Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Saudi gang rape victim sentenced to lashes and prison

He says he's a revert so maybe he hasn't had much time to learn much, He seems to have got most of his teaching from extremists, not scholars.

Fattboy, when did you become a Muslim, and what led you to decide to become one?
 
I don't think it's that people are denying that "these kind of muslims exist", and of course we should continue to challenge such ideas as and when we meet them regardless of their originator, but we should be aware that there's a concerted attempt by a small number of sock-puppets to fake extremist discourse on uk message boards as well.

BK, I asked a similar question of him, and he answered here: http://www.urban75.net/vbulletin/showthread.php?p=6917313&highlight=catholic#post6917313
 
Thanks IP, reading the other thread now, and found this.

fattboy said:
basically, i was chatting 2 a neighbour (and now like my best friend) about Iraq and things that were happening and we'd always end up chatting about Islam, and the more i learnt about it, the more i saw of muslims, the manners, the importance placed on family and dedication 2 the religion the more i loved it and realised this is like what i always kinda believed and wished christianity was more like.
anyway this brothers family never really placed much emphasis on religion, but he was kind of thru with his party days but wasnt really established in the local pakistani masjid and most of his friends he grew up with were settling down with their families and advising him 2 do the same, and they all went 2 the salafi masjid, so we did, not cos i knew enough about the difference between the groups, but as i attended classes and circles i realised the importance of following the salaf, so it was a blessing how it worked out cos i dont know how id have felt about Islam if the brother brought me 2 some of the other masjids.

Hmmmmmmmmm.
I have met quite a few people who come out with exactly the same stuff as he comes out with, so I am more inclined to think he is genuine now,

and someone who has been spoon-fed this stuff by hardliners, more's the pity.
 
mmm... Maybe I could start questioning him about Catholicism to see how much of what he wrote in that post is true?

salaam.
 
Badger Kitten said:
I have met quite a few people who come out with exactly the same stuff as he comes out with, so I am more inclined to think he is genuine now,

and someone who has been spoon-fed this stuff by hardliners, more's the pity.

It is possible, however it looks suspicious to me that he chose this message board to "bring the Radical message". It's not that U75 has a reputation of being fertile ground for Radicals to be welcolmed with open arms and to recruit sympathisers to their cause, is it.

salaam.
 
nino_savatte said:
But some of us on this thread (who aren't Muslim) seem to know more about Islam than he does.

This is what I find so odd.

There is stuff that people who've been brought up in a religion kind of miss learning about it and vice versa. when i was doing my conversion course i learned the symbolism behind loads of shit that the average joseph bloggenstein doesn't have a clue about. I've forgotten most of it now. But there is loads of stuff i don't know anything about and then when i meet an orthodox person who knows absolutely everything about what rules there are and stuff that i'm blatantly doing wrong (or would be doing wrong if i was orthodox) i just think "wtf"!

In Islam it's different because from what i've heard, you convert and THEN learn about the practice of it, and of course fanatics would skate over the more "tolerant" parts of islam, different opinions, etc, so the teaching agenda may well be what THEY want you to know and other stuff would just get brushed aside.

i havent seen anything so far that is a glaring error that anyone knowing anything about islam in terms of practicing it, no matter what their religious persuasion was, would blatantly know and not get wrong
 
Aldebaran said:
It is possible, however it looks suspicious to me that he chose this message board to "bring the Radical message". It's not that U75 has a reputation of being fertile ground for Radicals to be welcolmed with open arms and to recruit sympathisers to their cause, is it.

salaam


Evangelising on any subject is more or less trolling when the audience are clearly disinterested, and the poster a single-issue bore.

See conspiraloons.

He is scattering his seed on rocks, anyway, and if he wants to carry on surely it is only a matter of time before he FAQs-up ( I thought proselytizing was frowned upon).
 
Badger Kitten said:
Thanks IP, reading the other thread now, and found this.



