Thursday July 22, 2004 1:16 PM
Just short of two-thirds of the new Iraqi police and security troops have completed some form of training, although many of them lack weapons, vehicles and other equipment necessary to do their job, Pentagon figures show. In addition, about half of the troops in the country's reconstituted military are trained, but many of those units also face equipment shortages, the Pentagon says. The Pentagon projects that both the security services and military will be fully trained and equipped by spring 2005, with certain units being fully capable sooner, according to the figures, which were posted on a Pentagon public relations Web site.
Military officials pointed to the figures as a sign of progress that Iraqis are growing more capable of managing their own security, although they acknowledge the job is far from finished. The more Iraqi forces are capable of fighting insurgents on their own, the fewer American and allied troops will ultimately be needed in the country, they say. Pentagon officials blamed the difficulties on getting equipment to Iraqis on the red tape that goes with U.S. government contracting. But they expect that to change and say money is now flowing to buy body armor, weapons, radios and vehicles. So far, the new Iraqi security and police forces have a mixed record in facing insurgents. In April 2004, when U.S. forces faced concurrent uprisings in two parts of Iraq, some Iraqi units refused to fight, and a few deserted to the insurgents. U.S. officials say this has hastened efforts to create a wholly Iraqi chain-of-command.
In some cases, the insurgents have been better armed than the Iraqi security forces, and the insurgents repeatedly have targeted police and local officials, viewing them as collaborators with U.S. forces. But defense officials point to other operations as a sign that well-equipped Iraqi units are up to the job. In recent months, Iraqi security forces defended a northern governor's office during an insurgent raid, and they have conducted successful large-scale sweeps for insurgents in Baghdad.
Reports of any progress are coming far too late, according to Anthony Cordesman, an Iraq expert with the Center for Strategic and International Studies, who has reviewed the Pentagon's figures. Cordesman, a former Defense Department intelligence official, said in a paper that the U.S. military should have trained and equipped Iraqi security forces to this point far sooner. "The U.S. wasted precious time waiting for its own forces to defeat a threat that it treated as the product of a small number of former regime loyalists and foreign volunteers, and felt it could solve without creating effective Iraqi forces,'' Cordesman writes.
Pentagon officials disputed Cordesman's assertions, saying they have made progress in the areas he cites as lagging: training and equipping security forces, cooperation between U.S. and Iraqi forces, and intelligence collection. Iraqi internal security forces fall into three categories: police, border patrol and facilities protection. Of the 188,851 needed, more than 180,000 have been hired. Of those, 121,943 - about 64 percent - have finished some form of training.
Pentagon data on Iraq:
http://www.defendamerica.mil/downloads/Iraq-WeeklyUpdate-20040720a.pdf
Anthony Cordesman report:
http://www.csis.org/features/iraq-inexcusablefailure.pdf