Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

The Dominic Cummings file

What does this bit actually mean do you reckon

"Johnson, who is a civil libertarian at heart, spent the week resisting Cummings's demands for a full-blown lockdown of London — banning inhabitants from travelling outside the city.
Discussions about a shutdown were first aired at Cobra on Friday the 13th. By Tuesday the news was leaking after a Cabinet Office official emailed other departments to ask how a curfew might work. A Whitehall insider said: "It was quickly established that the Paris model — with people being issued paperwork and allowed out of the family home one at a time would not work."
A senior Tory said: "Boris really doesn't want to shut stuff down. He is more worried than most about the economic impact but also the social impact of locking people up in their homes for months. Fundamentally there is a Boris-Dom cleavage. First Boris bottled herd immunity. Now he's bottling lockdown."

What makes us different from France in this?
 
British exceptionalism.

I do think it's avoidable but it needs a massive step up in message from government. So unavoidable then
 
"Johnson had also been queasy about the previous original approach."

When you're not quite happy at the idea of hundreds of thousands of people dying, but you go along with it anyway cos Dom persuaded you.
I would take this whole story as a work of fiction, tbh. Cummings must know that part of his job is to take the fall when his master needs saving.
 
I would take this whole story as a work of fiction, tbh. Cummings must know that part of his job is to take the fall when his master needs saving.

True, though he knows he is the last man to get thrown under the bus - there is an entire government, civil service and the indestructible Corbyn to go before him.
 
yeah possibly, but I think the whole situation reflects worse on TCJ than Cummings.
Whatever Cummings has advised, it is Johnson's decision to make, and yes, this attempted distancing of himself from his decisions makes him look terrible. But it is still better for him to have Cummings saying the unthinkable about deaths rather than Johnson himself. That's Cummings' function. A very public sacking after saying the unthinkable and it being the wrong thing will also serve a function.
 
All that said, the reported story does sound all too believable. Cummings clearly does think he's a genius, and he prides himself on being 'up' on science, so the idea that he would consider his own opinion on the science to be superior to that of the scientists telling him about it is very plausible.
 
I make informed consumer choices after considering all of the available evidence.
You are subliminally influenced by advertising because you do not have the the insight to recognise it, or the strength to reject it.
He/she is a sheep.

Only sheeple believe that, motherfucker!
 
True, though he knows he is the last man to get thrown under the bus - there is an entire government, civil service and the indestructible Corbyn to go before him.
I think they'll throw the chief medical and scientific officers under there first. "We were just listening to the experts"

Like all good government specialist advisors in the UK, they provide the expert backing for whatever batshit crazy policy their masters think up. Just look at the state of the ACMD
 
Thing is, Cummings has done his job now really. He got Johnson elected, and with a big majority. Whatever happens to him now, he's been a success. :(
 
I think they'll throw the chief medical and scientific officers under there first. "We were just listening to the experts"

Like all good government specialist advisors in the UK, they provide the expert backing for whatever batshit crazy policy their masters think up. Just look at the state of the ACMD

they are doing that now, tbh - "the science was wrong" etc
 
Back
Top Bottom