Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

What stupid shit has Trump done today?

Wanted to reply properly to this when I had time, because while other posters have pointed out some of your logic quirks, there are some really serious points here to discuss.

Firstly, it's a two party system, so just founding a new party isn't that quite straightforward - Sanders reached an audience that would never have been possible if he hadn't campaigned within the Democratic Party. And I think that was the right thing to do. I wish, I really wish, that Sanders had gone further, and having reached that wide audience by running for the Dem nomination he had stood as an independent in the Presidential election and used that to build a new party. This was easily achievable - at one point he had 550,000 people contributing to his campaign on monthly direct debits, most of them outside of the Dems, which could have provided the basis for a new party. Possibly you will feel that people shouldn't use your party for their own agenda's. I really don't care - the Dems are the political representatives of capital and big business. The people who own and control your party are the enemy. There is nothing useful about the Democrats whatsoever, except that it provided a platform for Sanders. Which he wasted, the silly reformist fuck.



First of all, nobody is denying that for the majority of black Americans (not all) their life experiences are more limited than white/wealthy people. That's also the case by the way for working class people in relation to wealthy people. But fuck your noise about black Americans being somehow more homogenous as a racial group. Seriously, fuck off.

You are correct to say that universal programs in the past have excluded people. That does not mean on any level that Black Americans dont support free healthcare and free education, and I guarantee you will produce no evidence that a majority of Black Americans feel that way. As for Black Americans supporting Clinton's policies, what fucking policies? All she offered was a continuation of Obama. As for bringing an end to structural racism, nobody thought Sanders was going to achieve that, obviously a Presidential election was never gonna solve that problem whoever the candidate was - are you trying to claim Clinton was going to eradicate structural racism? You're chucking shit to see what sticks because you oppose free healthcare and free education and you don't want a genuine political alternative for working class people (Black or otherwise) to develop.



Sanders isn't perfect by any means - but he sees what you can't. Because he's right - the majority of Trump voters are people who are struggling economically and who chose "something different" to the "more of the same pain" Clinton offered. Clinton was the most establishment Presidential candidate in history. She went on telly promising to put coal miners out of jobs and demanding to know why she wasn't ahead in the polls. Trump said he would create jobs. Do you not see how this was not a good strategy? Clinton was literally the only candidate that could have lost to Trump and the fact that she did does not make millions of ordinary working class people racists.

Everyone is painfully aware that vicious, systemic racism remains one of the most oppressive elements of US capitalism. Sanders has done a lot more to challenge that than you and your fucking Democrat scum politicians, you dirty scab.

It's really not worth the time and effort with her but I think you've just found that out.
 
well trumps been in nearly a year and there hasn't been a nuclear holocaust.
so that's one major success.
a level of achievement you haven't killed everyone:hmm:
theirs setting a low standard but this is ridiculous:facepalm:
 
  • Like
Reactions: CRI
If support for Sanders came from outside the Democratic Party, my suggestion would be that he build his base of support either within a different party, or found his own. I genuinely don't understand the obsession with dragging the Democratic party in a direction most members don't want, rather than trying to influence its direction by discussion, listening to the base and yes, compromise.

African Americans have a narrower range of experiences in America because of the constraints of white supremacy. There was literal segregation of public spaces and services that in parts of America that was still in place during my lifetime. There were "Sundown Towns" elsewhere, and "zoning policies" that barred Black folks from renting or buying in some areas. There were government backed programmes like New Deal and the GI Bill that weren't open to Black Americans, but set up a whole cohort of white blue collar folks with greater financial and social stability they could pass on through the generations. Many Trade Unions excluded Black workers, and shop floors were often segregated with jobs occupied by white workers attracting better salaries and conditions. Even now, we see white supremacy at work in the way communities are policed, how crises are managed (or not), how education is resourced, etc. White people, even those that are poorer with limited opportunities still don't suffer the limitations POC do within a white supremacist nation.

There is information out there that shows African Americans backed Clinton because they liked her policies and they generally aren't convinced by the message Sanders and his followers are giving out even now. For example, you've mentioned universal health care and free education. I've posted lots of links before, but it's not hard to find articles, blogs and social media discussions from African Americans explaining exactly why they aren't convinced by the "if it's good for everyone, it will be good for you" argument. History tells us that "universal programmes" can still exclude some people (see New Deal, GI Bill, etc.) and it tends to be the people who are already more advantaged get the most from these. And, you'll also see that they're not buying the idea that Sanders' approach will bring an end to structural racism or the mechanisms of white supremacy because well, they don't actually address them at all.

In a recent Ohio Rally, Trump said, "I think that the vast majority of Trump supporters are people who are in pain, who are struggling economically, who are worried to death that their kids are going to be in even worse shape economically than they are, and they turned to Trump because Trump said things that made sense." Back in March, he said, "Some people think that the people who voted for Trump are racists and sexists and homophobes and deplorable folks. I don't agree . . ." He's has said similar things on other occasions. His continuing refusal to genuinely acknowledge and condemn the racism of Trump and his supporters undermines efforts to "reach out" to Black Americans.