Hmmmmmmmmm.
I have met quite a few people who come out with exactly the same stuff as he comes out with, so I am more inclined to think he is genuine now,

and someone who has been spoon-fed this stuff by hardliners, more's the pity.

yep. :(
 
frogwoman said:
In Islam it's different because from what i've heard, you convert and THEN learn about the practice of it,

No, it isn't. Every serious Imam of every serious mosque would educate anyone who expressed the wish to become Muslim for an amount of time before he takes the shahada. That period should be long and intense enough to be sure of the person's intentions and willingness sto tudy Islam and live the life of a Muslim.

salaam.
 
frogwoman said:
i havent seen anything so far that is a glaring error that anyone knowing anything about islam in terms of practicing it, no matter what their religious persuasion was, would blatantly know and not get wrong

Everything I saw of his postings so far is blatantly wrongly twisted.

salaam.
 
Aldebaran said:
No, it isn't. Every serious Imam of every serious mosque would educate anyone who expressed the wish to become Muslim for an amount of time before he takes the shahada. That period should be long and intense enough to be sure of the person's intentions and willingness sto tudy Islam and live the life of a Muslim.

salaam.

OK, thanks for correcting me.
It's jsut that i've heard from quite a few people that it's the other way round, but thanks for putting me straight on that one
xx
 
Aldebaran said:
Everything I saw of his postings so far is blatantly wrongly twisted.

salaam.

I know it is mate but it's the kind of stuff the extremists come out with...:( What i mean is there isn't any obvious errors in the way he thinks the faith to be practiced (apart from the obvious ones of being a complete nutter and believing in an extremist viewpoint), some of the stuff he's coming out with i have seen and heard before, he's not making it up.
 
frogwoman said:
OK, thanks for correcting me.
It's jsut that i've heard from quite a few people that it's the other way round, but thanks for putting me straight on that one
xx

It is an idea many people seem to have, because "all you have to do to become Muslim is say the shahada in front of two witnesses".
Of course in case there is no other option, let's say when you are with 3 on an isolated island with no rescue in sight, that should not be a problem.
It isn't even a problem to say the shahada on your own when you are alone with God. ;)

salaam.
 
frogwoman said:
What i mean is there isn't any obvious errors in the way he thinks the faith to be practiced (apart from the obvious ones of being a complete nutter and believing in an extremist viewpoint), some of the stuff he's coming out with i have seen and heard before, he's not making it up.

It is the type of nonsense one can find on nutcase websites and other publications (I think he even came up with a Christian anti-Muslim website at some point). You don't need to be a Muslim to get that.
His defence of the Crazy Taliban Lunatics reveils enough about where and how he gets his stuff.

salaam.
 
You can be a salafi extremist and have far right opinions, surely? I mean, a lot of the out-there extremist stuff is strikingly similar to the Storm Front-y stuff. Antisemitism, conspiracy theories, misogyny and tiny-minded smugness ''that's just the way it's naturally ordained to be'' as justification for their opinions. I read a load of extremist literature over the summer and it was unbelievably depressing but I was struck by how similar a lot of it was to other hardliner stuff.


Re. Fattboy - I reckon he's about 19, been in and out of trouble in his teens, found himself looking for a new gang, a new masculine identity, some people who feel like brothers, some people who can tell him what to think and what to do with a side order of machismo and victimhood to feel newly good about himself, a new family almost. Maybe he's been in a spot of bother, stint in Feltham or whatever, still has a need for a bit of rebellion against the family, & has recently got involved with some local bro's who took him down the salafi mosque - and here we are.

U75 is a silly baord to try and proselytise on, but he's not doing it to win converts, he's doing it for himself because it makes him feel good.

Zealotry, boredom, and something to show the big boys to prove how devoted he is, that's what this is about

As long as he sticks to txt-spk gibberish on BBs he's harmless. It's when the machismo and the toxic misrepresentation of Islam he's swallowed starts becoming something else that its a worry. Germaine Lindsey was a teenage revert and that didn't end too well.
 
