Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Is this woman a transphobe?

sometimes, its just too crazy. KS is accused there (in the linked highly recommended extremely long piece) of 'genocide apologism', i mean, srsly.
 
SWP spinoff

ETA - over the Comrade Delta stuff:

Strong vibes
 
sometimes, its just too crazy. KS is accused there (in the linked highly recommended extremely long piece) of 'genocide apologism', i mean, srsly.
do you mean in the Grace Lavery piece? Thats the only one I can see makes any such reference. But what else would you call a demand for the 'elimination of the practise of transgenderism'?
 
I can't do this today and shouldn't have said anything.
People who think its great that she's not working at sussex uni anymore should celebrate the victory but hurry up cos according to that same piece the vice chancellor of the university needs to lose his job too. "I realize that Tickell’s en route to a new position as VC of Birmingham University. He should lose that job too. "..
 
I can't do this today and shouldn't have said anything.
People who think its great that she's not working at sussex uni anymore should celebrate the victory but hurry up cos according to that same piece the vice chancellor of the university needs to lose his job too. "I realize that Tickell’s en route to a new position as VC of Birmingham University. He should lose that job too. "..
fucking diddums. Pity the poor bosses who make awful decisions.
 
fucking diddums. Pity the poor bosses who make awful decisions.
what should he have done in your opinion?
Agreed that her working there was a danger to the safety of students and sacked her?
Its a bit of a weird one this in my head cos 100 years ago i went to that same university, and my department was run by a bunch of short haired hardcore materialist feminists, they are probably all gone now by natural causes but i don't think they'd be "on the right side of history" now.
 
do you mean in the Grace Lavery piece? Thats the only one I can see makes any such reference. But what else would you call a demand for the 'elimination of the practise of transgenderism'?

In principle, the practice could be eliminated without killing any people, by eliminaing gender (once a fairly uncontroversial aim amongst feminists). Your position is like saying those who want to end the practice of animal farming want to murder all meat eaters. This isn't to say I think that elimination is a particularly good aim, or that I don't think it's often wrapped up with some pretty unpleasant stuff*, but to call it genocide is ridiculous hyperbole. (*And the stuff on Lily Cade's blog was vile bigotry, that deserves to unequivocally condemned.)
 
Last edited:
do you mean in the Grace Lavery piece? Thats the only one I can see makes any such reference. But what else would you call a demand for the 'elimination of the practise of transgenderism'?
I guess an elimination of racism or sexism would count as genocide as well then.
 
I don't think it's particularly useful, but if people were calling for the elimination of a particular religion, or the practice of homosexuality from society, it might focus a few minds about what that actually looks like (and you could do both of those, in theory, without killing anyone, not directly anyway).
can you imagine the response of Jeremy Corbyn had said he wanted to end the practise of Judaism? I doubt the usual apologists here would be defending his comments in the same way.
 
oops

BBC discovers one of the anti-trans bigots it quoted is....an anti-trans bigot with a history of sexual misconduct. Well, what a surprise.

And the sort of bigot who calls for violence and then resorts to a pathetic defence.

Since the article’s publication Cade, who was quoted in the original story, published violently transphobic remarks on her website – which has been down since Wednesday – appearing to call for the “lynching” of high-profile trans women. In a statement to the Guardian, Cade said she had only attacked “personas”, not people, and said Lily Cade was also a persona.
 
Back
Top Bottom