Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

A thank you to Brexiteers.

It's certainly led to some interesting and good humoured discussions here, hasn't it...
Certainly been no shortage of comically clueless people offering opinions on how my career as a musician hasn't supposedly been negatively impacted, or hoe touring the US is somehow comparable to playing Europe.
 
Keep on spinning, chum.

Oh, and I'll ask you the same question: Putting the vaccination issue to one side, tell me all the positive things that have come out of Brexit so far.
the fish! the fish are happier.
fewer HGVs grinding their way to Holyhead
Farage isn't on the telly every night
refugees who are fortunate enough to make not to Kent definitely won't get shipped back to France
Union Jack sales are up a huge amount
need I go on...?
 
So are things getting better for asylum seekers coming to the UK as a result of Brexit then? And are they going to keep on getting better and if so, how?
No & no, I expect...but you did ask for any one thing....
 
the fish! the fish are happier.
fewer HGVs grinding their way to Holyhead
Farage isn't on the telly every night
refugees who are fortunate enough to make not to Kent definitely won't get shipped back to France
Union Jack sales are up a huge amount
need I go on...?
and my tiny violins are shifting in numbers never previously known
 
I'm not convinced this was down to chance; I'm prepared to accept that our venal, corrupt, esurient 'leaders' are actually better suited to neoliberal gaming than the EU bureaucrats.

I think I'd put it a different way - at its heart, the EU structures (and those attracted to work in them) are technocratic, legalistic beasts whose raison d'etre is the management of trade treaties.

Nation states within the EU honking off about the EU's inability to do quick response was a thing long before Dear Nigel ever coined the term Brexit. many of the member states were as quick off the mark as the UK government when it came to vaccines (and were certainly quicker when it came to hoovering up PPE): the problem they had is not (or not necessarily) deciding to club together to buy huge amounts of vaccine for a continent without (broadly) internal borders, their problem was putting in the hands of a legalistic structure who's gut reaction is rules and process.

They were faced with a crisis, a really frightening crisis, and - like most of us - they reverted to type. In Johnson's case it was the freewheeling shitshow, but in UVDL's case it was making huge political statements and ignoring the mechanisms to bring it about, and then (as she did in at least two government departments in Germany) arguing over money and then flailing about trying to find someone else to take the blame.

With Johnson the shitshow brought us the death toll, but the freewheeling brought us the vaccine.
 
I think I'd put it a different way - at its heart, the EU structures (and those attracted to work in them) are technocratic, legalistic beasts whose raison d'etre is the management of trade treaties.

Nation states within the EU honking off about the EU's inability to do quick response was a thing long before Dear Nigel ever coined the term Brexit. many of the member states were as quick off the mark as the UK government when it came to vaccines (and were certainly quicker when it came to hoovering up PPE): the problem they had is not (or not necessarily) deciding to club together to buy huge amounts of vaccine for a continent without (broadly) internal borders, their problem was putting in the hands of a legalistic structure who's gut reaction is rules and process.

They were faced with a crisis, a really frightening crisis, and - like most of us - they reverted to type. In Johnson's case it was the freewheeling shitshow, but in UVDL's case it was making huge political statements and ignoring the mechanisms to bring it about, and then (as she did in at least two government departments in Germany) arguing over money and then flailing about trying to find someone else to take the blame.

With Johnson the shitshow brought us the death toll, but the freewheeling brought us the vaccine.
All good points, well made.
 
No no no.

You have to put all obvious positive's of Brexit to one side. Then you have to agree that all of the things that you see as positives, aren't actually positives at all, and put those to one side too.

That's how this game works :D

Tbf my step-mum’s aunt’s scratching was very mediocre, so a discount DJ mixer would have been wasted on her anyway.
 
