given Editor is now actively watching the OP of this thread ... i'm sure it won;t be long before we get an outcome one way or t'other
In a thread format where one post follows another, rather than the next post overwriting the one before, 'speaking over' literally isn't possible
it fundamentally is , becasue in a discussion there is one or both of an (attempt at) explanation / rationalisation of a position or an evolution of the position as those with actual expertise inform someone who holds a position which is not supported by evidence
I think the 4chan slang here pretty much definitively settles this as being a human troll. Say what you like about Lenin or Tito, but they never used 4chan memes.
So have I, but my part is bigger.
not all beards
I realised that I do not understand the "boiling a kettle of water" example of dialectics. How is heat the antithesis of water?
Yeah, I take back my supposition that it's AI. They're clearly just a bit of a bellend.
It’s the transformation from quantity to quality. How one small step that has been made many times before with no fundamental change occurring, suddenly transforming a thing entirely. An antithesis doesn’t have to be like matter/antimatter, it’s just two different states - heat from kettle v waters nature to remain the same.
Any time you feel ready to fuck this "fabianite" forum off, you just be sure not to let the reactionary capitalist running dog door hit your socialist arse on the way out...
Four lines of Fabianite revisionism.
If they're implying that medical transition is "TERF ideology" then why bother listening to the revisionists then?
But you see, that's just the part of what I advocate. This forum is about a part of what I see as fit for communism. We can debate about other aspects of mine Marxism-Leninism, per your interest and mood.
But don't they want to be free of their gender dysphoria? Isn't that the common cause that the trans people advocate for? In a socialist state, this is carried out without any delay! These people simply wanna be recognized and affirmed.
Well, trans people are telling you what they want, but you appear to be ignoring them and projecting what you want for them instead.
The majority of trans people clearly have an outcry that they want to medically transition for their current pre-transition body is doing much emotional pain. Revisionism is killing their dreams. The vanguard party will proceed as usual and liberate them from their misery. After all, if we ought to emancipate the proletariat by a revolution, then we can emancipate the transgender with medical transition. It is a revolutionary step!
"The petty-bourgeois democrats, those sham socialists who replaced the class struggle by dreams of class harmony, even pictured the socialist transformation in a dreamy fashion — not as the overthrow of the rule of the exploiting class, but as the peaceful submission of the minority to the majority which has become aware of its aims. This petty-bourgeois utopia, which is inseparable from the idea of the state being above classes, led in practice to the betrayal of the interests of the working classes, as was shown, for example, by the history of the French revolutions of 1848 and 1871, and by the experience of “socialist” participation in bourgeois Cabinets in Britain, France, Italy and other countries at the turn of the century."
"waters nature to remain the same." Water does not have a nature to remain the same.
