popular among Westminster bubble, which tells you all you need to know about them.It may be that Murdoch prefers Gove and with Johnson's abysmal non-handling of the pandemic the writing is on the wall.
Well to a point, not seen any evidence that an aggressive suppression and elimination strategy was even suggested by "the science", nor, if it was, any reason that the government would've rejected it in favour of "herd immunity" and the horrors of its attendant death toll.Private Eye Magazine | Official Site - the UK's number one best-selling news and current affairs magazine, edited by Ian Hislop
The official site for Private Eye magazine, the UK's number one best-selling news and current affairs publication edited by Ian Hislop. Subscribe here for only £45 a year.www.private-eye.co.uk
Gove's decision to 'self-isolate' always looked significant.Yup, Gove very popular among Westminster bubble, which tells you all you need to know about them.
He's also smart enough to know he wants to keep a very low profile ATM, so that'd be an absolute last resort.
They are all available here, including the 11 February and 26 February papers mentioned in the article.Azrael I was wondering if the papers referred to in the Private Eye article are publicly available somewhere or are still unreleased.
He managed to get the affected party tested, (which irritated some) the test was negative and he was later photographed out running. So he hasn't been isolating for some time.Gove's decision to 'self-isolate' always looked significant.
Time enough to get his ducks in a row and avoid some of the growing shitstorm.He managed to get the affected party tested, (which irritated some) the test was negative and he was later photographed out running. So he hasn't been isolating for some time.
No, too valuable a resource at the momentNot sure he'll have a job for much longer