Netpol's report out today on the policing of pro Palestine protests
Read the full report now.
I did feel it could be a bit more nuanced. Its correct that sections of media and some politicians ( from left and right) did and are trying to smear those who demonstrate as anti Semitic and or extremists. However despite the best efforts of the Suella Braverman Met did not try to ban demos.
I do feel however the post these demos and in future a government may try to lower the bar for Met to be able to ban protests. So agree with report that protest needs defending.
On the bit in report about collusion between those opposing demos and police. Felt this was a bit overdone. Whilst its clear that groups like CAA and other pro Zionist groups have done their best to discredit demos/ protestors. Even Met do not always go along with this. Take the I cant walk across London as a Jew safely accusation at recent march. Where Met go it in the neck for not facilitating this attempted provocation.
Given my couple of reservations its a good report. And all respect to those who volunteer as observers.
My feeling is from being on demos is that the police are closely filming them and watching people. I've found it quite intrusive and its like the authorities are looking over ones shoulder. They make it clear they are doing it. The sheer numbers of those attending mean its difficult for police to do this but they are trying to.
The general atmosphere has changed and I do not see people with placards about genocide being told to take them down now. Since the ICJ saying their is a case to answer. I did witness this in earlier demo.
I agree with the report that the IHRA definition of anti semitism plus examples is what the police have been using.
From page 6
A climate since October 2023 where political speech and protest criticising the state of
Israel is policed almost entirely as a potential ‘hate crime’, based on a very strict adoption
of the IHRA definition of antisemitism by the government and by the College of Policing.
Listening to spokesperson from one of the student occupations in UK and one of their demands is the UNI drop the IHRA definition.
Something I agree with.
The IHRA plus examples can be easily used to discredit people who are anti Zionist. And equates anti Zionism with anti semitism.