I have just watched the whole thing in about a month. For the first time.
It is cool. I liked it. I'll watch some again. The one where her mum dies is probably the single most rawly traumatic 45mins of screen drama I have *ever* seen. Very real. Horrible. I wept for my own dead dad when I watched it - and actually, was fairly cross about it, as well as impressed. I didn't sign up for *that*.
But then, for dawn to be essentially "over" the death of buffy after a few months seemed a bit unreal.
The logical inconsistencies of the show were annoying. Like, did they register her death or not? They had a funeral, a tombstone, but didn't tell her Dad? Or the school? Unlikely.
Also, the one slayer at a time rule didn't seem clear in early seasons. And why would you have a whole council of watchers if Giles is the only active one?
Oh Christ the accents. I mean, yes - James Marsden = hot. But wtf was his accent? They had a bloody British actor on set and he still couldn't pronounce "can't".
But I have enjoyed it and will watch it again in bits and pieces. Might start with the one where Giles eats the Halloween chocolate... Oh my!