Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Afghanistan: Mission Accomplished

I googled to see if Tony Blair had said anything.

What I did get was this from 2015 on Afghanistan war.

Blair was still saying then that British military was cornerstone of projecting British influence in the world.

He did the usual infuriating supporting our boys line whatever the policies are.

So at that time unrepentant Liberal imperialist.

Tony Blair Reflects On The Afghanistan War

Forces TV has spoken to Tony Blair - the man who sent British troops into Afghanistan after the 9/11 attacks to fight the Taliban and kill Osama bin L
www.forces.net www.forces.net

Seeing Blair going on just makes my blood boil.

I did oppose Iraq war. On Afghanistan I was mixed.

I don't think Biden should be getting the shit for what's happening now.

What is needed is real look at Bush/ Blair who are main players in this mess.
 
I just saw this post by the Workers Solidarity Federation in Pakistan:

🚨
Mutual Aid Alert
🚨

From our comrades at عصر آنارشیسم - Fedration of Anarchism Era (Afghanistan and Iran):

Donation

asranarshism.com asranarshism.com
 
Last edited:
The difference between me and Tony Blair is that I didnt have the power to send soldiers to die for this.

This insinuation from Blairites that was common during Iraq war that one isn't patriotic if you don't support our boys without question is one of the worst aspects of Blairite Third Way.
 
We had a stall in the town square at the time of the invasion of Afghanistan. We tried pointing out that there was no clear goal in mind. Very little support from the general public. I was called a bleeding heart middle class liberal. I'm no lover of fundamentalist Islam. Taliban, Alquaida, (and the Pope, just to be non-sectarian). It's all crap. But what the fuck does anyone think has been achieved?
 
Kevbad the Bad said:
We had a stall in the town square at the time of the invasion of Afghanistan. We tried pointing out that there was no clear goal in mind. Very little support from the general public. I was called a bleeding heart middle class liberal. I'm no lover of fundamentalist Islam. Taliban, Alquaida, (and the Pope, just to be non-sectarian). It's all crap. But what the fuck does anyone think has been achieved?
Click to expand...
There are pebbles in Afghanistan which were great rocks on 9/11. But that's about it, everything since then, everything the Western powers have done, clearly built on sand
 
brogdale said:
I mean, where are they landing etc?
Click to expand...
Kabul airport I surmise. It is apparently being watched over/protected by 2,000 of the Turkish army’s finest. The Taliban leadership had earlier promised to keep the three mile corridor to the airport free to all who wanted to leave. But I would guess that road would be fraught with danger and the possibility of conflict breaking out spontaneously.
 
Kevbad the Bad said:
We had a stall in the town square at the time of the invasion of Afghanistan. We tried pointing out that there was no clear goal in mind. Very little support from the general public. I was called a bleeding heart middle class liberal. I'm no lover of fundamentalist Islam. Taliban, Alquaida, (and the Pope, just to be non-sectarian). It's all crap. But what the fuck does anyone think has been achieved?
Click to expand...

Lots was achieved, the problem you have is that like many, you only see achievements in stuff that lasts forever, even though nothing last forever.

At its most basic, 9/11 level, for 20 years it was pretty much impossible for groups to base themselves in Afghanistan and to use it as a jumping off point for attacks on other countries/societies.

In Kabul, and a number of other cities, for the best part of 20 years it was possible for a woman to go to school, then university, and then work as Dr's, or civil servants, or teachers, or police officers, and to do so while wearing what she chose to wear, rather than what some bloke in a beard told her to wear. You may not see that as a big deal, but even if it was fleeting, many women in Afghanistan think it is a big deal.

Lots of things didn't work - corruption is rampant, a good number of disgusting abuses are ingrained into Afghan law, and - for good or ill - the jockeying for power among wider family groups is, in effect, still the bedrock of Afghan politics.

By all means discuss and come to a view over whether 'it was worth it', but don't say that nothing was achieved, because it was - such a view is, imv, akin to thinking that the space race achieved nothing because no one lives on the Moon wearing silver Spandex.
 
kebabking said:
Lots was achieved, the problem you have is that like many, you only see achievements in stuff that lasts forever, even though nothing last forever.

At its most basic, 9/11 level, for 20 years it was pretty much impossible for groups to base themselves in Afghanistan and to use it as a jumping off point for attacks on other countries/societies.

In Kabul, and a number of other cities, for the best part of 20 years it was possible for a woman to go to school, then university, and then work as Dr's, or civil servants, or teachers, or police officers, and to do so while wearing what she chose to wear, rather than what some bloke in a beard told her to wear. You may not see that as a big deal, but even if it was fleeting, many women in Afghanistan think it is a big deal.

Lots of things didn't work - corruption is rampant, a good number of disgusting abuses are ingrained into Afghan law, and - for good or ill - the jockeying for power among wider family groups is, in effect, still the bedrock of Afghan politics.

By all means discuss and come to a view over whether 'it was worth it', but don't say that nothing was achieved, because it was - such a view is, imv, akin to thinking that the space race achieved nothing because no one lives on the Moon wearing silver Spandex.
Click to expand...
9/11 was by extremists from Saudi Arabia. Yet no invasion of that country.

