Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

The ongoing stupidity of Home Secretary Priti Patel

I look forward to her getting the bill for a day's use of an A400M, a Shadow R1, and a Poseidon MR1 - it's an amusing spectacle, when ministers from other govt departments discover that the MOD bills them for using military assets to cover for their catastrophic failures of policy - err... I mean to help them manage unforeseable events...
Especially as, going on current form, she probably has a mate with a Cessna and a pair of binoculars who could have done the job for twice the price.
 
If someone drowns, she runs a high risk of the officers in charge simply refusing their orders. Which would be a damned sight more embarrassing than a few refugees landing on the shores. The Navy isn't going to shoot or ram anyone - they'd refuse that before anyone got hurt. So what's the point of involving them at all?
 
If someone drowns, she runs a high risk of the officers in charge simply refusing their orders. Which would be a damned sight more embarrassing than a few refugees landing on the shores. The Navy isn't going to shoot or ram anyone - they'd refuse that before anyone got hurt. So what's the point of involving them at all?
I hope you are right. I hope that the Navy is moral enough to refuse the order.
 
7un
If someone drowns, she runs a high risk of the officers in charge simply refusing their orders. Which would be a damned sight more embarrassing than a few refugees landing on the shores. The Navy isn't going to shoot or ram anyone - they'd refuse that before anyone got hurt. So what's the point of involving them at all?
Because unlike you, someone who spent perhaps 2 minutes composing those thoughts and committing them to writing, Priti Patel cannot think further than the end of her nose. I'd have said "cheekbones", but when she's got that supercilious sneer on, they probably protrude further than the end of her nose.
 
Good luck with that.
Oh, I think they'll refuse the order, but not on the grounds of morality. Over time, a lot of sailors have owed their lives to the willingness of other sailors to set aside differences and come to their aid - it's a pretty embedded part of the culture, regardless of laws or morality. I don't think that a typical RN officer would even countenance an action that would be blatantly and brutally inimical to that culture, and far less be seen to do so.
 
Oh, I think they'll refuse the order, but not on the grounds of morality. Over time, a lot of sailors have owed their lives to the willingness of other sailors to set aside differences and come to their aid - it's a pretty embedded part of the culture, regardless of laws or morality. I don't think that a typical RN officer would even countenance an action that would be blatantly and brutally inimical to that culture, and far less be seen to do so.

Like they helped those lads on the Belgrano.
 
I, for one, would hope that MOD never makes a cabinet minister look like a complete moron purely to ensure that said cabinet minister never got the opportunity to preside over MOD....

The RN is no more about to ram migrant boats than the Army is going to machine gun the queues outside the immigration tribunal - they will provide (astonishingly expensive) surveillance assets, and platforms for the BF to pick people put of the water, but that's it. If she thought otherwise, she's the fuckwit everyone had long suspected....
 
If someone drowns, she runs a high risk of the officers in charge simply refusing their orders. Which would be a damned sight more embarrassing than a few refugees landing on the shores. The Navy isn't going to shoot or ram anyone - they'd refuse that before anyone got hurt. So what's the point of involving them at all?

Because for a certain tory-voting demographic, war (talk of it, images of it, not the actual experience of it) is their favourite thing. It being meaningless or contrary to basic decency and international law has nothing to do with it.
 
Priti Patel tells Tory MPs that migrants 'flock to Britain' because France is racist.

Even a stopped clock.

It is absolutely correct that many people who try to get to the UK have been mistreated elsewhere in Europe. Same reason people in France dread getting their fingerprints taken and getting Schengened back to Greece or Italy, where conditions are even worse.

Anecdotally it seems that the Belgian state is among the most brutal in Europe. But it's a race to the bottom throughout the EU. The stuff Patel has made (probably empty) threats of doing in the channel has been happening on a huge scale in the mediterranean for years already, and international law be buggered.
 
Even a stopped clock.

It is absolutely correct that many people who try to get to the UK have been mistreated elsewhere in Europe. Same reason people in France dread getting their fingerprints taken and getting Schengened back to Greece or Italy, where conditions are even worse.

Anecdotally it seems that the Belgian state is among the most brutal in Europe. But it's a race to the bottom throughout the EU. The stuff Patel has made (probably empty) threats of doing in the channel has been happening on a huge scale in the mediterranean for years already, and international law be buggered.
Indeed; my mate Mo from the Parisian banlieues has always explained his move to London on the basis of the push factors of French racism.
 
Oh, I think they'll refuse the order, but not on the grounds of morality. Over time, a lot of sailors have owed their lives to the willingness of other sailors to set aside differences and come to their aid - it's a pretty embedded part of the culture, regardless of laws or morality. I don't think that a typical RN officer would even countenance an action that would be blatantly and brutally inimical to that culture, and far less be seen to do so.
I think it's also that - historically - the First Law Of The Sea is that the preservation of human life is paramount, except in times of war. I may be wrong in this, but I thin k this was also ratified as such by UN Convention
 
France is a racist country though and refugees are treated terribly by the police, they do so cos the orders come down from on high. As a country that ravaged Africa it has a large number of people from those former colonies but they are mostly pushed out of sight in to ghettos in the suburbs of Paris and Marseille and so on.
In the UK we have a Muslim mayor of London and a Hindu chancellor of the exchequer (feted perhaps to become PM one day) and no one bats an eyelid at that.
Not to say the number of racist people in France is more or less than the Uk, I just don’t know, but the state set up certainly is.
 
Back
Top Bottom