I could be catching up up with the great classics of cinema I've missed out in and watch those Eric Rohmer and Bela Tarr movies I've never seen but here we are.
Butt Boy is an extension of a comedy sketch by the YouTube comedy collective Tiny Cinema. The plan must have been to make the best film possible from the most stupid, most purile premise imaginable. This is about a family man who discovers he derives great pleasure from shoving things up his butt. At first small objects start disappearing, eventually pets and small children go missing too.
The odd thing is that the film treats this almost completely straight. It is very stylishly made, in an 80s retro-cool way, like a neo-noir serial killer procedural with a synth score and cinematography reminiscent of the movie Drive. There is a stakeout sequence at night with a Spielberg-sky of twinkling stars and I though, why did they take such care to make this look beautiful ?
The problem is, that the length of a feature film can't sustain its one-joke premise and it's not outrageous and tasteless enough. I was hoping for something as insane, funny and outright peculiar as The Greasy Strangler, but during the mid-section this really drags and it isn't funny enough. The last act gets increasingly surreal but the logistics of the butt magic never convinced me. I'm probably looking for sense and reason in all the wrong places. I never though I'd say this about a film, but considering its premise, this isn't scatologial enough.
Watching the movies you don't have to...
Gretel & Hansel was much better, though not perfect. It's a horror retelling of the fairy tale and the spooky world it createst is gorgeous, somewhere between a fairy tale past and a future black-magic dystopia. The pacing and plotting is a little wobbly, but its atmosphere and visual invention carry it. If you like gothic horror, check it out, it's the best horror update of a classic fairy tale I've seen.