You said, "Your suggestion they "prefer" Clinton sounds like bollocks and a lot of African Americans would have liked Sanders policies like universal health care and free education." Black voters aren't stupid. They understood the respective policies of Clinton and Sanders, and of Clinton and Trump and made their choices who to support accordingly. I'd suggest so long as Sanders fails to acknowledge the magnitude of white supremacy in the US and persists with the fantasy that universal social programmes and wealth redistribution will make that all go away, he's never going to get significant numbers of African Americans to back him. My worry is he's too afraid of alienating his own base of support, who either think the whole racism thing is over-blown and/or frankly don't want to critically examine their own part in perpetuating white supremacy. So, sadly, I think he'll still be chasing that unicorn disaffected, economically anxious, blue collar Trump supporter who just needs a bit of tlc and they'll convert the Sanders cause. Maybe someone will follow him who does have the have the courage to leave the comfort zone, but I'm not seeing signs of that yet. :(

I wonder if there will ever be a black president... oh, hang on...
 
Yeah, I remember when Obama was elected and racism ended. Except maybe for that guy who was always going on about how Obama was not a real American at all but a fraudster who was actually born in Africa, whatever happened to him?

He became president. You couldn't make it up, could you?
 
Yeah, I remember when Obama was elected and racism ended. Except maybe for that guy who was always going on about how Obama was not a real American at all but a fraudster who was actually born in Africa, whatever happened to him?
Tbf was a common muttering that he wouldn't last a term without getting shot let alone two... US Dibble are good at some shit... Which is increasingly unfortunate
 
  • Like
Reactions: CRI
Happy festivus, you dirty scab :D

It's been quite a year for you, CRI. As a strong minded poster, braving the ugly sniping from a shrill minority, some of whom used unacepptable language here. Shame on them. Keep up the posts and don't be intimidated.

(but the Democrats are a load of poo, mind)

Plugging one's fingers into one's ears is not being "strong minded", that's being wilfully blind. There's also nothing brave about that either.

Also, CRI has falsely accused multiple people of being racist, and still hasn't apologised to any of them. That's not strong-minded or brave either, but is in fact the mark of a coward willing to throw any shit in the hope that it sticks.

The fact that you're sticking up for this disgrace says a lot about you, none of it good.
 
Plugging one's fingers into one's ears is not being "strong minded", that's being wilfully blind. There's also nothing brave about that either.

Also, CRI has falsely accused multiple people of being racist, and still hasn't apologised to any of them. That's not strong-minded or brave either, but is in fact the mark of a coward willing to throw any shit in the hope that it sticks.

The fact that you're sticking up for this disgrace says a lot about you, none of it good.
You're nothing more than a bullying gang of cunts.

Self-appointed mouthpieces of the working class? Fuck off, all of you.

Who on earth would want to be associated with such reprehensible behaviour?

 
You're nothing more than a bullying gang of cunts.

Self-appointed mouthpieces of the working class? Fuck off, all of you.

Who on earth would want to be associated with such reprehensible behaviour?



What bullying? What reprehensible behaviour? Can you point to even a single occurrence that was not done as a response to CRI 's own terrible behaviour?

Because all I've seen are people either trying to engage with her and being ignored, or people firing back after being subjected to false accusations of bigotry.
 
You're nothing more than a bullying gang of cunts.

Self-appointed mouthpieces of the working class? Fuck off, all of you.

Who on earth would want to be associated with such reprehensible behaviour?



Congratulations on making CRI look reasonable and coherent.
 
Merry Christmas to all you fuckers! As I've said, I like being here, just to hear another opinion on just how fucked up things are. Everyone I know voted for Trump, and still stand by the fuck. I voted for Clinton.
 
The man is on form :D:D:D



why, even he himself used to be oppressed!

HH-tweet4.jpg
 
You pull shit like this, and yet you have the gall to whine when people have a go at you for your shit politics?

My politics are better than yours, waaah!

I'm going to get my mates after you, boo!

Merry fuckin xmas,bah humbug.

ETA:

Ok, that's not going to help matters much. Let me try again.

There's a lot more important shit going on than CRI's posts in this thread. Surely it's more important to digest and discuss the daily drip drip of Trump horrors that impact not just the US but the environment, the rest of the world and so on?

There's plenty of jaw dropping headlines all the time and going after one poster because her politics aren't as sophisiticated as the next person's is a bit pointless.

Yes, US Presidents don't have a particularly inspiring track record. Yes, it would be nice if there was an alternative to the Dem/Repub switcheroo but that's unlikely for now.

What can be achieved in the meantime, to bring about real change?

(I'm asking that one for my own curiosity as it's driving me to distraction)
 
Last edited:
There's plenty of jaw dropping headlines all the time and going after one poster because her politics aren't as sophisiticated as the next person's is a bit pointless.

I can't speak for anyone else, but "sophistication" (whatever that is supposed to mean, I'd hardly call myself well-read politically) has nothing to do with the problems I have with CRI and her political fellow-travellers.

My problem is that liberal politics is as anti-working class as the Tories, we saw that plainly in the aftermath of the Brexit and Trump votes in which various "progressive" types threw their toys out of the pram and declared a majority of the electorate to be irredeemable "thickos" (or "deplorables" if you're American), as well as increased talk about requiring people to pass political tests in order to vote.

In other words, on many liberals the mask has slipped. Rather than face up to and examine the causes of why their political vehicles in the Clinton and Remain campaigns lost, they instead dropped the pretence of being in favour of democracy.

With CRI in particular, one of the problems I have with her politics is the way she writes off entire populations as irredeemably bigoted, now and forever. If people like her are not even going to attempt to build bridges within a working class that has been divided against itself by its class enemies, then they are part of the problem, not the solution.
 
Back
Top Bottom