Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Is it too late?

I don’t see revolution happening in my lifetime though and past experience suggests that it just creates a new 'ruling class', let alone do anything for the environment. It's hard not to be fatalistic. I feel very down tbh :(
have you not seen how much the world has changed in the last 40 years?
China have changed their system twice since the 80s, Africa and South Asia where most of the people are still don't have proper systems in place, it's still all open in the main parts of the world
 
Think I've posted this before, and I've never actually listened to/read most of their stuff, but Live Like the World is Dying seems like a reasonable perspective on this subject: About, Live Like the World is Dying

Has anyone ever actually read Desert? (I haven't read it all the way through myself.)
 
Think I've posted this before, and I've never actually listened to/read most of their stuff, but Live Like the World is Dying seems like a reasonable perspective on this subject: About, Live Like the World is Dying

Has anyone ever actually read Desert? (I haven't read it all the way through myself.)

Yeah, not for ages though. Broadly says we're fucked and give up on hope as it's pseudo-religious and an impediment, but don't give up on the possibility of change; largely that'll happen in areas that are 'peripheral' to capital, and that have some collective memory and practical ability to survive the retreat/collapse of state and capital. And that some of the collapse will also open up new spaces for people to rediscover better ways of living. Something like that? Here for those of you that haven't seen it Desert

I nearly mentioned the quote in the first page earlier... “It’s not the despair — I can handle the despair. It’s the hope I can’t handle.”
 
Last edited:
Think I've posted this before, and I've never actually listened to/read most of their stuff, but Live Like the World is Dying seems like a reasonable perspective on this subject: About, Live Like the World is Dying

Has anyone ever actually read Desert? (I haven't read it all the way through myself.)
Margaret Killjoy is great, they did


Will read through later
 
Yeah, not for ages though. Broadly says we're fucked and give up on hope as it's pseudo-religious and an impediment, but not on the possibility of change; largely that'll happen in areas that are 'peripheral' to capital, and that have some collective memory and practical ability to survive the retreat/collapse of state and capital. And that some of the collapse will also open up new spaces for people to rediscover better ways of living. Something like that? Here for those of you that haven't seen it Desert

I nearly mentioned the quote in the first page earlier... “It’s not the despair — I can handle the despair. It’s the hope I can’t handle.”
Yeah, from what I've seen of it I wasn't too impressed the first time round, but as time goes by it feels harder and harder to refute the "we're fucked" bit. Feels like it may be the kind of text where even if you disagree with it, thinking about why and how you disagree with it might be productive?
 
I don’t think humanity is heading for extinction but it seems harder and harder to stop a future in which too many other animals are. :( not to mention millions of people dying due to water shortages, extreme heat etc
I think the most likley outcome is mass extinctions of plants and animals. Billions less humans than now and a loss of industrial society,
 
If you want to try and avoid despair about the climate emergency, if only so as to be able to keep trying to do something, read this novel.

View attachment 334208

It was probably a mistake to read this so soon after 40 degrees here. It's mostly making me angry. Started it a few days ago.

We'll see how it ends up. It's a funny old book, half story and half rant asking what the fuck, and telling us we have the tools to change already.
 
I heard a good analogy last night:

Imagine dice with the 6 face being an extreme weather event.

(The summer of 77 or whatever, before my time.)


We are now playing with die that have more than one 6 face, meaning sequences of 6s becoming more and more likely. Added to which it's not random probability an extreme weather event increases that occurrence of more.
 
For it not to be too late I think there has to be a constant media interest in the progress towards zero, there was interest at the time of Glasgow but then there was Covid 19 and then there was Ukraine which both seem to have banished climate off the front pages altogether.

This is not good, we need constant pressure on the decision makers, daily stories, weekly pressure, regular updates as to progress.

In short we need those in power to know that we the electorate care deeply about achieving net zero and going further, that it matters, that they will be held to account for their progress or lack of it.
 
I had, after certain point, considered Greenland as a possible escape from global Warming. I've no I dea what is involved in immigration to Greenland
 
I had, after certain point, considered Greenland as a possible escape from global Warming. I've no I dea what is involved in immigration to Greenland

Don't go. Great in the winter, if you like astonishingly cold temperatures - but in the summer it's an absolute midgefest: you'll be eaten alive, and if you're not, you'll shoot yourself to avoid being eaten alive.
 
Don't go. Great in the winter, if you like astonishingly cold temperatures - but in the summer it's an absolute midgefest: you'll be eaten alive, and if you're not, you'll shoot yourself to avoid being eaten alive.
I did not know that. I've heard that the roads are quite bad...
 
I believe we're fucked too, not least because of some of the factors already discussed here, but also worryingly, hardly anyone outside of bio-sciences (with to my knowledge an exception of monbiot) seems to be talking about severe top-soil degradation/erosion due to natural erosion and exacerbated by over use of nitrites, acidification, drought/flooding, removal of hedges to create bigger fields, illegal logging/deforestation etc etc etc etc. Ultimately it's driven by the intense pressure on arable land to feed billions of people (and livestock) imo. We are talking about the planet losing a football field of soil every 5 seconds and even the UN are now talking about losing 10% of crop yields by 2050 (a huge number) and serious crop failiures within 80 to 100 harvests, well within many children's lifetimes. When/if that happens, it shouldn't really need spelling out that we're in deep trouble given that 95% of our food comes from the soil. Everything is connected I guess.
 
I think it is but that doesn't mean nothing should be done. Like if you're crashing a car you'd try to steer it away from a cliff or tree, to minimise your injuries.

The problem is I think we've passed the tipping point where we're masters of our own destiny, where human action can halt emissions. The melting permafrost and methane bubbling out of the Arctic seas suggests to me the even if we stopped our emissions there are a load we cannot deal with. And when the Arctic methane hydrates beneath the sea melt, well, the stars will be right and r'lyeh and great cthulhu will arise to scour the earth
sick!!
 
There will be no significant attempts to limit environmental catastrophe until enough private property has been damaged. Not property owned or used by the impoverished global south of course...but when we have massive flooding as the Thames barrier collapses, there might be something on offer apart from the daily game of handwringo. The solutions are unpalatable to everyone who has gotten used to driving around, flying off on holiday and expecting energy at the flick of a switch.
This is the problem i think. The powers that be realise people are energy hogs who expect power at the flick of a switch 24/7 and 365 and won’t accept anything less. So fuck ‘em. Make hay while the sun shines.
 
I wonder if this issue is having an influence on immigration and border policies in the Northern developed temperate zone countries. Trump‘s wall or sending people to Rwanda. Because when it really kicks in people will head away from the equator out of necessity.
 
Back
Top Bottom