Even at the national level, fans seem resistant to seeing their sport and their passion co-opted for political ends. At the club level, such gambits are not only futile but likely to be counterproductive. Swansea and Cardiff, like Manchester United and Liverpool, Spurs and Arsenal, Portsmouth and Bouremouth are implacable rivals and enemies, not regional allies. Most would back the Mladic First XI over their neighbour. Some appear to enjoy seeing their rival fail more than witnessing their own club succeed. This is tribalism at the purest form western life now allows. It is not always healthy or pleasant (and in Cardiff and Swansea’s case, like Celtic and Rangers’, it is often decidedly ugly) but it is a fact and it can’t be wished away with platitudes or appeals for a higher, Welsh sense of unity.
Nor should it be. Leaving aside the violence and intimidation that often attends the meeting of these two great Welsh clubs, there should be room inside modern Welshness for distinctive, divergent, rival regions, for impassioned sporting tribalism and for heartfelt and irreconcilable differences of opinion. Gwynfor Evans spoke of Wales as a “community of communities”, a plural, diverse collection of communities that together comprise a national polity. Yet little of this notion now appears to survive within Wales’s modern nation-building discourse. Instead, and increasingly, Wales is described aspirationally as an undifferentiated entity, united within itself by its distinctiveness from the Outside Other. Appropriate concern is paid toward ethnic diversity, while elsewhere all other such divisions are there to be battered down or overcome. For some, such as those disparities of wealth, opportunity and aspiration, this is right and proper. But in a quest to forge the Welsh sense of self into something that functions as a civic mentality, the danger of is prescribing a monocultural Wales, where all must commit to their Welshness above – and even to the exclusion of – all others, and where rivalry within this suffocating entity is to be deplored and discouraged, in the name of preventing a return to divide and rule.