Either that or he's what Aldebaran and Butcher's Apron say (and what I initially thought) - a troll playing at being a Muslim, and being a totally objectionable one.
 
Badger Kitten said:
You can be a salafi extremist and have far right opinions, surely? I mean, a lot of the out-there extremist stuff is strikingly similar to the Storm Front-y stuff. Antisemitism, conspiracy theories, misogyny and tiny-minded smugness ''that's just the way it's naturally ordained to be'' as justification for their opinions. I read a load of extremist literature over the summer and it was unbelievably depressing but I was struck by how similar a lot of it was to other hardliner stuff.


Re. Fattboy - I reckon he's about 19, been in and out of trouble in his teens, found himself looking for a new gang, a new masculine identity, some people who feel like brothers, some people who can tell him what to think and what to do with a side order of machismo and victimhood to feel newly good about himself, a new family almost. Maybe he's been in a spot of bother, stint in Feltham or whatever, still has a need for a bit of rebellion against the family, & has recently got involved with some local bro's who took him down the salafi mosque - and here we are.

U75 is a silly baord to try and proselytise on, but he's not doing it to win converts, he's doing it for himself because it makes him feel good.

Zealotry, boredom, and something to show the big boys to prove how devoted he is, that's what this is about

As long as he sticks to txt-spk gibberish on BBs he's harmless. It's when the machismo and the toxic misrepresentation of Islam he's swallowed starts becoming something else that its a worry. Germaine Lindsey was a teenage revert and that didn't end too well.

Exactly
excellent post BK
 
He is not a would-be suicidal terrorist or has the potential to ever be one, if that is what you meant to say.
It takes a lot more than reading some websites to get to the point of being convinced that killing yourself while becoming a mass murderer is the most noble and rewarding thing to do.

salaam.
 
It is extremely unusual yes, but if he is for real, and especially if he is white or black rather than asian, then he's the sort of useful idiot...

...the chances are microscopic, but I raise the point because the tripe he is spouting is unnervingly similar to the rubbish the Al Muhjaroun and Supporters of Sharia and the Saved Sect and all that lot have been coming out with for the last few years, and the links between them and numerous young men who have been through court on terrorism charges is startling.
 
I'm totally oblivious about internal UK situations. Maybe he got caught in some of the groups (unknown to me) you mention but still from there to having suicidal wishes is an enormous gap to bridge.
Maybe if he shows up again you could ask him a few questions on that :)
(in any case he must feel good with all the attention he generates here)


salaam.
 
I doubt he'll last much longer on these boards, with his FAQ-busting txt-speak little ways. Religious misogynistic antisemitic homophobic conspiraloons, mmmmm.
 
I don't see reason to ban him unless editor starts panicking his precious atheist board is going to be overrun by threads posted by this newly arrived member :) (Maybe inviting some of his friends to help him proselytize you all.)


salaam
 
Of course he shouldn't be banned.

Exposing his/her nonsense to themselves is the best thing that could happen. And it is.

Ban Aldebran.
 
Personally I don't think he should be banned either, it's better for his stuff to be expertly sliced and diced by posters such as Aldebaran etc who have far more idea of what they are talking about but given what he has been posting I would not be surprised if he did end up getting banned at some stage based on the FAQs about God-squadding & bigotry being ''unwelcome''.
 
butchersapron said:
Ban Aldebran.

:):)
It is written Aldebaran (even my dyslexic mind has fiunally got that) but you can always ask editor to ban me to have the playground for yourself.

salaam.
 
Debate on Sharia on R4's Beyond Belief today.
14 January 2008

The term Sharia Law has become for some people the epitome of tough justice. Its apparently reactionary and harsh nature has been highlighted in recent times by the case of British school teacher Gillian Gibbons who could have faced flogging after allowing her class in Sudan to name a teddy bear Mohammed.

