A genius double bluff.There is a tweet from the "binACG2" twitter account that accuses Rhydical of being a TERF.
So who knows? Not me that's for sure.
It’s still on the website.I don't want to dig up old shit, but I'd be interested in seeing the old ACG statement on trans rights. I'd be cool with a PM of it, as I don't want to stir old beef, just so I can make my own judgements on how egregious it is.
LDC did mention above that my impression of the Cowley seemed a bit out of date. Which is fine, I suppose, I don't live in Brighton and don't need to know about it.Obviously not familiar with recent developments at the Cowley Club then!
Lol, it’s not. I’ll see if I can find a draft.It’s still on the website.
But I’ll PM it to you.
I think you'll find that on this issue any calls for peace, love and understanding will be deemed egregious by some.I don't want to dig up old shit, but I'd be interested in seeing the old ACG statement on trans rights. I'd be cool with a PM of it, as I don't want to stir old beef, just so I can make my own judgements on how egregious it is.
Well 70+ pages for an event in London. I might have a good bit of time on my hands, but there are limits.It’s actually on this thread: London Anarchist bookfair 2020
The link was to a particular post from comrade Serge.Well 70+ pages for an event in London. I might have a good bit of time on my hands, but there are limits.
And thanks for sending it through. For what it's worth, it doesn't sound like an unreasonable statement and doesn't strike me as transphobic in any way, but what would I now.
Oh, FFS. I've now started reading the whole thread. I planned on doing shit today.The link was to a particular post from comrade Serge.
In the Soviet era you could get denounced by your ideologically pure children. Getting denounced by your own sockpuppet is the way it runs in the internet age.There is a tweet from the "binACG2" twitter account that accuses Rhydical of being a TERF.
So who knows? Not me that's for sure.
Don't tell him Pike!Well 70+ pages for an event in London. I might have a good bit of time on my hands, but there are limits.
And thanks for sending it through. For what it's worth, it doesn't sound like an unreasonable statement and doesn't strike me as transphobic in any way, but what would I know.
Fwiw, I think it is still on the website, just you have to scroll down a long way to read it:Lol, it’s not. I’ll see if I can find a draft.
However it’s not that dissimilar to the new one. We just felt it needed refreshed.
Given Rhyddical's record of giving clear, straightforward answers to straightforward questions, I'm sure they'll be along shortly to give a neat, unambiguous answer that everyone can be satisfied with on the question of whether or not they're East Dulwich postcode and/or a terf.In the Soviet era you could get denounced by your ideologically pure children. Getting denounced by your own sockpuppet is the way it runs in the internet age.
Sadly I’m one of those in charge of upkeep of the website. I’m 56. These are all my own teeth.Fwiw, I think it is still on the website, just you have to scroll down a long way to read it:
Statements - Anarchist Communist Group
The following are statements by the Anarchist Communist Group since its formation in February 2018, 8 April 2021 (this statement supersedes the earlier statement of 11 August 2019) Trans Rights Statement We, the ACG, reaffirm our support for trans and non-binary people. We...www.anarchistcommunism.org
Might make that page easier to navigate if you added a table of contents thing at the top with links to the point on the page where each statement starts, which I don't know how to do myself but imagine would be fairly possible for someone who's better at web design than me to do?
If there was one positive to come out of this whole shit show it would be if critics of the ACG and/or bookfair collective actually engaged with this statement. As it is, they seem stuck in what probably feels like a comfortable place, denunciations and red lines. As you mention Danny and also Chilango, this has become disconnected from what the actual politics and positions of the ACG are. Not uncommon for political (and personal) battles to end up like that, but it's also very depressing and even a bit disturbing.Sadly I’m one of those in charge of upkeep of the website. I’m 56. These are all my own teeth.
But, yeah, the substantive point is that the old statement is still sound. It just needed to flow a bit better.
And there’s no dog whistles because we have no intention of giving succour to transphobes. Of course, as chilango says, whatever the issue those who have problems with us have, it’s not transphobia. What it is, I have no idea.
But I’m happy to discuss it with SE22 They don’t know me, but they seem to be happy to decide what I secretly believe inside, despite my words and actions.
Exactly.Don't get me wrong, I'm not claiming that the ACG's response to trans stuff is perfect. No one's has been. Including Urban (one reason why I've not been posting as much here recently).
But "not perfect" does not mean transphobic.
...and I'll tell you one thing for sure, all of this toxic bullshit does not aid our trans comrades nor the wider movements one bit.
Why do you hate trans people !!!I think it'd be pretty insulting for anyone to pretend this has anything to do with transphobia at this point.
i dont think those 2 statements are per se the big offending issue...If there was one positive to come out of this whole shit show it would be if critics of the ACG and/or bookfair collective actually engaged with this statement.
Theyve only just discovered PDFs! One step at a time.Might make that page easier to navigate if you added a table of contents thing at the top with links to the point on the page where each statement starts, which I don't know how to do myself but imagine would be fairly possible for someone who's better at web design than me to do?
No I agree. I know about the split and about the supposed support for particular alleged terfs circa 2017-18, though I'm not involved and don't know about any other flashpoints. However the statements look like a way of moving on and getting some degree of mutual accommodation.i dont think those 2 statements are per se the big offending issue...
...though the point I'm grasping for isn't even about the statements. It just that the denunciations are very much of the fingers in ears shouty type. All very reassuring as a way of shoring up certainty and red lines, but not a very mature way of dealing with comrades.No I agree. I know about the split and about the supposed support for particular alleged terfs circa 2017-18, though I'm not involved and don't know about any other flashpoints. However the statements look like a way of moving on and getting some degree of mutual accommodation.
Anti homeless bullshit. Spikes and slanted seats all over the shopi tried to ignore it but have to ask now - wtf is this bus stop (hostile architecture) thing?
facepalm is ready
As far as I know nobody’s had any contact with them. I certainly hadn’t heard of them.Hang on, there’s something about bus stops. Maybe ACG have been banned for being unkind about the the hostile architecture smashers
December 12 2020:i tried to ignore it but have to ask now - wtf is this bus stop (hostile architecture) thing?
facepalm is ready
greenanticapitalistmedia
We got sent this photo of an action taken in London against advertising. The influence of capitalism extends into almost every waking minute of our life. Even small actions like this, if reproduced everywhere, can help deestablise the beast and undermine it's control over our minds. No matter how big or small, start planning and taking action right now!
Fuck ads! Fuck capitalism!
#anticapitalism #anarchism #adhacking #noads #ecology #environmentalist #directaction
37w
Unsurprisingly we have also had lots of issues with tankie groups. After we posted an action where windows of a bus stop had been smashed we received a fuck tonne of abuse online. Several members of the Young Communist League attacked us online labelling us as “counter revolutionary”. We aren’t surprised they care more about a broken window then multiple reports of sexual harassment and sexual assault from within the group. [...] It was very clear from the response to the bus stop action that our local scene was not a safe space for us. We’ve accepted this and moved on. [...]
The bus stop action also caused for us to be further copjacketed, this time by mostly British Marxist-Leninists and anarcho-communists. While again entertaining this really irritated us as people we would consider to be comrades had once again abandoned us and sided with the enemy. Copjacketing is a very harmful thing in leftist scenes. We encourage people to be more cautious about it.
Project Full Stop Affinity taught us very quickly that the left hate us, and we hate the left.