So why not invasion of that country?
 
The human cost of the war, per the AP:

American service members killed in Afghanistan through April: 2,448.

U.S. contractors: 3,846.

Afghan national military and police: 66,000.

Other allied service members, including from other NATO member states: 1,144.

Afghan civilians: 47,245.

Taliban and other opposition fighters: 51,191.

Aid workers: 444.

Journalists: 72.
 
kebabking said:
Lots was achieved, the problem you have is that like many, you only see achievements in stuff that lasts forever, even though nothing last forever.

At its most basic, 9/11 level, for 20 years it was pretty much impossible for groups to base themselves in Afghanistan and to use it as a jumping off point for attacks on other countries/societies.

In Kabul, and a number of other cities, for the best part of 20 years it was possible for a woman to go to school, then university, and then work as Dr's, or civil servants, or teachers, or police officers, and to do so while wearing what she chose to wear, rather than what some bloke in a beard told her to wear. You may not see that as a big deal, but even if it was fleeting, many women in Afghanistan think it is a big deal.

Lots of things didn't work - corruption is rampant, a good number of disgusting abuses are ingrained into Afghan law, and - for good or ill - the jockeying for power among wider family groups is, in effect, still the bedrock of Afghan politics.

By all means discuss and come to a view over whether 'it was worth it', but don't say that nothing was achieved, because it was - such a view is, imv, akin to thinking that the space race achieved nothing because no one lives on the Moon wearing silver Spandex.
Click to expand...
9/11 did not happen because of the Taliban, nor anything happening in Afghanistan. It was financed by Saudis, carried out by Saudis and one Pakistani, probably planned in Germany, and most of the training took place in the USA. When the invasion of Afghanistan happened the Taliban did not control the whole country and who knows how things might have turned out? Now it looks like they might control the whole place.
 
Osama Bin Laden was holed up there though. He was still doing interviews with ABC News at the turn of the century.
 
kebabking said:
Lots was achieved, the problem you have is that like many, you only see achievements in stuff that lasts forever, even though nothing last forever.

At its most basic, 9/11 level, for 20 years it was pretty much impossible for groups to base themselves in Afghanistan and to use it as a jumping off point for attacks on other countries/societies.

In Kabul, and a number of other cities, for the best part of 20 years it was possible for a woman to go to school, then university, and then work as Dr's, or civil servants, or teachers, or police officers, and to do so while wearing what she chose to wear, rather than what some bloke in a beard told her to wear. You may not see that as a big deal, but even if it was fleeting, many women in Afghanistan think it is a big deal.

Lots of things didn't work - corruption is rampant, a good number of disgusting abuses are ingrained into Afghan law, and - for good or ill - the jockeying for power among wider family groups is, in effect, still the bedrock of Afghan politics.

By all means discuss and come to a view over whether 'it was worth it', but don't say that nothing was achieved, because it was - such a view is, imv, akin to thinking that the space race achieved nothing because no one lives on the Moon wearing silver Spandex.
Click to expand...
Have you seen post 533?
 
glitch hiker said:
I see Gollum (rory stewart) is trending again. Somehow everyone thinks this guy is a hero.

His voting record is as much a litany of shit (a shitany, if you will) as the rest of them. Voted for climate change, voted for poverty. A cunt
Click to expand...
I remember about the time he was finding out the Tory party didn't want him m as leader there as an open debate in the Commons on Afghanistan.. He was too busy campaigning to share insight tgen
 
Yossarian said:
Ted Rall called it right back in December 2001.



www.villagevoice.com

How We Lost Afghanistan - The Village Voice

DASHT-E QALEH, AFGHANISTAN—We’ve lost this war. So how much will it cost? In 1842, the First Afghan War ended with an infamous retreat across the Hindu Kush that cost between 10,000 and 15,000 Brits and their camp followers their lives. One guy, a Dr. Brydon, survived the Afghans to tell the...
www.villagevoice.com www.villagevoice.com

His view this week on critics of the US withdrawal:



rall.com

Stop Listening to the Pro-War Idiots Who Got Afghanistan Wrong | Ted Rall's Rallblog

You’re going to read a lot of Afghan War postmortems in the coming days. Some have already been published. Don’t listen to anyone who was ever in favor of occupying Afghanistan. They were wrong for thinking that the United States could have won. They were stupid to think that invading...
rall.com rall.com
Click to expand...
Wow, I didn't know there was an American journalist who gets it, and has always got it. Thanks for posting it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

PTK
Afghanistan: UK special forces 'killed 9 people in their beds'
Replies
24
Views
1K
Silas Loom
Silas Loom
weltweit
Afghanistan Earthquake, Taliban ask for help ..
Replies
6
Views
542
blossie33
blossie33
StoneRoad
Taliban [Afghanistan] destroy music
2
Replies
53
Views
2K
Pickman's model
Pickman's model
crossthebreeze
US drops 'mother of all bombs' (not nuclear) on Afghanistan
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
169
Views
7K
JimW
JimW
DrRingDing
Afghanistan mission accomplished, says David Cameron
2
Replies
45
Views
3K
gosub
gosub
Back
Top Bottom