But has Sharia law got an unfair reputation? Are we judging it by shocking and uncharacteristic examples of its application? Could it have a beneficial impact on our national life if it were to be applied in the United Kingdom?

http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio/podcasts/belief/
or rightmouseclick and download: http://downloads.bbc.co.uk/podcasts/radio4/belief/belief_20080114-1635.mp3
 
the thing is, there are lots of different kinds of shariah law, so it's dangerous and misleading to describe one way (the most extreme way, normally) as the only proper version of islam
 
Fattboy has been interesting, he reveals the fundamentally violent/intolerant core of Religion. In this case Islam.
The vast majority of religious people adhere to humanist values based on a social consensus. They will often ignore or reinterpret the glaringly obvious flaws in their religion.
 
Badger Kitten said:
You can be a salafi extremist and have far right opinions, surely? I mean, a lot of the out-there extremist stuff is strikingly similar to the Storm Front-y stuff. Antisemitism, conspiracy theories, misogyny and tiny-minded smugness ''that's just the way it's naturally ordained to be'' as justification for their opinions. I read a load of extremist literature over the summer and it was unbelievably depressing but I was struck by how similar a lot of it was to other hardliner stuff.


Re. Fattboy - I reckon he's about 19, been in and out of trouble in his teens, found himself looking for a new gang, a new masculine identity, some people who feel like brothers, some people who can tell him what to think and what to do with a side order of machismo and victimhood to feel newly good about himself, a new family almost. Maybe he's been in a spot of bother, stint in Feltham or whatever, still has a need for a bit of rebellion against the family, & has recently got involved with some local bro's who took him down the salafi mosque - and here we are.

U75 is a silly baord to try and proselytise on, but he's not doing it to win converts, he's doing it for himself because it makes him feel good.

Zealotry, boredom, and something to show the big boys to prove how devoted he is, that's what this is about

As long as he sticks to txt-spk gibberish on BBs he's harmless. It's when the machismo and the toxic misrepresentation of Islam he's swallowed starts becoming something else that its a worry. Germaine Lindsey was a teenage revert and that didn't end too well.


im a lot more than 19 and ive been a muslim 4 years now and ive never been in prison neither.
i dont really care if im not liked on here to be honest, in fact id be more worried if i was cos theres some not very nice ppl here but theres nice ones as well.

all the first generation, the salaf were reverts and they were the best ppl ever raised from mankind, and some of them were the bitterest of enemies to Islam and the Prophet pbuh, and they became the leading lights of Islam by the Grace of Allah, so only Allah Knows whos gonna become a muslim one day out of u lot, if any.
some ppl become muslims just before they die, it doesnt often happen overnight.
i wouldnt expect ppl to just jump up and become muslims, i never always liked Islam, i thought it was for ppl who needed to chill out a bit and not be so serious but when u see the truth of Islam and ur sincere u will accept it.

i can relate to some of u lot, i used to go pubbing and clubbing, drinking and smoking,this that and the other, bagleys, gatecrasher,strawberry sundae,dance valley, all the ibiza clubs, been there 3 times, goa, amsterdam nuff times, so u lot probably think im stuck up or self righteous but im not, ive lived a bit as well and had a good time but i would never want to go back to them times, thats just existing for the sake of it, theres no purpose to it other than doing as much decadence as u can and thats not what we here for, the hereafters gonna be a thousand times better than anything u can do in this temporary life, so why trade peace and bliss for all eternity for the sake of a few years,but thats pretty much the test of this life.
and anyway even if u do some stuff like that, it doesnt mean ur not a muslim, ur just not a very good one.
u aint gotta be perfect to be a musim,u just try ur best thats all u can do, better to be believer that sins than a disbeliever.

Islams the truth and its beautiful when u live it but to see it u gotta put ur prejudices and bias aside or else u'll never see it for what it is.
we aint miserable ppl, we have a laugh and a joke and yeah there is great brother and sisterhood in Islam, i love my family but i love my brothers and sisters in Islam more.
i just wanna try and show ppl that Islam isnt what they might think it is, if just one person thinks a bit differently and reflects on it, then thats good innit.:)
 
Back
Top Bottom