Has anyone here looked at the decision making process in regards to disability benefits and the qualifications of those making those decisions. I am particularly interested in comments from people who have, or who are looking to appear at a 1st or upper tier tribunals.
Its just that in these times of austerity, welfare benefit cuts and the disappearance of a legal aid system that is the only chance for many to access their legal rights. The Tribunal Service that is under the jurisdiction of the Ministry of Justice, is hiring in High Street solicitors to sit as Tribunal Judges and also write up medical decisions and statements ("in their own time") that are denying people benefits.
Knowing what I do about lawyers I would rather a second hand car salesman/woman or a road sweeper make such decisions on my health concerns, but people with some medical experience would be good.
Even people with an ounce of common sense and a pinch of integrity would be acceptable.
It seems to me that based on my own experiences yer local lawyers are having themselves a little feeding frenzy curtousy of said Ministry. Fucking hypocrits.
Below from a FOI request.
MINISTRY OF JUSTICE
FEES FOR FEE PAID COURT AND TRIBUNAL APPOINTMENTS
WEF 01.04.11
01.11.09 [see note 3 below]
01.04.10 [see note 3 below]
01.04.11 [see note 3 below]
Courts (Crown, County, Supreme Court)
Retired Lord of Appeal
940
940
940
Retired Lord Justices (sitting COA)
894
894
894
Retired High Court Judges etc
785
785
785
Deputy High Court Judge
785
785
785
Retired Judges of the TCC (sitting as Deputy Judge of TCC)
630
630
630
Recorder
583
583
583
Deputy Circuit Judge
583
583
583
Assessor, Taxation Tribunal (County Court)
468
468
468
Assessor, Taxation Tribunal (High Court)
468
468
468
Deputy District Judge
468
468
468
Deputy District Judge (Magistrates Courts)
468
468
468
Deputy Judge Advocate
468
468
468
Deputy Supreme Court Master/ Registrar
468
468
468
Tribunals
Upper Tribunal - Administrative Appeals Chamber
Judge (including Deputy Judge) except where otherwise specified
583
583
583
Care Standards
Other member
201
201
201
Information Rights
Judge
n/a
501*
524*
Other member
265
265
265
Transport [Traffic Commissioner Appeals]
Judicial Member (Chairman)
478*
501*
524*
Other member
334
334
334
Upper Tribunal – Immigration and Asylum
Judge
n/a
583
583
Other member
n/a
265
265
Upper Tribunal – Lands Chamber
Member
549
549
549
Upper Tribunal – Tax and Chancery Chamber
Judge
552*
559*
566*
Other member
265
265
265
First-tier Tribunal – General Regulatory Chamber
Former Acting President
-
-
583
Local Government Standards in England (formerly Adjudication Panel For England)
Former President, Adjudication Panel For England
480*
495*
510*
Judge
404*
418*
432*
Other member
184
184
184
Charity
Judge
468
468
468
Other member
265
265
265
Claims Management Services
Chairman
549
549
549
Other member
265
265
265
Consumer Credit Appeals and Estate Agents
Judge
549
549
549
Other member
265
265
265
Gambling Appeals
Judge
468
468
468
Immigration Services
Judge [See note 4, below]
549
549
549
Other member
334
334
334
Information Rights
Judge
468
468
468
Other member
265
265
265
Transport
Principal judge
583
583
583
Judicial Member (Chairman)
468
468
468
Other member
334
334
334
First-tier Tribunal - Health, Education and Social Care Chamber
Care Standards
Judge
417*
428*
439*
Other member
201
201
201
Primary Health Lists (formerly Family Health Services Appeal Authority)
Former President [See note 4, below]
583*
583*
583*
Judge [See note 4, below]
486
486
486
Medical member
336
336
336
Other member
275
275
275
Mental Health
Judge (Restricted Patients’ Panel)
583
583
583
Judge
455*
458*
461*
Medical Member
454
454
454
Other member
212
212
212
Special Education Needs & Disability
Judge
468
468
468
Other member
239
239
239
First-tier Tribunal – Immigration and Asylum
Immigration Judge
468
468
468
Other member
265
265
265
First-tier Tribunal - Social Entitlement Chamber
Asylum Support
Adjudicator
412*
424*
436*
Criminal Injuries Compensation
Legal
397*
412*
427*
Medical Member
391
391
391
Other member
391
391
391
Social Security and Child Support
Judge
412*
424*
436*
Medical Member (medical examination might be required)
371
371
371
Medical Member (no medical examination required) [See note 5, below]
302
310
310
Financial Member
302
302
302
Member with experience of disability
192
192
192
First-tier Tribunal - Tax Chamber
Judge [See note 4, below]
549
549
549
Other member
265
265
265
Newly-appointed judge
468
468
468
Newly-appointed tax member
265
265
265
First-tier Tribunal - War Pensions and Armed Forces
Compensation Chamber
War Pensions and Armed Forces Compensation (previously Pensions Appeal Tribunal)
Judge
455*
458*
461*
Medical Member
454
454
454
Service Member
212
212
212
Other Tribunals
Adjudicator to HM Land Registry
Deputy Adjudicator
468
468
468
Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT)
Recorders
785
785
785
Member [and Assessor (appeals against decisions of Reinstatement Committees)]
303
303
303
Employment Tribunals (England & Wales; & Scotland)
Employment Judge
452*
456*
460*
Member
174
174
174
Gender Recognition Panel [ See Note 1 below]
Judge
412*
424*
436*
Medical Member [ See Note 2 below]
371
371
371
Pensions Appeal Tribunal (Northern Ireland)
Legal & Medical Member
454
454
454
Service Member
212
212
212
Proscribed Organisations Appeals Commission (POAC)
Member
415
415
415
Reserve Forces Appeal Tribunal
Employment Judge/Chair
452*
456*
460*
Non-legal member
174
174
174
Social Security Commissioner and Child Support Commissioners (Northern Ireland)
Deputy Social Security and Child Support Commissioners
583
583
583
Special Immigration Appeals Commission (SIAC)
Non-legal Member
415
415
415
Transport Tribunal
President
583
583
583
Judicial Member (Chairman)
468
468
468
Non-legal Member
334
334
334
Others
Solicitors' Disciplinary Tribunal - Non-legal Member
265
265
265
County Court Assessor (Landlord & Tenant)
265
265
265
County Court Assessor (Race Relations)
265
265
265
County Court Assessor (Sex Discrimination)
265
265
265
Note 1 - Legal members of the GRP are salaried first-tier tribunal judges (Social Entitlement Chamber) who receive no additional remuneration for undertaking GRP work.
Note 2 - Medical members of the GRP are drawn from the pool of Medical members, Social Security and Child Support.
Note 3 - Those fees highlighted by an asterisk include increments of phased increases, introduced from 1 November 2009, awarded further to the introduction of a new pay structure for legally qualified tribunals judiciary. Increases will be applied in April each year, with the final increment in April 2014.
Note 4 - Currently paid on a personal basis.
Note 5 - Once a medical member has sat for more than 20 days in any one financial year, their fee will be £371 for all subsequent sittings during that year.