Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Is Brexit actually going to happen?

Will we have a brexit?


  • Total voters
    362
why should she resign ? no on wants her job and its not like she has anything else going on in her life that she can be getting on with. She is like the doomesday bomb mechanism at the end of Dr Straneglove- she is unbale to reevaulate things with any new facts presented - she will see this through whatever the cost
 
Yes; they, as in the enfranchised of 2014.
That wasn't me; how should I properly refer to those who were able to?
The brexit vote was in 2016. What are you talking about?

Scotland and NI voted to remain, how do you suggest they get heard this time?
 
Lump it, like you'd be quite happy for leave voters to have had to have done if the EU vote had gone otherwise, or you'd have been quite happy for unionist voters to have had to do had the independence ref gone otherwise.

You know, reciprocity.

I don't think you know what reciprocity means.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CRI
Your voices were heard, but you're small numbers in the great scheme of things.

Sorry, but that's the fact of the matter.

There is another aspect, though, in that the pro-UK campaign in the independence referendum placed a great deal of emphasis on their notion that "an independent Scotland would be at the very end of the queue to join the EU, nyah njah nyah, you will have no friends, so there!" This would have influenced some people's vote. Now Scotland is to be dragged out of the EU despite voting 62% in favour of remain.

I realise it doesn't matter from your point of view, but it is sort of relevant to some of us.
 
There is another aspect, though, in that the pro-UK campaign in the independence referendum placed a great deal of emphasis on their notion that "an independent Scotland would be at the very end of the queue to join the EU, nyah njah nyah, you will have no friends, so there!" This would have influenced some people's vote. Now Scotland is to be dragged out of the EU despite voting 62% in favour of remain.

I realise it doesn't matter from your point of view, but it is sort of relevant to some of us.
Yeh but democracy means whither England pulls Scotland goes [/cs]
 
There is another aspect, though, in that the pro-UK campaign in the independence referendum placed a great deal of emphasis on their notion that "an independent Scotland would be at the very end of the queue to join the EU, nyah njah nyah, you will have no friends, so there!" This would have influenced some people's vote. Now Scotland is to be dragged out of the EU despite voting 62% in favour of remain.

I realise it doesn't matter from your point of view, but it is sort of relevant to some of us.
Yes but the nyah nyah nyah was more or less from the same people who campaigned for remain in 2016. All the main parties did. It’s not them pulling us out of the EU really is it, the majority vote was to leave the EU and it could only ever be a U.K. wide vote, how else would they have gone about it, I’m sorry but Scotland had a chance to vote Yes in 2014 and it didn’t happen. If you want a future Yes vote to be upheld, please don’t go down this road because it will come right back in your face if project fear/establishment/whateveryouwantotcallthem tried to block a future majority Yes vote.
 
Scotland and Northern Ireland didn't vote.
That's technically true, of course. However, that sort of shorthand is used very often. It is an aspect worth noting given the amount of newspaper commentary telling us that the "metropolitan elite" voted to remain, or that only young people voted to remain etc. There may very well have been analyses attempting to show that people with different hairstyles voted differently for all I know, or people who open their boiled eggs from the top or the bottom.

Certainly it makes sod-all difference to May and her wonderful deals, but if one of the countries of the UK has an electorate who voted 62% to remain, that is something worth noticing. It might not be important to many, but it adds to the whole "getting Tory governments when not voting Tory" aspect of things, and might have implications for the future.

As a tangential aside, is anyone else annoyed by the "everyone over 35 or so is an ancient useless evil bastard and voted to leave and is therefore guilty of ruining the future of all younger people" narrative? And the "everyone who voted 'leave' is a terrible dim-witted racist bastard" one? That level of discourse is pretty poisonous. :(
 
Yes but the nyah nyah nyah was more or less from the same people who campaigned for remain in 2016.

Really? I am not sure that is the case. Admittedly, I have not read any proper surveys examining that, so it would be interesting to see some.

Also, of course, there were people who voted for independence who voted to leave the EU. It's all nicely complicated. :D
All the main parties did. It’s not them pulling us out of the EU really is it, the majority vote was to leave the EU and it could only ever be a U.K. wide vote, how else would they have gone about it, I’m sorry but Scotland had a chance to vote Yes in 2014 and it didn’t happen. If you want a future Yes vote to be upheld, please don’t go down this road because it will come right back in your face if project fear/establishment/whateveryouwantotcallthem tried to block a future majority Yes vote.
Oh, I didn't call anybody "Project Fear". The Labour Party invented that name, didn't they?
 
That's technically true, of course. However, that sort of shorthand is used very often. It is an aspect worth noting given the amount of newspaper commentary telling us that the "metropolitan elite" voted to remain, or that only young people voted to remain etc. There may very well have been analyses attempting to show that people with different hairstyles voted differently for all I know, or people who open their boiled eggs from the top or the bottom.

Certainly it makes sod-all difference to May and her wonderful deals, but if one of the countries of the UK has an electorate who voted 62% to remain, that is something worth noticing. It might not be important to many, but it adds to the whole "getting Tory governments when not voting Tory" aspect of things, and might have implications for the future.

As a tangential aside, is anyone else annoyed by the "everyone over 35 or so is an ancient useless evil bastard and voted to leave and is therefore guilty of ruining the future of all younger people" narrative? And the "everyone who voted 'leave' is a terrible dim-witted racist bastard" one? That level of discourse is pretty poisonous. :(
Yeah but...Watched that Benn Heath question time from 97 last week and it was same slant then oldies holding us back from joining EUro...Reality was/is thank fuck and if the EUro obsessives hadn't had a hand in it we wouldn't have had a Euro convergence unit in the treasury then maybe we would nt have chased interest rate parity and fucked the banks and the housing market
 
Really? I am not sure that is the case. Admittedly, I have not read any proper surveys examining that, so it would be interesting to see some.

Also, of course, there were people who voted for independence who voted to leave the EU. It's all nicely complicated. :D

Oh, I didn't call anybody "Project Fear". The Labour Party invented that name, didn't they?
You didn’t, no. I just mean like, The Establishment. The people who campaigned for remain in 2016: Tories, Labour, Lib Dem, BUISINESS *applause*, leading economists fucking... Bob Geldof.... etc. Yes I’ve no doubt some swivel eyed Tory leavers were involved in scaring Scottish people into maintaining the union but 90 per cent of the establishment is pro remain.
So the “they” that were doing the nyah nyah nyah not wholly or even mostly invested in crashing out of the EU, basically.
 
I’m sorry if I didn’t use the term Project Fear with laser accurate precision but that’s because I know I’m posting to a generally clued up audience like yersel ;)
 
You were probably too busy singing "It's coming home!"
Interesting. I was born and bred in Scotland and as far as football goes always indulged in “anyone but England” type banter... but my dad and his whole family are English. Is that a problem in your future Scottish paradise?
 
As a tangential aside, is anyone else annoyed by the "everyone over 35 or so is an ancient useless evil bastard and voted to leave and is therefore guilty of ruining the future of all younger people" narrative? And the "everyone who voted 'leave' is a terrible dim-witted racist bastard" one?

Don't think anyone's annoyed by that, no. It's not even an issue that's been mentioned on this thread I don't think.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom