Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

14th November Movement for Left Unity

Presumably a few of those 1250 (up 50 since the conference!) members are on a direct debit, so they'd have some money for a worker. Tho not quite enough to stand in all the seats they want to.
 
Presumably a few of those 1250 (up 50 since the conference!) members are on a direct debit, so they'd have some money for a worker. Tho not quite enough to stand in all the seats they want to.
Just seems to me that it will eat up a huge amount of their income, especially as they also say they will have to sort out office space, which means rent and then there is equipment as well. If you only have one part time worker, why can't they just work from home?

They are only asking for £2 per month membership.
 
Would you want all a national party's paperwork, finances and people cluttering up your home? A part timer and an office should be doable on a grand a month. Whichshouldntb e beyond there means considering how successful they are going to be. I mean, are already.
 
Would you want all a national party's paperwork, finances and people cluttering up your home? A part timer and an office should be doable on a grand a month. Whichshouldntb e beyond there means considering how successful they are going to be. I mean, are already.
Just seems a big investment to me. But I suppose if they need it, they need it.
 
That's a link to a link to a tweet in which she says she's - very controversially admittedly - clearing some nappies up during a binmen strike.

"Personally, don't think picking dirty nappies from street & putting in bag on side of road undermines importance of strike"
Doing the work of people on strike is the definition of scab, surely?

Although see J Ed's post after mine.
 
Doing the work of people on strike is the definition of scab, surely?

Although see J Ed's post after mine.
Was that what she was doing?

Sounds to me that she was just picking up some shit and putting it in a bag to be collected. Perhaps the bag had been vandalised or chewed up by foxes or something. I think, given the particulars, that isn't unreasonable. It's not the same as driving the bin lorry and collecting it yourself and would probably make the binmen's job easier when they have to go back and pick up all the shit that's spilled onto the streets in the meantime.

Am I wrong?
 
Was that what she was doing?

Sounds to me that she was just picking up some shit and putting it in a bag to be collected. Perhaps the bag had been vandalised or chewed up by foxes or something. I think, given the particulars, that isn't unreasonable. It's not the same as driving the bin lorry and collecting it yourself and would probably make the binmen's job easier when they have to go back and pick up all the shit that's spilled onto the streets in the meantime.

Am I wrong?
In pretty much everything you post - yes.
 
Stop pretending. Admit that that tactic has failed and summary new needs trying. But no, they'll carry on regardless getting embarrassingly tiny votes and pretending they're successes.

I don' t know if they are pretending they're successes. I do know that they have an uphill struggle: they don't get a platform in the media (look at how much time is given to Ukip ffs), they operate in a fucked up democracy in a capitalist system. The odds are totally against them. Now maybe they are on a hiding to nowhere, in which case, again, what do they do?
 
I don' t know if they are pretending they're successes. I do know that they have an uphill struggle: they don't get a platform in the media (look at how much time is given to Ukip ffs), they operate in a fucked up democracy in a capitalist system. The odds are totally against them. Now maybe they are on a hiding to nowhere, in which case, again, what do they do?
If they are on a 'hiding to nowhere'( :confused: ) then why defend repeating the action that lead to the hiding? You seem to want to want it every which way - how on earth do you square this series of posts about TUSC and the greens with your plea for people to vote labour? Incoherent.
 
I don't even know what this means.

This all seems entirely self destructive.

It means a number of things.

Initiatives such as Left Unity occur every few years with numbing regularity.

By and large it's exactly the same people, having exactly the same discussions/arguments every single time.

And every time they do exactly the same things with exactly the same results.

Yet they carry on regardless.
 
I don' t know if they are pretending they're successes. I do know that they have an uphill struggle: they don't get a platform in the media (look at how much time is given to Ukip ffs), they operate in a fucked up democracy in a capitalist system. The odds are totally against them. Now maybe they are on a hiding to nowhere, in which case, again, what do they do?
UKIP have 13 MEPs many councillors and poll solidly in the medium to high teens. The comparison with TUSC is miles off. What is this media obsession as well?
 
It means a number of things.

Initiatives such as Left Unity occur every few years with numbing regularity.

By and large it's exactly the same people, having exactly the same discussions/arguments every single time.

And every time they do exactly the same things with exactly the same results.

Yet they carry on regardless.

I'm not aware of other attempts. All i know is that the left seems hell bent on self destruction while the soceity is torn to shit by right wingers racists, bigots, corporations and cunts. It'd be nice to have some answers.

In next years vote the only choices on my ballot paper will be either Tory, who recently took over from the Libdems, who have traditionally held sway here. Labour won't get a look in, but are the only real chance of ousting this nighmare even though they aren't up to much. The rest are independent candidates, like Katie Hopkins, or BNP (if they stand - or some other England for teh English party) or UKip.

No left choice at all. Something needs to change, but it seems noone wants that to happen; either, as you say, through self destruction, or through sniping from the sidelines. Open season for the right wing gutter press.
 
Dump the shit name, say no to the truly truly awful No2EU rubbish, stand in far fewer seats. Would be a start.
Surely then they'll be seen as pro-EU lefy commie types? They can't win.

In the local elections last year Radio Bristol had a 'discussion' with the candidates. Even ukip got invited. Tusc only got a mention as 'tusc are also standing'. Noone was invited to speak from them nor was their cause even explained. They were relegated to the same platform as the Monster Raving party.
 
So how do they break thorugh if they can't even get invited to a discussion to at least put their point across?

Seems unfair to criticise them for the system they have to operate in.
 
Back
Top Bottom