Gender idealism?

[Yugoslav]

You're going to start gettnig warnings if you keep up this shit.

Alright. Let's not blame the ideology but I am still against the fact of calling this "cisnormative" because it does not help at all with solving the issue. Medical transition makes trans people less suicidal and depressed and you have plenty of scholarly proof.

 

[Yugoslav]

Who is Jonathan Reynolds?
Starmer and Streeting may be members of the Fabian Society, but they are not "reformist" Fabians. They are neo-liberals. Things have change more than a little in the past 100 years in Britain.

Fabians are indeed more supportive of neo-liberalism (because they aim to collaborate with the bourgeoisie and the bourgeoisie are supportive of neo-liberal capitalism). Reynolds is one of the members of the Fabianite cabinet.

 

[InArduisFouette]

Alright. Let's not blame the ideology but I am still against the fact of calling this "cisnormative" because it does not help at all with solving the issue. Medical transition makes trans people less suicidal and depressed and you have plenty of scholarly proof.

why do you continue to pretend to be confused by this

you have posted a postion that enforces binary Social, Medical and Surrgicla transtion on transgender people becasue you beleive this provides 'freedom'

you have reepatedly been told by trans people, people with primary Qualifying Health Professional Degrees and various other peopel who have a grip of the topic at hand that you view is dogmatic, unhelpful , not reflective of the evidence base and is actively transphobic

you have repeated misquoted the literature on the few occasions you have attempted to mis represent the evidence base to support your position

you have been actively transphobic in the way you refer to a trans masculine acquaintance of yours and when this was pointed out did not apologise, did not demonstrate an learning and continued to doulbe down on your misgendering

and yet you wonder why you have recieved informal and formal warnings about your conduct ...

 

[PTK]

Fabians are indeed more supportive of neo-liberalism (because they aim to collaborate with the bourgeoisie and the bourgeoisie are supportive of neo-liberal capitalism). Reynolds is one of the members of the Fabianite cabinet.

You do not know that about which you are posting.

 

[krtek a houby]

Alright. Let's not blame the ideology but I am still against the fact of calling this "cisnormative" because it does not help at all with solving the issue. Medical transition makes trans people less suicidal and depressed and you have plenty of scholarly proof.

You've gone from degenerates... to solutions.

Classy stuff.

 

[8ball]

O

Alright. Let's not blame the ideology but I am still against the fact of calling this "cisnormative" because it does not help at all with solving the issue. Medical transition makes trans people less suicidal and depressed and you have plenty of scholarly proof.

Interesting conversational judo attempt there..

 

[Yugoslav]

why do you continue to pretend to be confused by this

you have posted a postion that enforces binary Social, Medical and Surrgicla transtion on transgender people becasue you beleive this provides 'freedom'

you have reepatedly been told by trans people, people with primary Qualifying Health Professional Degrees and various other peopel who have a grip of the topic at hand that you view is dogmatic, unhelpful , not reflective of the evidence base and is actively transphobic

you have repeated misquoted the literature on the few occasions you have attempted to mis represent the evidence base to support your position

you have been actively transphobic in the way you refer to a trans masculine acquaintance of yours and when this was pointed out did not apologise, did not demonstrate an learning and continued to doulbe down on your misgendering

and yet you wonder why you have recieved informal and formal warnings about your conduct ...

Let me ask you something.

Why do you have to be pessimistic about this?

Don't you want trans people to live better lives?

Will we ever reach free healthcare if we keep assuming that actually helping people is "cisnormative agenda"?

Do you understand that biological sex is INDEPENDENT of the gender identity and therefore, from a materialist perspective, it negates the whole "gender idealism"?

"Gender-affirming surgery in appropriately selected gender dysphoric patients is associated with decreased postoperative rates of SSRI or SNRI use and improved mental health."
- Gender-Affirming Surgery Improves Mental Health Outcomes and Decreases Antidepressant Use in Patients with Gender Dysphoria - PubMed

 

[krtek a houby]

Stop hassling LGBT people, you fake

 

[Pickman's model]

Let me ask you something.

Why do you have to be pessimistic about this?

Don't you want trans people to live better lives?

Will we ever reach free healthcare if we keep assuming that actually helping people is "cisnormative agenda"?

Do you understand that biological sex is INDEPENDENT of the gender identity and therefore, from a materialist perspective, it negates the whole "gender idealism"?

"Gender-affirming surgery in appropriately selected gender dysphoric patients is associated with decreased postoperative rates of SSRI or SNRI use and improved mental health."
- Gender-Affirming Surgery Improves Mental Health Outcomes and Decreases Antidepressant Use in Patients with Gender Dysphoria - PubMed

Have you ever heard of the medical evidence pyramid?

 

[Yugoslav]

Have you ever heard of the medical evidence pyramid?

SEGM lied about the "increase in mental issues after surgery". You cannot always 100% trust the participant and their wordings. It's about that the participant said for their own perspective, not what the condition actually proved to be. Some may be hiding that for the agenda. Deep down, SEGM is lying about medical transition not improving mental health among trans people.