Results demonstrated vaccine efficacy of 76% (CI: 59% to 86%) after a first dose,

Note that, if I'm remembering correctly, efficacy in the context of this study means reducing transmission. In the context of preventing people getting serious C19 and ending up in hospital (which was the overwhelming crisis that was fast approaching with hospitals starting to run out of capacity), efficacy of the AZ appears to be much, much higher - at least 90% and possibly nearly 100%. Time will tell, but it was the right decision to start putting AZ in to as many arms as possible as soon as possible. Whilst there wasn't any complete academic study on this exact scenario, the preliminary data gave a strong suggestion that it was the case, so the scientists took a slight gamble, convinced the government of the gamble, and as a whole we and the NHS can all breathe a bit easier, both literally and metaphorically. Most medical staff in the UK TTBOMK have been prioritised to get the pfizer vaccine since it appears to give better transmission protection (but again it's going to be a long time before we know the full story).

Personally I'm currently of the opinion that we've had a lucky escape but that it's a largely orthogonal issue to brexit, but because they happen at the same time it's difficult to separate the two completely. The EU sabre-rattling over their own poor planning and logistics is at best childish and at worst downright ugly; the recent spats about the AZ vaccine reek of panicked face-saving (since you had almost all of the continental medical authorities saying that even if AZ did cause blood clotting, C19 causes clotting anyway* and is far more deadly... so take the fuckin' vaccine!) which has poured diesel on to an already toasty tyre fire, and dropping this particular political bollock is going to result in thousands more deaths. As I mentioned in another thread the press in italy has whipped up a massive storm and convinced lots of mugwumps to panic and swear off any vaccines at all, ever. My partner's mother, 65, has been told she can expect to be able to book for her (pfizer) vaccine appointment in seven months. There's certainly a technocratic side to the EU here that appears to have blundered substantially, in a similar way to our own home-grown substantially blundering technocrats were doing a year ago, and both are eyeing each up as Aunt Sally whilst the science and healthcare folk roll their eyes in despair**.

Anyway, this is all probably more relevant for the C19 board than the usual pram-throwing that goes on in this thread. I voted remoaniac and I'm still convinced brexit is a cake made of foetid pig effluent with union jack icing and a bulldog artfully placed on top for our dining pleasure (not eating your slice is not an option and no, you can't have a corner bit with slightly less pig shit in it). One accidental victory with vaccines at the same time as an EU mis-step isn't going to make up for all the other disruption going on at the same time (particularly with trade which is getting very ugly very quickly), but as long as brexit and C19 are happening at the same time, many people will ascribe all deleterious effects to their demon of choice and all advantages to their preferred messiah, because that's the simple nuance-free option.

* For those interested, last I read was that the clotting was put down to people having an allergic reaction to their own antibodies produced by their own bodies' immune response, so it can happen with any vaccine (and had already been recorded with the pfizer one at least) and of course would also happen if you caught C19, giving you a double-whammy. In most studies, the incidence of blood clots in AZ recipients is lower than the general population; the strongest data to the contrary is currently coming out of Norway who release their further findings on the matter tomorrow.

** Bias on my part here because I (laughably) consider myself a scientist and have been rolling my eyes so much over the last year I've given myself a crick in the neck.
 
I know we've moved on but have only just caught up and want to speak up for the British weather. Knocks the shitty continental climate we get here into a cocked hat, give me mizzle for weeks any time over either bollock freezing or scorching and sweaty and mosquitoes.
 
you do keep bringing it up tho. and touring the us is comparable to - but not equivalent with - playing europe.
In what ways is it 'comparable' for smaller bands - apart from the actual physical act of playing gigs? And if the experiences are so comparable, why do you think so few smaller bands who regularly play Europe ever get to tour the US?
 
And let’s not put the vaccine issue aside, you keep claiming it isn’t Brexit related and keep trying to back that claim up by conflating it with vaccine approvals, yet my friend Varnia still can not see her mum cos the over 80’s in Portugal are still waiting for a jab, but I will have mine on Monday, aged 48. My step-mum’s aunt is still dead cos she lived in Holland and not the U.K.
You've done the personal stuff before, so it's getting a bit boring now.

But I did ask politely, so could you now list all the positive things that have come out of Brexit so far?
 
Back
Top Bottom