I quite like the 'old Urban' politics threads in the sense of having a focus on ideas, information and consistency, though there was always a point where that could get a bit oppressive to some of those on the receiving end.
There was also the oft repeated notion that it became the domain of middle aged shouty blokes. Shocking, I know! Also, while I might like the idea of the 'old Urban', I'm not that comfortable with the idea of anything like 'enforcing' it.
What all that adds up to, I haven't got a fucking clue. Sheesh, things change a bit. It's fine.