There is clear empirical outcome! Trans person is more happy when fully transitioned because they're affirmed and they're content and confident of their outlook. These are the main benefits upon completing a gender reassignment surgery and SEGM does not want to admit it.

 

[Pickman's model]

SEGM lied about the "increase in mental issues after surgery". You cannot always 100% trust the participant and their wordings. It's about that the participant said for their own perspective, not what the condition actually proved to be. Some may be hiding that for the agenda. Deep down, SEGM is lying about medical transition not improving mental health among trans people.

There is clear empirical outcome! Trans person is more happy when fully transitioned because they're affirmed and they're content and confident of their outlook. These are the main benefits upon completing a gender reassignment surgery and SEGM does not want to admit it.

That's the longest no I have seen recently

 

[InArduisFouette]

Let me ask you something.

Why do you have to be pessimistic about this?

Don't you want trans people to live better lives?

Will we ever reach free healthcare if we keep assuming that actually helping people is "cisnormative agenda"?

Do you understand that biological sex is INDEPENDENT of the gender identity and therefore, from a materialist perspective, it negates the whole "gender idealism"?

"Gender-affirming surgery in appropriately selected gender dysphoric patients is associated with decreased postoperative rates of SSRI or SNRI use and improved mental health."
- Gender-Affirming Surgery Improves Mental Health Outcomes and Decreases Antidepressant Use in Patients with Gender Dysphoria - PubMed

you really don;t understand this at all do you and feel that you have some great insight and can dictate ot trans people how they should live their lives

as well as your repeated transphpbic comments and misgendering

 

[InArduisFouette]

SEGM lied about the "increase in mental issues after surgery". You cannot always 100% trust the participant and their wordings. It's about that the participant said for their own perspective, not what the condition actually proved to be. Some may be hiding that for the agenda. Deep down, SEGM is lying about medical transition not improving mental health among trans people.

There is clear empirical outcome! Trans person is more happy when fully transitioned because they're affirmed and they're content and confident of their outlook. These are the main benefits upon completing a gender reassignment surgery and SEGM does not want to admit it.

You are the person bringing up SEGM

which is a typicla transphobe dick move , even with your performative allyship

 

[Yugoslav]

you really don;t understand this at all do you and feel that you have some great insight and can dictate ot trans people how they should live their lives

as well as your repeated transphpbic comments and misgendering

Your repeated ignorance amuses me here.

 

[Yugoslav]

You are the person bringing up SEGM

which is a typicla transphobe dick move , even with your performative allyship

Every reply seems to contain the word "transphobe" here. Yet, there is no evidence.

 

[InArduisFouette]

Every reply seems to contain the word "transphobe" here. Yet, there is no evidence.

thanks for confirming you are utterly delusional and without a shread on insight into your frantic ejaculations

 

[Yugoslav]

thanks for confirming you are utterly delusional and without a shread on insight into your frantic ejaculations

I don't know what I confirmed at.

 

[cesare]

I don't know what I confirmed at.

Cobweb left I think

 

[Yugoslav]

Cobweb left I think

Ah. Funny. Anyways...

"A tendency has emerged in Western liberal politics to conflate queerness with progressiveness, placing value on what is perceived as one’s intrinsic identity rather than anti-normative political activity."

- Down with the Rainbow Bourgeoisie - Honi Soit

Don't you think it's about time people actually focus on the Stonewall spirit and not some commercialized month by capitalist class?

 

[Yugoslav]

InArduisFouette

Do you believe in gender idealism? The belief that people can just be whatever gender they are because of what they create and imagine? These days, many people in the West are subscribing to this notion. Yet I thought that we were meant to fight against gender stereotypes and not create new ones.

 

[existentialist]

I thought this thread was dead - there were flies buzzing around it, and everything.

Shame it's not.

 

[editor]

InArduisFouette

Do you believe in gender idealism? The belief that people can just be whatever gender they are because of what they create and imagine? These days, many people in the West are subscribing to this notion. Yet I thought that we were meant to fight against gender stereotypes and not create new ones.

MOD MODE

I think this board is pretty much done with your endless transphobic musings.,

Try a different topic. There's loads of other things to talk about, you know.

 

[krtek a houby]

InArduisFouette

Do you believe in gender idealism? The belief that people can just be whatever gender they are because of what they create and imagine? These days, many people in the West are subscribing to this notion. Yet I thought that we were meant to fight against gender stereotypes and not create new ones.

Change the record

There would be no "gay people" in Africa without Western intervention, and there would be no homophobia either. The West is attempting to export its own degraded model of sexuality onto Africa, and it is using brute financial force in order to do so.

You don't understand. "Gay" and "transgender" are Western categories, which are being forcibly imposed on Africa.

 

[Yugoslav]

Change the record

Is this some sick coincidence?

 

[InArduisFouette]

Is this some sick coincidence?

oh do shut up Phil, Editor has already pretty explicitly warned you