I feel we're missing some Japanoise on this thread. Here's some Violent Onsen Geisha to rectify that.
I love how the top rated albums on ratemymusic change over the decades - in the 1960s & 70s there's lots of variety, plenty of canon albums everyone has heard of... by 1991 the first page is almost exclusively obscure death metal and post rock.
I dunno if it makes sense to think of it as being one singular canon? Like, as well Public Enemy, there's releases by a fair few of the big names of West Coast hip-hop (Ices both Cube and T, plus the Cube-less NWA album), those are certainly part of a canon?I'm not on the same page as the RYM crowd, but I must admit that when it gets to about 1978 or so and beyond I'm at a complete loss as to what the canon actually is anymore. In 91 there's Nevermind and that fluffy clouds album from The Orb but aside from that I'm totally clueless as to what hip people were listening to.
It's not really hip people who make the canon though is it? It's bands that have a wider appeal beyond the hip - there was huge albums by Red Hot Chilli Peppers, Pearl Jam, Guns & Roses, Metallica - none of them appeal to me very much, but they're definitely Rock Canon albums, and albums which were similarly successful from bands at similar points in their careers in previous eras would be much further up the rankings than they are in 1991I'm not on the same page as the RYM crowd, but I must admit that when it gets to about 1978 or so and beyond I'm at a complete loss as to what the canon actually is anymore. In 91 there's Nevermind and that fluffy clouds album from The Orb but aside from that I'm totally clueless as to what hip people were listening to.
I dunno if it makes sense to think of it as being one singular canon? Like, as well Public Enemy, there's releases by a fair few of the big names of West Coast hip-hop (Ices both Cube and T, plus the Cube-less NWA album), those are certainly part of a canon?
Listening to this now and it's a lot of fun, it's just horny disco music for people who like satan a bit. Not something I'd want to listen to all day every day but definitely has its place as part of a balanced diet.Checking further, My Life With the Thrill Kill Kult did Sexplosion...
It's not really hip people who make the canon though is it? It's bands that have a wider appeal beyond the hip - there was huge albums by Red Hot Chilli Peppers, Pearl Jam, Guns & Roses, Metallica - none of them appeal to me very much, but they're definitely Rock Canon albums, and albums which were similarly successful from bands at similar points in their careers in previous eras would be much further up the rankings than they are in 1991
they're totally wrong on Lulu thoughRYM are getting one thing right wrt Metallica massive dip in the ratings when it comes to the black album .
they're totally wrong on Lulu though
have a break from '91 and stick it on nowI knew you were going to say that . Never got round to listening to it tbh.
The Public Enemy/Anthrax collaboration is perhaps regrettable for helping to set in motion a chain of events that would eventually lead to nu-metal, but it's thrilling in its way:Oh yes of course. I wasn't into hip hop at the time. Much more open to it now though. Hip hop me up, please!
Wonder Stuff were, are and always will be total dogshit. My best mate's girlfriend copped off with Miles Hunt at Reading '92. These two facts are entirely unrelated.Wonder Stuff
The Public Enemy/Anthrax collaboration is perhaps regrettable for helping to set in motion a chain of events that would eventually lead to nu-metal, but it's thrilling in its way:
Very good record
Just listened to it again, can confirm this is definitely the best song of 1991 if not the entire twentieth century, Nirvana wish they could've written this:Wonder Stuff were, are and always will be total dogshit. My best mate's girlfriend copped off with Miles Hunt at Reading '92. These two facts are entirely unrelated.
Not sure about his top ten, but his favourite album of the year was that sublime mixture of Byrdsian melodies, Big Stars power pop and Stooges noise, Bandwagonesque.Might well have been in Kurt's?
Maybe not….I always bracket them with Skinny Puppy tho, just noise (bloody glorious noise)I do, but I wouldn't think of it as being industrial?