Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

So Tesla

I ordered one a few years ago, delivery was postponed many times and I ended up selling my allocation back to them for about $30 profit. They have the best charging infrastructure and battery/powertrain technology but the cars themselves are quite shoddily built. I've only ever driven a Model S and it is a fantastic driving experience, no doubt about that. However, the competition are now upping their game and if I wanted a BEV now I think I'd get a BMW i4.
 
I drove a friend’s e-tron recently, wow, just wow! Instant kick when you hit the throttle. As well as being electric it is an Audi so is beautifully kitted out and is very well built. Plus it winds up divs who hate Audis cos Top Gear told them to switch their ire away from Beemers to the four ringed beasts.
 
I drove a friend’s e-tron recently, wow, just wow! Instant kick when you hit the throttle. As well as being electric it is an Audi so is beautifully kitted out and is very well built. Plus it winds up divs who hate Audis cos Top Gear told them to switch their ire away from Beemers to the four ringed beasts.

It's only 10 grand cheaper than the Taycan base model which will hold its value better. Unless you need the extra space of the e-tron you're better off with the better range and performance (2 speed PDK) of the Taycan.
 
What's the verdict? Anyone ever driven one? Some saying it's the greatest car ever made and all that bollocks.

I hired one for a day when I was on a business trip to San Francisco a few years ago - just to go to a few meetings in Palo Alto and San José. I’m not really into cars but was curious.

It was incredibly smooth and fast to drive. Virtually silent so easy to find yourself going too fast. The guy I hired it from (did it through Turo so private hire) had forgotten to top it up so I spent the afternoon worrying that I was going to run out of juice.

Can’t remember model but here’s a cheesy pic:

DB577B31-5417-4677-84F3-0BB42CAE7B3B.jpeg
 
It's only 10 grand cheaper than the Taycan base model which will hold its value better. Unless you need the extra space of the e-tron you're better off with the better range and performance (2 speed PDK) of the Taycan.


He has dogs. But he was salivating over the RS GT etron, which is not far off the Taycan Turbo S, which would be much better.
 
Took a model 3 for a test drive. I’m 5’2” and I found it really low to the ground. The charging network is great, must admit. We have just got a Hyundai kona electric and more than happy
 
They are silly rapid when i have come across them accelerating on the Autobahn. Also the Tesla supercharge network is a massive infrastructure project in Germany. Kinda compatible tho - a hour at 140 mph, then you've got no option but to pull off' let the whole thing cool down and charge the fucker up again whilst you have a beer and some mett. better off with a diesel germanbox that will get you from Berlin to munich in one hit.
 
Not driven one but my cousin's husband has a Model S for his daily commute in the states. It was great passenger experience and the screens inside were amazing. However the build quality. given you are paying luxury car prices is far more 'American' than it is 'German'...
 
I drove my brother-in-law's Model S. Super torquey, but surprisingly lacking in fun factor. Letting it rive itself was a wierd feeling; I couldn't relax, but presume I'd get more confident in it over time.
 
Last edited:
It vexes me mildly that the early all electric cars have all been expensive up-market cars, sold on things like their acceleration. If Tesla had started off with a more affordable small family car I might have a higher opinion of them.

D'you think that's becuause the R&D and manufacturing costs are too high to make a fully electric car that could compete in that segment?
 
D'you think that's becuause the R&D and manufacturing costs are too high to make a fully electric car that could compete in that segment?
Yeah, I get the R&D costs, but once you've done the R&D, why not stick it in a Focus/Zafira type car and shift 100,000s of them?

We're meant to be saving the planet.
 
Yeah, I get the R&D costs, but once you've done the R&D, why not stick it in a Focus/Zafira type car and shift 100,000s of them?

We're meant to be saving the planet.
Cos it takes time & a lot of money to scale up to the volumes required, so they "practiced" with the model S while building up the production capacity and proving to investors that they've got the chops for a mass market car.
 
Yeah, I get the R&D costs, but once you've done the R&D, why not stick it in a Focus/Zafira type car and shift 100,000s of them?

We're meant to be saving the planet.

I don't know whether that tech can be produced at a price low enough to compete with a Focus (people are willing to pay a premium for performance that they're not willing to pay to reduce emissions).
 
Tesla are still getting by on credits from the US government (and sometimes selling them to other manufacturers) to a fair extent. Also, other manufacturers did make mass market cheap EVs but they were all flops. And automotive trends usually do tend to be popularised by the rich first.
 
Tesla are still getting by on credits from the US government (and sometimes selling them to other manufacturers) to a fair extent. Also, other manufacturers did make mass market cheap EVs but they were all flops. And automotive trends usually do tend to be popularised by the rich first.

Trickle-down, innit.
 
Yeah, I get the R&D costs, but once you've done the R&D, why not stick it in a Focus/Zafira type car and shift 100,000s of them?

We're meant to be saving the planet.
Even cheaper models by non-luxury brands are still pricey. VW no longer seems to be offering the e-Golf, but the ID3, which is kind of a Polo type of car, costs from 30k to 42k. Fucking laughable frankly
 
It’s how the car industry works - this was the UK model described to me. Change the brands for other countries

1. some bloke with a beard* in a university invents something.

2. BWAB works with a spin off company to get that something to the point it can be used in motorsport - probably F1 but coukd be somewhere else. 5 cars in the world have it and it costs millions of pounds per car.

3. McClaren or Aston Martin ( before they start using Mercedes tech) puts the something in their fuck off million pound supercar. 20- 50 get sold.

4. AM put it in their city boy bonus, retired accountant car 1000/2000 get sold.

5. JLR put it in their luxury Jag 10,000 /30,000 get sold.

6. The mass market manufacturers put it in their cars millions get sold.

This has been the developed path for 70 odd years - see ABS or composites .

(* These days BWAB may not be a bloke with a beard).
 
I refuse to drive a car that won't start unless it downloads some updates. Cars might be better with computers, but they sure as hell should not behave like computers.
 
I refuse to drive a car that won't start unless it downloads some updates. Cars might be better with computers, but they sure as hell should not behave like computers.

A Tesla will drive just fine if it has updates pending. You just can't drive it, for obvious reasons, while it is updating. The updates can be scheduled to happen in the middle of the night or whenever.
 
Even cheaper models by non-luxury brands are still pricey. VW no longer seems to be offering the e-Golf, but the ID3, which is kind of a Polo type of car, costs from 30k to 42k. Fucking laughable frankly

About twice the cost of a petrol polo, which has a much greater range, and none of the hassle and delays of charging! Until they make them similar ballpark in terms of costs, I can't see a big voluntary uptake of fully electric cars.
 
Back
Top Bottom