Gender idealism?

[Sweet FA]

bourgeois revisionist propaganda caused by postmodernist Frankfurtian thinking that led to the degradation of leftist sympathy for leftists of non-Western nations.

 

[existentialist]

Fuxake, it's an obvious troll. Someone familiar with the board, probably banned for whatever, and striking controversial poses that they know will encourage responses of various kinds.

I think you're right. I've thrown out a few softball questions that a True Believer would have been all over, but this one hasn't bitten once, just rolled around into the same circular arguments.

Someone's having a bit of stupid fun.

 

[Yugoslav]

It failed.

It failed because you failed to grasp it. That's reactionary.

 

[Elpenor]

Fuxake, it's an obvious troll. Someone familiar with the board, probably banned for whatever, and striking controversial poses that they know will encourage responses of various kinds.

Cranaddict must have had a few theory books for Christmas

 

[Yugoslav]

"The social-democrats began their betrayal by getting away from the basic teachings of Marxism-Leninism, which they proclaim as out-dated and inexpedient, by renouncing the class struggle and replacing it with the "theory" of harmony and reconciliation of classes, by negating the revolution and replacing it with reforms within the capitalist order, by giving up the revolutionary way and replacing it with "peaceful", "democratic" and parliamentary method, by denying the indispensability of breaking up the old bourgeois state machinery and accepting the capitalist state as a means to cross over to socialism, by withholding their assent to the dictatorship of the proletariat and replacing it with "pure and general democracy", by departing from proletarian internationalism and going so far the other way as to plunge into positions of the national-chauvinists, to open union with the imperialist bourgeoisie."

- The Modern Revisionists

This analysis is undeniable proof that Marxism-Leninism does not tolerate gender idealism, especially the revisionists who are trying to reinforce traditional gender norms the opposite way. Gender ought to be abolished as a label and in a society of communism, there is man, woman, and Intersex, the three material aspects of gender itself from nothing more than basic elementary school biology.

 

[A380]

They’ve nicked your full stops on here as well.

 

[existentialist]

They’ve nicked your full stops on here as well.

"From each according to his needs..."

 

[krink]

Fuxake, it's an obvious troll. Someone familiar with the board, probably banned for whatever, and striking controversial poses that they know will encourage responses of various kinds.

These troll/banned returner threads bore the crap out of me. If I was the boss they wouldn't get past 1 post. Why people indulge these sad people is a mystery.

 

[krtek a houby]

These troll/banned returner threads bore the crap out of me. If I was the boss they wouldn't get past 1 post. Why people indulge these sad people is a mystery.

Because, imho, some of them are incredibly toxic and they can linger and fuck up threads for months or years.

There's enough trolls and shit posters on social media, they shouldn't be here.

 

[InArduisFouette]

It failed because you failed to grasp it. That's reactionary.

There's only one thing you appear to grasp and that is a part of your anatomy ...

 

[InArduisFouette]

These troll/banned returner threads bore the crap out of me. If I was the boss they wouldn't get past 1 post. Why people indulge these sad people is a mystery.

I suppose we ought to move the thread to a 'comedy greats' section now

 

[Silas Loom]

I still think it’s a Bosnian posting in good faith. Comedy personas don’t have this level of stamina.

 

[existentialist]

I still think it’s a Bosnian posting in good faith. Comedy personas don’t have this level of stamina.

Bosnian, perhaps. Good faith? Not so sure. Though I still think it's more likely to be someone tweaking our collective noses.

 

[Yugoslav]

you really are talking shite here

a genuine and compassionate response to trans people , regardless of their or your politico-ideological-philosophical position should be

1. I want to ensure you have access to the Gender affirming care you want or need at your pace and without judgement
2. I want a society that accepts you as you are and has legal protections for people who are gender incongruent / have the protected Characteristic of Gender Reassignment ( which the UK's Equality act 2010 aims to do on paper and was doing until the Selfservatives tried to undermine it and the EHRC by packign the EHRC with stooges)
3. i want a legal system which either does not record sex and gender unless needed for clinical purposes OR has a system of self declaration with suitable protectiosn against the system being abused.


and if peopel want to claim a 'trans agenda' the above three points are what it might actually look like , rather than the MAGAt/ Evangintal ./TERF wank -addled pornsick lunacy around ' cross dressing men dominating women;s sports' , 'transing children at school' and 'furries shitting in litter trays in the classroom' ...

You're almost there but you fail to realize that not everyone has a "transgender consciousness" (gender dysphoria). You should pick carefully on who to affirm and medically transition because you don't wanna ruin the wrong person's body or life. Hence, a two-stage path towards gender-affirming care which includes a therapy, a fulfillment of medical criteria from such, and finally entering the medical transition in which the trans person is liberated of their misery of the "wrong body".

 

[existentialist]

You're almost there but you fail to realize that not everyone has a "transgender consciousness" (gender dysphoria). You should pick carefully on who to affirm and medically transition because you don't wanna ruin the wrong person's body or life. Hence, a two-stage path towards gender-affirming care which includes a therapy, a fulfillment of medical criteria from such, and finally entering the medical transition in which the trans person is liberated of their misery of the "wrong body".

Ah, still demonstrating your notorious flexibility of mind, then?

 

[Yugoslav]

Ah, still demonstrating your notorious flexibility of mind, then?

The downfall of communism was the downfall of a society as a whole.

 

[existentialist]

The downfall of communism was the downfall of a society as a whole.

I think quite a lot of people in Russia, and the former Soviet republics, might not agree with you.