Sorry, I just objected to this whole idea of 'you got something defective, the charity didn't do a proper job so return it for a refund' thing. I was disgusted by that.
oh dear.
can't say i'm entirely impressed by your choice to misinterpret my words to try to start another session of shitstirring and whittering.
but in explanation for those who prefer to discuss rather than play these stupid games.
the interests of the cats are paramount. it is in the interests of the cats to be socialised, by people that th shelter know can handle this process and with a support network to assist them in this process. it reduces their stress and means they are more likely to be rehomed rather than left in a shelter for a year. and that the rehoming is more likely to be successful. sending out poorly socialised cats is more likely to be deeply stressful to them and it means the adoption is less likely to be successful.
and sometimes it's best to admit defeat, particularly when there's other animals involved. if the situation between them cannot be resolved and keeps causing the animals involved a great deal of stress, it is time to put the human ego aside and act in the interests of the animals and seek another home for them. the only failure in that scenario would be in a refusal to consider that as an option when it was clear that there was no way to make the situation work. because that would be the decision that the animals needed the people to take, in their best interests.
and thinking some more about what is being described, the female is protecting the humans. which is very likely influenced by the fear the boys are showing. if their fear reactions had been reduced before placing them in a home with another pet, then the level of strife between the cats would probably have been less and everything would be just that little bit further along.
What do you do with the ferals though?
Also bear in mind that socialisation is usually done by unpaid volunteers.
Have YOU volunteered recently?
for your info, i'm both an employee and a volunteer (in different sections) of an animal charity. i'm also on the list of cat fosterers.
that's a national charity btw. who use animal fosterers wherever they operate.
and YOU? what's your credentials that give you the right to try to call out others for having opinions and not being an active volunteer?
and ferals tend to be handled by spey and release. not only in rural areas, but also in towns. they aren't going to be part of a discussion on socialisation, because they aren't going to be placed into a home. those that can't be released in situ tend to be released into a safer area with the agreement of the land holder. or kept by volunteers who keep them in outdoor pens. someone who knows how cat charities operate would know this already and know that the number of feral cats in an area is not going to be part of a discussion on number of cats needing socialisation.